Speaking for myself, I want two things
1) P5 conferences to have:
9 game conference schedule,
1 OOC from a MAC-tier conference
2 OOC with other P5 conferences
2) 8 Team playoff, no automatic bids for any conference. No rankings until halfway through the season. This still allows Boise State cinderella stories.
Unfortunately, the above is fairly unrealistic unless the P5 secede from the NCAA.
I am extremely supportive of everything you said. My additions and commentary:
-No more scheduled FCS games, ever. Anyone that does should almost receive downvotes and be removed from playoff consideration.
-9 game conference schedule is an absolute must. Play every team in your conference at least once every three years.
-MAC-tier is almost as good as saying FCS schools at this point. I think on a whole, the MWC and AAC has much better teams than essentially all MAC teams usually every year. If the MAC decides to keep not competing, than these games should be seen as scheduling bona fide cupcakes (like the SEC does every year in November)
-Love the 8 team playoff idea with no automatic play-ins. That allows for both overrepresenting the SEC, as will assuredly happen until the conference comes back down to Earth, and allows for teams on a huge run, like the aforementioned Boise St, Utah, Northern Illinois, and even teams like Marshall, should they "earn it."
-Pre-season or early-season rankings ruin the league. It causes SEVERE imbalances in perception. For example, had there not been any rankings up until last week, nobody would have called wins over South Carolina, Texas A&M, Florida, Mizzou, Stanford, Miami, Louisville, Texas, Oklahoma St, or Texas Tech "QUALITY," but a lot of teams were getting boosted like crazy for beating up early in the season on what ended up being bad or extremely uneven teams at best.
-2 OOC P5 games would be incredible, and something that it looked like the PAC-12 and B1G were heading towards, but everything got screwed up with conference realignments, acquisitions, and so on. Here's hoping they revisit this in the future.