The Smoking Bun
Banned
Ash Ketchum is in a coma too, also Finn from Adventure Time and Frankie from Imaginary Friends is an autistic child staring at a snow-globe
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Crazy Harry Potter Theory. Harry Potter is about mental illness.
- Thread starter entremet
- Start date
- Status
Well, you asking for super spoilers.
The one that paints it like this from the beginning is Life on Mars, the UK version. I hear the US version is crazy times.
At least the UK one is watchable because it respects the viewer by providing the plot twist upfront. It is not great but surely it would have sucked if it had been all explained in the last episode.
Messofanego
Banned
Jacob's Ladder
Alan Wake does it brilliantly where it gives you a few minutes of "you know what, that makes sense with what's happened" but that's only chapter 4.
Death Metalist
Member
Ugh, it's that "Pokemon" all in Ash's head theory. Can't things really exist like they are, do they have to have a M. Night Shama-lama-ding-dong twist?
Zomba13
Member
Same. In some cases the author is doing something like this but like, Pokémon isn't a post apocalyptic nuclear future Japan with mutants, Ash isn't in a coma, Squall isn't dead and Harry is a wizard.
Messofanego
Banned
I think the autistic aspect started with Tommy Westphall that I linked to on the first page (
www.escapistmagazine.com/videos/view/the-big-picture/6074-Worlds-Within-Worlds). Maybe someone can find an earlier autistic character that fits this as well.
www.escapistmagazine.com/videos/view/the-big-picture/6074-Worlds-Within-Worlds). Maybe someone can find an earlier autistic character that fits this as well.
yes, which is why it is my favorite "CRAZY theory"
maybe harry just takes way more time to work on people ... maybe after they departure they became even more good ?
The problem with these dumb readings isn't that they're reading too much into it. The problem is they're not reading into it at all.
Man Called Aerodynamics
Member
That's what I thought of too. Great episode.
This kind of after-the-fact "interpretation" just seems like reeeally low-hanging fruit... "It was all a dream." Okay, then what? What does it add to our understanding or appreciation of the work?
TheOnlyOneHeEverFeared
Member
It really is weird how under acknowledged the Dursleys treatment of Harry is in the books. Social services in the muggle world, or someone didn't step in?
And that theory is rubbish she wrote a fucking fantasy book thats it.
And that theory is rubbish she wrote a fucking fantasy book thats it.
We never see Harry returning to the Dursley's, just the last week before leaving at the start of each book.
Maybe he is p well received for the first few days, then the Horcrux kicks in again and it's cinderella time.
MrRudiMentary
Member
I remember when Rowling had to debunk that Harry coming out of the closet when he was eleven to live in a magical world was a metaphor for homosexuality.
Kyleripman
Member
I think a more interesting HP question is whether he was actually (last book spoilers)
I'd have to reread it and see if that holds up, though.
in a literal "limbo" in the last book when he "dies" and sees Dumbledore again, or whether that's a construct of his unconscious mind. IIRC - and it's been a while - I don't think he actually "learns" anything from Dumbledore that he didn't already know or couldn't figure out, which could be what his mind is doing by creating this experience.
That's an interesting interpretation.
I've always wanted to write a Batman story that was in a similar vein. Basically, a schizophrenic goes on a killer spree. Batman, Joker, Penguin, etc are all just his various personalities. The story is from the perspective of Gordan who is trying to solve the crime.
I've always wanted to write a Batman story that was in a similar vein. Basically, a schizophrenic goes on a killer spree. Batman, Joker, Penguin, etc are all just his various personalities. The story is from the perspective of Gordan who is trying to solve the crime.
Admiral Woofington
Member
isn't this just copy/paste of the pokemon theory?
Pai Pai Master
Banned
That's dumb I prefer it being about cool wizards and shit.
way more
Member
Are people just stupider these days or is mediocracy celebrated too much on the internet? Actually I think the problem is people just care about plot points and events, It's the only way such dumb theories can gain any traction.
It's shocking how vapid they can be. It's mad-libs with literary analysis.
It's shocking how vapid they can be. It's mad-libs with literary analysis.
Admiral Woofington
Member
OrlanisWorks
Banned
Harry is a coward. The end.
Kai Dracon
Writing a dinosaur space opera symphony
Interpreting fiction as a metaphor for psychological breakdown ("It was all a hallucination, Billy is in a coma") is really popular. Probably because it's so easy. You can force anything to fit the suggestion that the point of view character in a story is delusional and imagining everything. Because the story is, in fact, fictional! There is no reality to provide facts which back up the veracity of the story.
Of course, it also usually comes off as very forced because much fiction deviates readily from a single character's point of view. Sometimes even stories written 99% in first person.
The popularity of this trick is one reason why I can't fully buy into the "death of the author" concept. You cannot really pretend a specific story is about anything you like without just plain turning your essay into fan fiction.
Of course, it also usually comes off as very forced because much fiction deviates readily from a single character's point of view. Sometimes even stories written 99% in first person.
The popularity of this trick is one reason why I can't fully buy into the "death of the author" concept. You cannot really pretend a specific story is about anything you like without just plain turning your essay into fan fiction.
What about Go Dog Go?
Go Dog Go: 1
Every other piece of fiction: 0
(Yeah, you can make parallels with tons of series to mental illnesses/comas/whatever. But as said earlier in the thread, a majority of the time, said comparisons add nothing to the thematic elements or messages each author is trying to convey.)
Spaced Harrier
Member
Exactly, they were clearly on the holodeck.
And Link is dead in majoras mask!
Batman is commited in arkham and imagines his doctors as super villains!
Nobita is an autistic kid who imagines Doraemon!
The main character from Captain Tsubasa was a legless kid imagining he could play soccer!
Homer has been in a coma since the beer prank!
Finn is in a coma!
Ash is also in a coma!
You're in a coma!
COMAS FOR EVERYONE!
Batman is commited in arkham and imagines his doctors as super villains!
Nobita is an autistic kid who imagines Doraemon!
The main character from Captain Tsubasa was a legless kid imagining he could play soccer!
Homer has been in a coma since the beer prank!
Finn is in a coma!
Ash is also in a coma!
You're in a coma!
COMAS FOR EVERYONE!
Reminds me of this graph
As a writer, this pretty much true.
NHarmonic.
Member
Mind blown.
That would work except for the fact that it was explicitly stated that Petunia became a horrible bitter person because she couldn't get over her dear sister being taken away by the magical world, so to speak.
I found that kinda depressing, she went on to become one of the worst human beings in the world because she loved her sister too much as a kid.
EroticSushi
Member
I seriously hated this about English class. The class that teaches you to overthink every single sentence.Reminds me of this graph
evil solrac v3.0
Member
people in the 21st century just can not accept fantasy it seems. it always has to have a deeper meaning. how sad.
What if the 21st century is a mass shared coma hallucination?
davepoobond
you can't put a price on sparks
Harry Potter is really about the socioeconomical state of the commonfolk of the Holy Roman Empire
Aaron Strife
Banned
No Harry is dead/in a coma and Hogwarts is purgatory/a dream
Standard insanity "fan theory". Wake me up when someone takes a real look at the material, like this guy did: Expecto Patronus: or How the Wizarding World Really Works (Part 1)
Man Called Aerodynamics
Member
It's a basic revenge story for people who think they don't fit in/and or got dealt a bad hand at life. Instead of the rich jock being allowed to break all the rules, the poor nerdy kid get's too!
/the end
/the end
just getting into the spirit of silly analysis, although I'm PARTLY serious
jackissocool
Member
This isn't creative. It's the same garbage hallucination/dream/coma theory that gets said about every single piece of fiction.
Ziltoidia 9
Member
I see that scene at the end where Harry asks if its all in his head as Rowling speaking through Potter, asking if everything was in her head and then Dumbledore talking to her, telling her that it doesn't mean it isn't real. The HP series was huge and I think she was coming to terms with what it all meant. I remember exiting the last movie and people around me saying "That was the end of my childhood."
I don't get why people are so hostile to this. It's an interpretation. It's not saying it's the only interpretation. It's taking a set of facts and discussing them in light of another set of facts. There are lots of other interpretations that both can and should be had. Interpretation is the whole point of art. That's why the artist's intent is usually irrelevant - or ar most just one more interpretation.
You're missing the point. Your teacher is trying to get you to use your mind and think about things.
Reminds me of this graph
You're missing the point. Your teacher is trying to get you to use your mind and think about things.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked