Again, you're thinking it in black and white terms. Sure, yes, in some weird ideal world you will always lose 1/2 your games even in the short term. But this isn't an ideal world and you're not going to lose 2 games just because you said I only want to play 4 today.
Winning 9 games in a row should be hard, for anybody. And yes, you will lose more often, but because you lost to your equals and not because you just happened to get matched against people who would clearly trounce you. If you lose to your equals it's because you played poorly for how you should be playing at your skill level. Beat them by playing smarter and better. This isn't a black/white game of chance. There are more variables than just "50/50 guess I lose this time."
It does not work - it killed COD AW community - skill based match making with me as KD of 2 all games I got where people > 500 miles away... clan of 20 and we all left. COD lost many players.
I never got games with UK players at peak time on Ps4 ...and UK has massive install base.
That's why I play destiny - I just want games where I play and people are not lagging all over the map.
Skill based match making ONLY works if you have LOCAL DEDICATED SERVERS. COD AW is basically who is on the good side of LAG, and the lag is real in every single game as the game server searches for similar players from Greece, Poland, France, UK, Spain, Italy...and its SHIT.
Otherwise every game should be based on PING to the host, as primary, secondary and tertiary.
Otherwise at 30 FPS the game is CRAP for many players, the only ones that benefit are the people with the average KD.
And then the reverse boosting starts, get killed all week and then wreck in trials. That what happens in COD...
They started banning people for killing themselves. It was an epidemic.
Destiny did it right, its based on Connection for trials of OSIRIS.
and it should be. Games have to be local to be fair otherwise you spend you time shooting where players used to be, getting shot round corners...shudders at what COD has become. If it had local only match making I would still be playing...but COD is dead to me.
And what KD do you use to match with a party ? Will the KD 0.5 players want to play with a 3 KD player anymore....?
Split up friends by KD ? Just no. NO.
Destiny is a social game - I want to play with others I enjoy playing with, imagine if they said sorry you cant join us we are all KD 0.7 we don't want a good player to join us who gets to light house every week.