I've played this game about 40 hours in the past week and I'm just astounded by it. I got through most of the main story and am in PL right now. It's an absolutely incredible game. The world, the dialogue, the character design, the artwork, the story, the environmental storytelling, the sidequests, the flexibility in character building, I'm just blown away. It has some jank here and there around the edges, and it has crashed for me a bunch of times (on PS5), but it's an incredible game. Easy 10/10 for me.
In a way it pisses me off that the first thing everyone that is going to come to my mind is some "redemption arc" thing because it really does obscure the fact that CDPR spent years working on this brilliant work of art and it just got ruined.