Just got past to the Boreal Valley and honestly I'm liking this game less and less the more I play. I really wish they hadn't tried for the pseudo-Bloodborne style combat because it just makes every encounter bland. Like 90% of my combat is me dodge-rolling into my enemies attacks then hitting their backside. Also the level design is kind of... whatever, it's relatively linear yet doesn't quite feel as organic as something like Bloodborne, particularly due to the overly generous bonfire placement. I find myself running past a lot of enemies because so many of them are just so annoying to fight, like pretty much every single enemy in the Catacombs. Just awful.
I also can't tell if I'm imagining things or if the enemy variety in this game really is lacking as much as it seems. Like, okay so I beat the Abyss Watchers, aka fast athletic dudes with large weapons. I then go into the Catacombs filled with fast athletic dudes with large weapons. Then, finally I reach the Boreal Valley and the first enemy I encounter is... a fast, athletic dude with a large weapon. I want to fight some goddamn monsters not yet another humanoid guy with a weapon.
I'm actually debating if I should keep on playing or not. I've beaten Demon's Souls, Dark Souls, and Bloodborne (no DLC though) and this is by far the worst of those three. I have SotFS and I'm debating if I could pick that up or not.