• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

COMICS!!! |OT| July 2017 | Princess, I've Seen the Way You Look At Me.

D

Donniewahlberg

Banned
It's a kids/all ages book based off of a cartoon so probably won't interest folks around here, but I saw Dark Horse are publishing an OGN based off of GDT's Trollhunters netflix series. Not sure my love for Del Toro reaches that far but I do really really like this cover by Sienkiewicz, thought it was cool enough to share:

TRLHSV1-CVR-SOL-4X6.jpg
Click to expand...
 
E

ElNarez

Banned
Astonishing X-Men, look. You're trying to pull a very earnest "the focused totality of her psychic powers". That's a risky move. But also, I'm starved for a half-decent X-Men book with the characters I actually like, so, you'll do.
 
B

BenjaminBirdie

Banned
RepairmanJack said:
I've loved his run until issue 23 and keep hoping it turns back. It seems he's given up his more emotionally fueled story for all fluff and fan service with no real substance. 23 good 5 bad isn't exactly a bad ratio.
Click to expand...

Didn't I already systematically dismantle this fan service nonsense? I know you never responded after I added all the detail you apparently required but I thought that was because you'd realized you were wrong.

This is worse than that Swamp Thing issue of Batman.
 
R

RepairmanJack

Member
BenjaminBirdie said:
Didn't I already systematically dismantle this fan service nonsense? I know you never responded after I added all the detail you apparently required but I thought that was because you'd realized you were wrong.

This is worse than that Swamp Thing issue of Batman.
Click to expand...

Maybe I missed the edit or something, I don't remember not responding to anything intentionally. I just can't browse as much with GAF now being blocked at work.

Kite-Man in itself is fan service though. And he is forced into that Swamp Thing issue because he's apparently the only one who can get into a high skyscraper (which is somehow also a slum apartment?) and he just so happened to pawn his kite.
 
D

Donniewahlberg

Banned
Captain Skeleton said:
Nearly everything he does is great.
Click to expand...

Yea, I can getting totally behind that. I'm mostly just joshing Birdie too though, it's way too early for me as a trade reader to say that about Black Hammer but hey, if he's digging it
Birdie is also the master of hype
. Lemiere is really consistently great though, the only thing I really have by him that I feel a little apathetic about is Trillium (which is getting a deluxe HC release lol). He is rule of thumb fantastic though bar the odd superhero book that sounded right but ended up not meshing well with him as a writer. Really enjoying Descender right now.

BenjaminBirdie said:
Speaking of, Joe Golem and Baltimore are the shit why did I wait this long
Click to expand...

Haha they are pretty great, also minor spoiler but did you see recently in the new Golem series
they connected the two?
 
B

BenjaminBirdie

Banned
RepairmanJack said:
Maybe I missed the edit or something, I don't remember not responding to anything intentionally. I just can't browse as much with GAF now being blocked at work.

Kite-Man in itself is fan service though. And he is forced into that Swamp Thing issue because he's apparently the only one who can get into a high skyscraper (which is somehow also a slum apartment?) and he just so happened to pawn his kite.
Click to expand...

THAT IS AN INSANE STATEMENT!

No but seriously Kite Man is an awesome gag. I am actually really legitimately interested in discussing this idea of fan service with you. I fundamentally believe what you think of as fan service is "making comics fun in the context of an ongoing continuity".
 
R

RepairmanJack

Member
BenjaminBirdie said:
THAT IS AN INSANE STATEMENT!

No but seriously Kite Man is an awesome gag. I am actually really legitimately interested in discussing this idea of fan service with you. I fundamentally believe what you think of as fan service is "making comics fun in the context of an ongoing continuity".
Click to expand...

Forcing something into a story as much as possible because people like it. I was fine with him showing up early on and really like him but he is literally forced into that Swamp issue for no other reason than King likes him and fans like him. The story would actually make more sense logically if he wasn't in that story. Swamp things dad is living in a sky scraper slum just for the sake of it being too high to access, kite man sells his main instrument of villainy just because the actual villain needs a way to access said skyscraper slum. There's a difference between fun and cool things being coming from a story and those things being forced into the story and changing it just to get these moments. It completely loses the "cool" for me.
 
D

Donniewahlberg

Banned
Captain Skeleton said:
  1. Essex County
  2. The Underwater Welder
  3. Trillium
  4. The Nobody
  5. Roughneck

Haven't read Sweet Tooth. Royal City is too new.
Click to expand...

Embarrassingly I haven't read Essex County yet lol its been on my list for maybe 4 years and I just never get there. The Underwater Welder and The Nobody are really great though, I love the notes he hits and how authentic he makes that stuff feel, you know he lives in that small town family place, in his heart. Read Sweet Tooth!
 
C

Captain Skeleton

Member
RepairmanJack said:
Forcing something into a story as much as possible because people like it. I was fine with him showing up early on and really like him but he is literally forced into that Swamp issue for no other reason than King likes him and fans like him. The story would actually make more sense logically if he wasn't in that story. Swamp things dad is living in a sky scraper slum just for the sake of it being too high to access, kite man sells his main instrument of villainy just because the actual villain needs a way to access said skyscraper slum. There's a difference between fun and cool things being coming from a story and those things being forced into the story and changing it just to get these moments. It completely loses the "cool" for me.
Click to expand...

It could have been any other supervillian with a flying apparatus but Tom King used Kiteman.

Donniewahlberg said:
Embarrassingly I haven't read Essex County yet lol its been on my list for maybe 4 years and I just never get there. The Underwater Welder and The Nobody are really great though, I love the notes he hits and how authentic he makes that stuff feel, you know he lives in that small town family place, in his heart. Read Sweet Tooth!
Click to expand...

I know I know. I have the first 3 volumes too!
 
R

RepairmanJack

Member
Captain Skeleton said:
It could have been any other supervillian with a flying apparatus but Tom King used Kiteman.



I know I know. I have the first 3 volumes too!
Click to expand...

So you think even if it wasn't Kite-Man it would have still been the same set up? Because everything else is pointless to the actual story other than to involve Kite-Man. Literally he knows the MO of the killer immediately and even reveals later he knew the killer but wanted to confirm it. The set up of it being a high rise and having to fly in the window doesn't matter at all to the story other than to involve Kite-man. That is literally fan service.

To add to this, it's worth noting that this was originally only meant to be half of an issue that also included part of Rooftops. It's be pretty easy to see how this story was basically just the beginning and end with all the kite man stuff added to fill out the issue.
 
B

BenjaminBirdie

Banned
RepairmanJack said:
Forcing something into a story as much as possible because people like it. I was fine with him showing up early on and really like him but he is literally forced into that Swamp issue for no other reason than King likes him and fans like him. The story would actually make more sense logically if he wasn't in that story. Swamp things dad is living in a sky scraper slum just for the sake of it being too high to access, kite man sells his main instrument of villainy just because the actual villain needs a way to access said skyscraper slum. There's a difference between fun and cool things being coming from a story and those things being forced into the story and changing it just to get these moments. It completely loses the "cool" for me.
Click to expand...

I think that's the core disagreement. I don't think it's forced for the audience. I think it's there because HE thinks it's great. It's cool that you don't dig it, but I guess I just have a real problem with calling it fan service.
 
C

Captain Skeleton

Member
RepairmanJack said:
So you think even if it wasn't Kite-Man it would have still been the same set up? Because everything else is pointless to the actual story other than to involve Kite-Man. Literally he knows the MO of the killer immediately and even reveals later he knew the killer but wanted to confirm it. The set up of it being a high rise and having to fly in the window doesn't matter at all to the story other than to involve Kite-man. That is literally fan service.
Click to expand...

Swamp Thing can travel through the earth. If you wanted to stay as far away from swamp thing as you can, what do you do? Unless you are Bruce or Lex you can't go live in space. Unless can't live in the country so you have to live in the city, lots of concrete. But you still get parks and green spots so you go up. But penthouse flats are a lot of money.

So now you have a man who is a hermit and lives in a high rise, how do you get to him?
 
R

RepairmanJack

Member
BenjaminBirdie said:
I think that's the core disagreement. I don't think it's forced for the audience. I think it's there because HE thinks it's great. It's cool that you don't dig it, but I guess I just have a real problem with calling it fan service.
Click to expand...

The only time I would ever really call it that is in 23. It totally seems like that whole story just adds a complete detour for no other reason than to add KM.

Captain Skeleton said:
Swamp Thing can travel through the earth. If you wanted to stay as far away from swamp thing as you can, what do you do? Unless you are Bruce or Lex you can't go live in space. Unless can't live in the country so you have to live in the city, lots of concrete. But you still get parks and green spots so you go up. But penthouse flats are a lot of money.

So now you have a man who is a hermit and lives in a high rise, how do you get to him?
Click to expand...

What? The character is his dad and wasn't hiding from Swamp Thing. The killer even finds out who he is because he's constantly bragging about being his father and knowing him and his super hero buddies which is the killers whole motivation to kill him.
 
C

Captain Skeleton

Member
RepairmanJack said:
The only time I would ever really call it that is in 23. It totally seems like that whole story just adds a complete detour for no other reason than to add KM.



What? The character is his dad and wasn't hiding from Swamp Thing. The killer even finds out who he is because he's constantly bragging about being his father and knowing him and his super hero buddies which is the killers whole motivation to kill him.
Click to expand...

Yeah I can barely remember what happens in that issue I'm just going off what you're saying.
 
Aizo

Aizo

Banned
Welp. Back into this thread where it's safe. I accidentally got a few people banned.

Picked up Wild Storm 6, Batman 27, and Aliens Dead Orbit 3 (preorder discount). Looking forward to Wild Storm the most :)
 
Aizo

Aizo

Banned
The fight at the beginning of Wild Storm 6. Goodness.
Captain Skeleton said:
What did you do?
Click to expand...
I made a thread about my opinion on something I felt was creepy in a Japanese game, and then the discussion went to real world Japan, so I talked about real world shit in Japan. I don't want to derail this thread, so if you wanna take a look, take a look at my posting history to see the thread, but I don't recommend continuing the discussion outside of PMing me haha. The thread was closed and several people were banned.
 
C

Captain Skeleton

Member
Aizo said:
The fight at the beginning of Wild Storm 6. Goodness.

I made a thread about my opinion on something I felt was creepy in a Japanese game, and then the discussion went to real world Japan, so I talked about real world shit in Japan. I don't want to derail this thread, so if you wanna take a look, take a look at my posting history to see the thread, but I don't recommend continuing the discussion outside of PMing me haha. The thread was closed and several people were banned.
Click to expand...

Wow. Some people... BACK TO COMICS!
 
R

RepairmanJack

Member
Checked out the first trade of Hellboy, as I suddenly got an urge to check it out, and I really liked the feel of it. I think the stuff that's dropped and meant to be obvious future plot threads was a little heavy handed but I enjoyed the overall feel of the writing and characters. Gonna keep going on it when I can.
 
M

Messi

Member
Aizo said:
The fight at the beginning of Wild Storm 6. Goodness.

I made a thread about my opinion on something I felt was creepy in a Japanese game, and then the discussion went to real world Japan, so I talked about real world shit in Japan. I don't want to derail this thread, so if you wanna take a look, take a look at my posting history to see the thread, but I don't recommend continuing the discussion outside of PMing me haha. The thread was closed and several people were banned.
Click to expand...

I consider you to be fairly well versed in Japanese culture, possibly even expert in some areas so I can't imagine it was posted with any negative intent.
 
R

RedHoodedOwl

Member
RepairmanJack said:
Checked out the first trade of Hellboy, as I suddenly got an urge to check it out, and I really liked the feel of it. I think the stuff that's dropped and meant to be obvious future plot threads was a little heavy handed but I enjoyed the overall feel of the writing and characters. Gonna keep going on it when I can.
Click to expand...

It's disappointing that I'm only familiar with the movies and the superb animated films.
 
P

Poodlestrike

Banned
Aizo said:
The fight at the beginning of Wild Storm 6. Goodness.

I made a thread about my opinion on something I felt was creepy in a Japanese game, and then the discussion went to real world Japan, so I talked about real world shit in Japan. I don't want to derail this thread, so if you wanna take a look, take a look at my posting history to see the thread, but I don't recommend continuing the discussion outside of PMing me haha. The thread was closed and several people were banned.
Click to expand...

Looking over that thread... some of the replies, jaysus.

You did good.
 
H

Haloid1177

Banned
Can I just read straight through Astonishing X-Men and Uncanny X-Force or is there a whole lot of need to know stuff with them? Cyclops thread in OT got me thinking I should read some X-Men books since I don't think I've read anything with them past the 90s.
 
R

RepairmanJack

Member
After just reading Hellboy and then seeing that GDT Shape of Water trailer, no one can tell that is not an Abe Sapien origin movie. Even the pod he's in is identical.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Lifeless Moon coming to PS5, Xbox Series, PS4, and Xbox One on July 9
News
0
544
Thick Thighs Save Lives replied
Coming to Game Pass: Neon White, Flock, Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl 2, and More
39
2K
Punished Miku replied
  • Locked
Coming to Game Pass: Neon White, Flock, Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl 2, and More
News
17
1K
Stafford replied
Magical Delicacy - Release Date Trailer | Launches July 16 on Xbox, PC, Switch and Game Pass
News Trailer
0
484
Thick Thighs Save Lives replied
Coming to Xbox Game Pass: Venba, The Wandering Village, Serious Sam: Siberian Mayhem, and More
News 2
77
5K
Magic Carpet replied
Top Bottom