This was one that I thought about but dismissed. They were decent this year, but have not been very good historically. I'd want to see what they do under their next coach before looking there.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
College Football Playoff Thread | Setting A Daggerous Precedent
- Thread starter mre
- Start date
- Status
I think they have routinely been sort of okish and beat Colorado more than they should have given their athletic budgets.
That said, they aren't in Denver which I think sort of makes them a pass.
Cincy/Memphis and UCF are at least in major cities which gives you somewhere worth going on vacation. Cincy especially excites me since I live in NYC. It's not a horrible road trip.
Randolph Freelander
Member
This is the point in the discussion where I again suggest that the Big XII is the only conference right now that's doing anything right. Everybody should play everybody every year. Twice in basketball. Big XII shouldn't change for CFB, Big XII should instead petition for all the other conferences to drop to 10.
Yes, this is, of course, a pipe dream fantasy. :/
Yes, this is, of course, a pipe dream fantasy. :/
That and Swofford was the one who started this in 2003.
Randolph Freelander
Member
He read the tea leaves, but Big XII and SEC were already at 12 at the time. SEC got there, when, in 91 or 92? Whenever they picked up Arkansas and South Carolina.
Edit: There was talk/fantasy in the ACC for years about getting Miami to go along with Florida State, and not many people would have been against it. The total power play to go to 12 was out of left field (for fans), and I've never been pleased with it because of what it did to basketball. The only thing it gained was a football championship game that nobody went to those first few years they held it in Florida, though now in Charlotte, it's starting to draw a bit.
BertramCooper
Banned
Cincy's biggest issue, aside from getting demoted to a secondary conference when the BEAST imploded, is their stadium. Nippert is tiny. 35K people. I think they're planning to expand, but the stadium is surrounded by existing buildings so I don't think it's going to be anything huge.
Not sure how, if at all, that would impact the B12's interest in them, but it's certainly something that will hold Cincy back for the foreseeable future.
Well,
In order to be a decent get we only need a team that is capable of doing what Baylor/Tech do, which is being mediocre at worst and popping up to top 10 once a decade on a lark.
I think Cincy can do that. I would prefer they seat 50K plus however because the Big 12 does have some large fan bases that travel well.
It isn't about the location of the school, it's about the TV "market" they supposedly bring in.
That's why the B1G brought in Rutgers and Maryland even though they're in the most CFB-averse area in the country. Because they can sell networks on bringing in the DC and NYC TV markets even though nobody gives a shit about Rutgers and Maryland football.
"Major" is stretching it when it comes to Cincy and Memphis.
Sigh. I miss the old Big 12.
They did, Cinci went all in trying to get in relaignment and played all home games at Paul Brown this year due to the expansion.
Ohio is actually the one state that probably doesn't have enough p5 teams (I guess Louisiana as well).
I don't think NYC/Maryland is truly football averse.
For NYC specifically, It's just NYC is transient just like Atlanta is, we have a ton of college bars for almost every college there is, but no dominant team. The other is that NYC bandwagons like no other, if Rutgers was the best team in the country everybody would be wearing a Rutgers hat, just like they took off their Syracuse bball hats for their Uconn ones, and sometimes wear their Duke ones if they win.
Rutgers/Maryland was also brought in because the states have football talent, that was going away to other states, and they also had a ton of tOSU/Michigan alumni. This was all about making those two schools and PSU stronger (PSU wanted eastern partners for a long long long long time).
BertramCooper
Banned
They'd really be better off just making Paul Brown their home permanent home venue. It would be a lousy college stadium, of course, but it would a lot easier and cheaper than trying to make Nippert a legit stadium.
The Bungals probably wouldn't be thrilled about it, but they don't own the stadium, so they probably couldn't stop it.
Ohio has the perfect number of P5 teams.
That said, no one is legitimately afraid of Cincy rivaling Ohio State, even if they get back in a power conference. The Kelly years were a sham and no sane recruit is ever going to pick Cincinnati over Ohio State.
Won't speak for Memphis, but it's not a stretch to call Cincy a major city. The city proper is shrinking, like many other Rust Belt cities, but the metro area is 2 million+.
For the population and the amount of Div 1 talent that Ohio produces it makes more sense for Ohio to have 2 FBS teams than Iowa/Kansas/Michigan having 2, and North Carolina having 4.
edit. (I do understand alot of Ohio talent goes to ND and Michigan).
bucknuticus
Member
Without Further Ado, here are your conference picks updates, we still have the remainder playoffs to get through. (also cant figure out how to format this shit on here so there thats):
For a breakdown of everyones picks or you see errors here is the link:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Jg3zBUY9QGEJqdutWo5teIxbhJgiulQ00AWB12UxCQw/edit?usp=sharing
Scoring worked as following 1 pt for division, 2 for conf champ, 3 for playoff, 5 for champ game selections, and 7 points for National Champion.
Total Possible points for regular season was 20 points and 12 for playoffs.
Conference Picks/ Playoff Picks/ Total
RHFB 15/ 12/ 27
FelixOrion 14/ 12/ 26
Ron Paul 12 /9 /21
AndyCapps 12/ 9/ 21
Enfinit 12 /9 /21
theprodigy 12/ 9/ 21
Mr James 12/ 9/ 21
Cdyhybrid 11/ 9/ 20
Talon 11/ 9/ 20
Mac The Knife 11/ 9/ 20
pxleyes 12/ 6/ 18
Chaos Blade 11/ 6/ 17
Bucknuticus 11/ 6/ 17
Battlezone 10/ 6/ 16
Randolph Free 9/ 6/ 15
zyxwvu4321 9/ 6/ 15
AntoneM 9/ 6/ 15
TimetoKill 8/ 6/ 14
GoldenEye 11/ 3/ 14
StrikerObi 8 /6/ 14
Lonestar 8/ 6/ 14
Cyan 10/ 3/ 13
Chicko1983 7/ 6/ 13
JCX 7/ 6/ 13
Purple Cheeto 6/ 6/ 12
Draconian 6/ 6/ 12
Jhriad 8/ 3/ 11
Ganhyun 4/ 6/ 10
Sotha-Sil 7/ 3/ 10
MR. E 7/ 3/ 10
bachikarn 6/ 3/ 9
Frustrated_Grunt 5/ 3/ 8
Monroeski 5/ 3/ 8
Draxal 2/ 0/ 2
Ag-my001 1/ 0/ 1
For a breakdown of everyones picks or you see errors here is the link:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Jg3zBUY9QGEJqdutWo5teIxbhJgiulQ00AWB12UxCQw/edit?usp=sharing
Scoring worked as following 1 pt for division, 2 for conf champ, 3 for playoff, 5 for champ game selections, and 7 points for National Champion.
Total Possible points for regular season was 20 points and 12 for playoffs.
Conference Picks/ Playoff Picks/ Total
RHFB 15/ 12/ 27
FelixOrion 14/ 12/ 26
Ron Paul 12 /9 /21
AndyCapps 12/ 9/ 21
Enfinit 12 /9 /21
theprodigy 12/ 9/ 21
Mr James 12/ 9/ 21
Cdyhybrid 11/ 9/ 20
Talon 11/ 9/ 20
Mac The Knife 11/ 9/ 20
pxleyes 12/ 6/ 18
Chaos Blade 11/ 6/ 17
Bucknuticus 11/ 6/ 17
Battlezone 10/ 6/ 16
Randolph Free 9/ 6/ 15
zyxwvu4321 9/ 6/ 15
AntoneM 9/ 6/ 15
TimetoKill 8/ 6/ 14
GoldenEye 11/ 3/ 14
StrikerObi 8 /6/ 14
Lonestar 8/ 6/ 14
Cyan 10/ 3/ 13
Chicko1983 7/ 6/ 13
JCX 7/ 6/ 13
Purple Cheeto 6/ 6/ 12
Draconian 6/ 6/ 12
Jhriad 8/ 3/ 11
Ganhyun 4/ 6/ 10
Sotha-Sil 7/ 3/ 10
MR. E 7/ 3/ 10
bachikarn 6/ 3/ 9
Frustrated_Grunt 5/ 3/ 8
Monroeski 5/ 3/ 8
Draxal 2/ 0/ 2
Ag-my001 1/ 0/ 1
bucknuticus
Member
Here's your top 3 just from regular season:
RHFB 15
FelixOrion 14
Ron Paul 12
AndyCapps 12
Enfinit 12
theprodigy 12
Mr James 12
pxleyes 12
And heres your little sisters of the poor:
Ganhyun 4
Draxal 2
Ag-my001 1
Fun Stats:
Only one person picked Ga Tech
Six Picked OSU to win the B1g
No one Picked TCU
Two Players got none of the playoff teams correct
Two players picked all 4 playoff teams right
- Of those two only one has a shot to have a perfect playoff bracket
Only 3 people did not pick FSU to win the ACC
Behind the ACC the 2nd most correct conference was the AAC (due to 3 champions)
Not one person picked the PAC-12 south correctly.
RHFB 15
FelixOrion 14
Ron Paul 12
AndyCapps 12
Enfinit 12
theprodigy 12
Mr James 12
pxleyes 12
And heres your little sisters of the poor:
Ganhyun 4
Draxal 2
Ag-my001 1
Fun Stats:
Only one person picked Ga Tech
Six Picked OSU to win the B1g
No one Picked TCU
Two Players got none of the playoff teams correct
Two players picked all 4 playoff teams right
- Of those two only one has a shot to have a perfect playoff bracket
Only 3 people did not pick FSU to win the ACC
Behind the ACC the 2nd most correct conference was the AAC (due to 3 champions)
Not one person picked the PAC-12 south correctly.
BertramCooper
Banned
We probably would have two P5 programs if Ohio University hadn't been placed in the middle of Bumblefuck two centuries ago.
Otherwise the state of Ohio would have probably developed a more Michigan/Michigan State-type dynamic.
GoldenEye 007
Member
Any conclusions that UCF is a commuter school is about 15 years out of date at this point. We're a residential campus and now another destination campus within the state.
Purple Cheeto
Member
So it turns out the last version of NCAA I own is 12, which allows you to realign conferences but not delete existing conferences and a conference must have at least 4 schools. My plan was to create a couple of 12 team power conferences and make the Mid Majors go to 10 teams. Maybe if I user create some of the schools that moved up?
Gonna plan this out when I get to work. I'm open to bizarro world suggestions though.
Gonna plan this out when I get to work. I'm open to bizarro world suggestions though.
theprodigy
Member
top "3"
not bad for me though, also Alabama/Oregon final seems relatively likely which works out well
Could just be about teaching a lesson, like dropping Baylor due to non-conference scheduling. "Bring us an actual champion next time and we'll consider it," just like "if you had scheduled ANY P5 school you'd have been a few slots higher all year."
The bigger issue than actual size of the market is the amount of the market they deliver, and I don't think that is very large with Cincinnati. The size of their stadium, for example, isn't as much of a concern as the reason why their stadium is so small, which is because they don't have a particularly large and devoted fanbase. Having a lot of students doesn't necessarily equate to having a lot of fans of your football team.
There really aren't any all that great options out there for the Big 12 to add right now. I'd rather the conference hold out and stay at 10 rather than add two schools just for the sake of getting to 12. Really hope they can get a waiver to have a CCG with just 10 teams.
bucknuticus
Member
Becuase people in cincy jump on and off bandwagons of surrounding teams. OSU football fans in the fall, UK/Louisville fans in the winters, and if UC has a decent season hey were fans of them now too!
Sounds exactly like something a commuter school would say.
BertramCooper
Banned
This is true.
If you have a Cincinnati/Texas game, you'll probably get great TV ratings in the Cincy media market, but you better hope there's not an overlap with an Ohio State game.
Because it would get trounced, even if Ohio State is playing someone like Indiana.
bucknuticus
Member
This was your playoff picks:
LSU
Stanford
Oklahoma
MSU
You can see the rest in the link at the top of the rankings.
bucknuticus
Member
Uniforms for the playoff games, love em! going back to the OG grey sleeves!
BertramCooper
Banned
Uniforms for the playoff games, love em! going back to the OG grey sleeves!
OH MY GOD PLEASE KEEP THESE FOREVER.
bucknuticus
Member
This is kind of cool:
The new Nike Pro Combat Hypercool baselayer design pays homage to the legend of former head football coach Woody Hayes. The athletic department saved one of Hayes’ last “chalk board” sessions and enshrined it in Buckeye Football history. The baselayer pattern features a literal print of Woody Hayes' hand written notes for a book he was working on.
The pants just need the scarlet stripe instead of silver and these uniforms would be amazing
The new Nike Pro Combat Hypercool baselayer design pays homage to the legend of former head football coach Woody Hayes. The athletic department saved one of Hayes’ last “chalk board” sessions and enshrined it in Buckeye Football history. The baselayer pattern features a literal print of Woody Hayes' hand written notes for a book he was working on.
The pants just need the scarlet stripe instead of silver and these uniforms would be amazing
NEOPARADIGM
Banned
Black shoulder numbers, meh.
BertramCooper
Banned
Not a huge fan of those, but they're from a past uniform, so they're not a completely random addition.
Nix the black numbers and make these the primary jersey next year. Urban pls.
perfectchaos007
Member
Why is no one mentioning USF as a potential Big 12 candidate?
I know, I know, the SUCK at football right now, but don't they also have one of the largest student bodies in the nation? Also, Florida TV contract. There's potential there.
I know, I know, the SUCK at football right now, but don't they also have one of the largest student bodies in the nation? Also, Florida TV contract. There's potential there.
Because it wouldn't make sense to take them because you don't want to double down in Florida, and UCF is clearly the superior choice of the Florida schools at this point.
All of these potential new members are depressing.
I'm gonna go ahead and just pretend my fantasy conference exists in reality.
Big 12 North:
Nebraska
KSU
KU
Mizzou
OSU
Arkansas
Big 12 South:
OU
Tech
TCU
Texas
Aggy
...
Baylor, I guess.
Frustrated_Grunt
Member
Along with USF attendance being abysmal. I'd think the Big12 would pick a school that gets more fan support.
FelixOrion
Poet Centuriate
picking Nebraska to win the West was my tragic and yet inevitable undoing
*Nebraska shakes fist at Melvin Gordon*
*Melvin Gordon runs over Nebraska for a 30 yard gain*
I think you've done this in the past. Do you have results from previous years? I know I've participated before but have no clue how I finished.
GoldenEye 007
Member
:jnc
I mean. It's really bad over there. To the point we outdrew them at their own home game in Raymond James.
USF has been a mess since they reached #2 in the nation for a week.
FelixOrion
Poet Centuriate
"We just didn't execute!" - Bo
bucknuticus
Member
ill see if i can dig them up
Ohio State class of 2008 over here!quick, how many people here actually went to the university they root for
Uniforms for the playoff games, love em! going back to the OG grey sleeves!
Here are our playoff uniforms:
close up of the diamond swoosh because nothing else is changing.
elephant skin undershirt made up of Bama-related quotes, such as "let me go teabag that sleeping LSU fan"
In unrelated news, Lane Kiffin is your Broyles award winner for top assistant football coach:
perfectchaos007
Member
I'm aware that their program is in the dumps right now, but I'm basing it off potential. Don't they have a pretty large stadium? Being in the Big 12 would give them a much broader recruiting landscape. I could see them becoming decent again and enough fans showing up to their games to sell out 50% of the stadium
Their stadium has a pirate ship! The Big 12 would be fools not to consider them.
Picked the playoff teams, just don't think my Finals prediction will be 100% correct
Although who knows, maybe FSU brings the heat and upsets Oregon?perfectchaos007
Member
wow, so make that 2 shitty teams that poor stadium is hosting. Back when USF was good, so was Tampa Bay. Now both teams are at the bottom of their league
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked