• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

COMICS! |OT| April 2013. Trapped in humorless world, Prankster decides to end it all.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Beth Cyra

Member
Savage Wolverine, for the record, is very pretty, but kinda empty.

Sad to hear about Savage.

I picked up quite a few early WaTXM, but I was thinking of something more focusing on him. I'm honestly not that big a fan of his "students" and I enjoyed the interaction between Wolverine and Beast the best. Most of what I've heard from the series is Wolverine and the other staff continue to take a more backseat role so it kinda kills my desire to read it.
 
Yo, Wolverine and the X-Men has turned to shit. Avoid!!

glPEHLK.png

No
 

Beth Cyra

Member
Yo, Wolverine and the X-Men has turned to shit. Avoid!!

It's not so much qualtiy but the focus on the character. I seem to like alot of stuff that is generally frowned on such as AvX and crazy stuff like Wolverine tanking a nuke. So I could probably get into some of the "weaker" storylines. I just don't give a damn about Omega Kid or Edi and want more Wolverine, Beast, and other Profs.
 
I was the biggest supporter of W&TXM, but even I can't defend this arc.

This current arc is just dragging and I do NOT give a fuck about Dog Logan! I'm disappointed that they got rid of the awesome Kid Gladiator and turned Broo into a rabid beast.

I'm reaaaaaaaaaaally not liking Sharkgirl or Eyeboy. Lame, boring Angel & Beak knockoffs. If they end up getting together... lol. Also, terrible codenames. They sound like Legion cast-offs.

Really, the only fun thing about this arc has been the other new character, Jia Jing. She's got great chemistry with Genesis (Who should be called Kid Apocalypse, btw).
 

Dysun

Member
All three Wolverine books are pretty mediocre right now.

Savage is the worst of the bunch (by far), dont know what to make of Paul Cornell's yet but it's pretty pedestrian. WATXM has its moments
 

Beth Cyra

Member
All three Wolverine books pretty mediocre right now.

Savage is the worst of the bunch, but Paul Cornell's just has no hook yet. WATXM has its moments

This is sad to hear. Admittedly I didn't jump on when I last had the chance because I saw Hulk and Wolverine about to throw down over Cake and it really just made me shake my head.

At least Batwoman has stayed great from what I hear. Don't see much talk about Nightwing on gaf, just Bats, Super, Spider and Hawkeye when I pop in lately.
 
This current arc is just dragging and I do NOT give a fuck about Dog Logan! I'm disappointed that they got rid of the awesome Kid Gladiator and turned Broo into a rabid beast.

I'm reaaaaaaaaaaally not liking Sharkgirl or Eyeboy. Lame, boring Angel & Beak knockoffs. If they end up getting together... lol. Also, terrible codenames. They sound like Legion cast-offs.

Shark Girl? Eyeboy? Oh my god, this sounds worse than the circus arc. HOW IS THAT POSSIBLE?!
 
Well, this seemed easier than finding FF #2...

6c50c75e7a08163aab73bea29f263c38_zps96568b5f.jpg


Also random amazon pick-up just because (shipping cost twice as much as the book, and the book was only $1.75):
31b7473405daf29dc7b615dd8531fd6f_zpsc74144ec.jpg
 
So can any Wolverine fans give me the heads up on Savage Wolverine and Uncanny Avengers?

Haven't been able to pick up any comics for a while, but I really do want to get back into it again and would like to with my favorite character (well him + Nightwing and Batwoman.)

Uncanny Avengers is cash, but if you're wanting a comic that's all about Wolverine being the best at what he does and other stuff like that...it probably won't make you smile.
 
Daredevil end of days gets great reviews, anyone here read it? Worth ordering the hardcover from dcbs for half off?

Heard good things,. People are liking it, but are also hoping the payoff/reveal is satisfying.

Speaking of Daredevil, I read through #22-#25 the other day. So I ordered the first few trades. I was never really a DD fan, but Waid is writing some good shit here.
 

Tizoc

Member
not just Marvel dude. The current crew of writers and editors must all be swinging dicks, unhappily married, or divorced, because there's no such thing as a happy and stable relationship in mainstream comics. Constant drama and love triangles and bullshit. I think they believe that happy and normal relationships are boring, and we want to read about superpowerd lotharios juggling multiple women while being ignored by the "one he truly wants". Narm.

Yeah it's BS, and funny how only Reed and Susan are allowed to have a marriage.

...I should reread the Steph Batgirl run again soon.

Anyone read Aquaman? I was thinking of looking into the series, kind of an impulse thing since he's so badass in Injustice.

Aquaman is good, most everyone here likes the series.

Speaking of Daredevil, I read through #22-#25 the other day. So I ordered the first few trades. I was never really a DD fan, but Waid is writing some good shit here.

You'll be in for a treat, it's my fav. Marvel series and is a really fun series, as opposed to the darker ones previous authors were writing the DD series in.
 
Man if I were a multimillionaire, I'd pay Marvel to get Fraction/Dodson/Dodson or Fraction/Breitweiser/Breitweiser back to doing The Defenders :(

It's cancellation still stings me.
 

Tizoc

Member
Man if I were a multimillionaire, I'd pay Marvel to get Fraction/Dodson/Dodson or Fraction/Breitweiser/Breitweiser back to doing The Defenders :(

It's cancellation still stings me.

Best Defenders series IMO is Keith Giffen & Kevin Maguire.
Mainly because its written in the same style as their Justice League run
 
Yeah, that one was a shame. It was such a fun book, too.

Word, I say we protest!

Best Defenders series IMO is Keith Giffen & Kevin Maguire.
Mainly because its written in the same style as their Justice League run

Can't argue that, but you have to admit, Fraction/Dodson's run was fun as hell. Just seeing Surfer go through all kinds of shapes and get tripped out on ancient Wakandian herbs is just awesome.
 

Tizoc

Member
Word, I say we protest!



Can't argue that, but you have to admit, Fraction/Dodson's run was fun as hell. Just seeing Surfer go through all kinds of shapes and get tripped out on ancient Wakandian herbs is just awesome.

Wait it had Silver Surfer on CRACK?!
Gonna give it a try again and see if I'll like it.
 

ElNarez

Banned
I was on Team Defenders from day one, but let's be honest: every single Defenders run is fucking doomed always. Fearless Defenders is next. The market is never gonna want a book of Marvel second-stringers and bit players doing weird shit around time and space. AND IT'S A FUCKING SHAME AND WE ARE ALL TO BLAME.
 
I was on Team Defenders from day one, but let's be honest: every single Defenders run is fucking doomed always. Fearless Defenders is next. The market is never gonna want a book of Marvel second-stringers and bit players doing weird shit around time and space. AND IT'S A FUCKING SHAME AND WE ARE ALL TO BLAME.

Fearless Defenders is probably going to get canned sooner or later. But it'd be a terrible day if they cancel FF.
 
Wait it had Silver Surfer on CRACK?!
Gonna give it a try again and see if I'll like it.

It was issue 9 I think, I'll look it up in a few and confirm for ya

I was on Team Defenders from day one, but let's be honest: every single Defenders run is fucking doomed always. Fearless Defenders is next. The market is never gonna want a book of Marvel second-stringers and bit players doing weird shit around time and space. AND IT'S A FUCKING SHAME AND WE ARE ALL TO BLAME.

So true, and I don't see Fearless Defenders last past issue 8 to be honest...:(
 

TAJ

Darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that.
Just read Indestructible Hulk #6.
Did Walt Simonson suffer a catastrophic brain injury some time in the last couple decades?
I've never seen anyone's art devolve to that degree. The last few pages look like fan art.
 
I loved Defenders but maaaaan, that Dodson art. I can't deal with those chubby ass characters.

I really loved the Fear Itself: Defenders miniseries. Fractions run was great too, and I have high hopes for the current series, even though it will inevitably die.
 

Acid08

Banned
Just read Indestructible Hulk #6.
Did Walt Simonson suffer a catastrophic brain injury some time in the last couple decades?
I've never seen anyone's art devolve to that degree. The last few pages look like fan art.

whaaaaaaaaaaaaaat
 

Owzers

Member
Morning Glories half off comixology sale....just buy it so you can see what we/people complain/love about it. I am not caught up completely, but initially i loved the book until Spencer got well ahead of himself as to where he was leading the reader, but i've never disliked it.
 
I loved Defenders but maaaaan, that Dodson art. I can't deal with those chubby ass characters.

I really loved the Fear Itself: Defenders miniseries. Fractions run was great too, and I have high hopes for the current series, even though it will inevitably die.

I like Dodson's art granted I'm speaking more specifically on his pin up and cover art stuff than his interior stuff. When he has to be quick to meet his deadlines his art quality absolutely plummets. Just compare cover art for The Defenders versus an actual page. It also doesn't help that his stuff doesn't mesh well with some colorists.

Or better yet compare The Defenders to Songes
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom