• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

COMICS |OT| September 2016. Comics Should Be Good.

Messi

Member
The 2016 ComicGaf All-New All-Different Awards

Quote and fill in your votes! ANAD only

Best new character: Gwenpool
Best new version of a classic character: Laura as Wolverine
Most heroic hero: Thor
Most villainous villain: Axel Alonso
Best team-up: Power Man and Iron Fist
Most underrated title: Spider-Woman or Sam Wilson
Most outrageous cancellation: Angela always and forever. Or Mockingbird.
Best arc: Visions first arc
Best solo series: Black Widow
Best team series: Power Man and Iron Fist
Best series: Black Widow



...sometimes I go a bit over the top

There you go.

I find Jane's plight in Thor to be very sad but also very noble. It's a horrible situation she is in but she is still trying to be a hero. No one is even close to her for me.
 
Off the top of my head:
Kraven hunting a child in Standoff
Black Panther pulling out a Hulk Buster
Bruce Banner finally being free of his curse before he died
Steve reclaiming his youth
Sam Humphries going DC exclusive
Galactus fighting the abstract entities
 

Brian Fellows

Pete Carroll Owns Me
The WicDiv 1831 One Shot was super boring.

Luckily I followed it it up with what might have been my favorite issue of I Hate Fairyland to date.
 

Sandfox

Member
In terms of notable moments I forgot about
Night Thrasher returning
lol. The entirety of the previous Sam Wilson issue as well simply for the race and political issues it handled perfectly

EDIT: made some changes to my list.

Best new character:Gwenpool
Best new version of a classic character: Wolverine
Most heroic hero: Sam Wilson
Most villainous villain: Maria Hill
Best team-up: Gwenpool and Miles
Most underrated title: Unbelievable Gwenpool
Most outrageous cancellation: Contest of Champions
Best arc: Black Widow's first arc
Best solo series: Old Man Logan
Best team series: Uncanny Avengers
Best series: Power Man and Iron Fist

This was actually pretty hard to narrow down because there are a lot of books and characters I feel deserve recognition.
 
There you go.

Thank you Messi <3

The 2016 ComicGaf All-New All-Different Awards

Quote and fill in your votes! ANAD only

Best new character: Virginia (The Vision)
Best new version of a classic character: Jane Foster, Thor (The Mighty Thor)
Most heroic hero: Sam Wilson (Captain America)
Most villainous villain: Pymtron (Uncanny Avengers)
Best team-up: Gwenpool & Spider-Man (Gwenpool)
Most underrated title: Spider-Woman
Most outrageous cancellation: Nighthawk
Best arc: Welcome to New Egypt (Moon Knight)
Best solo series: The Vision
Best team series: Ultimates
Best series: The Vision
 

Messi

Member
The WicDiv 1831 One Shot was super boring.

Luckily I followed it it up with what might have been my favorite issue of I Hate Fairyland to date.

The cursing thing bothers me. The changing of words to hide it. Then he has covers that say fuck fairyland on them.

How did I forget Virginia and Viv for new character. Still Gwenpool but I want them recognized. Virginia is awesome.
 
The 2016 ComicGaf All-New All-Different Awards

Quote and fill in your votes! ANAD only

Best new character: Viv
Best new version of a classic character: Ms. Marvel
Most heroic hero: Ms. Marvel
Most villainous villain: Axel Alonso
Best team-up: Power Man and Iron Fist
Most underrated title: Silver Surfer
Most outrageous cancellation: Mockingbird
Best arc: Vision Arc 1
Best solo series: Ms. Marvel
Best team series: Power Man and Iron Fist
Best series: Ms. Marvel

...sometimes I go a bit over the top

I am all about dat Kamala Khan.
 
The 2016 ComicGaf All-New All-Different Awards

Quote and fill in your votes! ANAD only

Best new character: Nadia Pym
Best new version of a classic character: Nadia Pym
Most heroic hero: Thor (Jane Foster)
Most villainous villain: Apocalypse
Best team-up: The New Avengers and Avengers 2099
Most underrated title: The Illuminati
Most outrageous cancellation: The Illuminati
Best arc: Moon Knight's first arc
Best solo series: Old Man Logan
Best team series: The New Avengers
Best series: The Mighty Thor



...sometimes I go a bit over the top

Oh goddamnit this is hard. THERE'S TOO MANY THINGS I LOVE
 

PsychBat!

Banned
Obviously because there is no biggest scumbag category.

j91V0P.gif
 

Brian Fellows

Pete Carroll Owns Me
Best new character: Wolverine's Sisters
Best new version of a classic character: Laura as Wolverine
Most heroic hero: Mockingbird
Most villainous villain: Madcap
Best team-up: Spider-Woman, Captain Marvel, She Hulk, Hellcat, and Hawkeye
Most underrated title: Deadpool and The Mercs for Money
Most outrageous cancellation: Mockingbird
Best arc: Spider-Woman
Best solo series: Spider-Woman
Best team series: Uncanny Avengers
Best series: Spider-Woman
 

Sandfox

Member
I love that little guy but not even top five for me

Virginia
Gwenpool
Viv
Gabby
RiRi

I originally had that field as a three way tie between Gwenpool, Nadia, and Gabby.

Best new character: Wolverine's Sisters
Best new version of a classic character: Laura as Wolverine
Most heroic hero: Mockingbird
Most villainous villain: Madcap
Best team-up: Spider-Woman, Captain Marvel, She Hulk, Hellcat, and Hawkeye
Most underrated title: Deadpool and The Mercs for Money
Most outrageous cancellation: Mockingbird
Best arc: Spider-Woman
Best solo series: Spider-Woman
Best team series: Uncanny Avengers
Best series: Spider-Woman
I almost put Madcap as well lol.
 

Messi

Member
Has marvel been having trouble creating new male characters that stick? Lots of new girls in these lists. Which is awesome but I'm just curious
 
Seeing Peter live a life of constant suffering in regards to always having to bounce when he's with Gwen to stop crime I'm convinced BMB is a genius by having Peter reveal his identity to MJ in Ultimate Spider-Man.
 

Sandfox

Member
Has marvel been having trouble creating new male characters that stick? Lots of new girls in these lists. Which is awesome but I'm just curious

ANAD didn't really have all that many new male characters, while it had a ton of female ones.
 

VanWinkle

Member
Marvel needs to stop putting out omnis of their Marvel Now stuff that already HAS OHCs (Daredevil by Waid, Ms. Marvel, Deadpool by Duggan, Hawkeye by Fraction), and spend MORE resources on putting out omnis for their Marvel Now stuff that DOESN'T have OHCs!!
 
There should be a "Best Comeback" category, because USAgent would win that all day.
I think Maria Hill would win that for Pleasant Hill lol.
She should get that for everything ever
Agents of SHIELD so good this season brehs.
Loved the first ep, but it showed signs of something I'm actually tiring of in the show, and that's the Daisy love. There's way too much of it being, "it's all about Daisy!"
 

Messi

Member
Marvel needs to stop putting out omnis of their Marvel Now stuff that already HAS OHCs (Daredevil by Waid, Ms. Marvel, Deadpool by Duggan, Hawkeye by Fraction), and spend MORE resources on putting out omnis for their Marvel Now stuff that DOESN'T have OHCs!!

I'd stop doing omnibuses for shit that isn't finished or a well regarded run. More OHCs. Gimme Vision or Spider-woman in an OHC. Fucking love OHCs.
 

VanWinkle

Member
I'd stop doing omnibuses for shit that isn't finished or a well regarded run. More OHCs. Gimme Vision or Spider-woman in an OHC. Fucking love OHCs.

When it comes to choosing between the OHCs or omnis, I will definitely choose OHCs (unless the omni is cheaper, which usually isn't the case). But I still like omnis and much prefer them over trade paperback/standard-size HCs.

Holding out hope for a Vision OHC. If it isn't solicited by the end of the year I will cave and buy the trades.
 
Top Bottom