I'm really let down by the Trials changes. These are my impressions from watching GAF and reddit for the past week.
Luke made the point that a lot of us raiders are having problems, but that we're the 1% of the 1%, implying the system is set up for everyone, not just us. But I feel like the Trials changes were made for the 1% of the 1%. Everyone I see liking the Trials changes seems to be someone who was already consistently making it to the Lighthouse in Year One. They like how it's sweatier and not a guarantee. But for those of us who didn't make it to the Lighthouse 3x, every week, like me, well, it feels like the rug got yanked out from under me.
I'd say I'm a top 20% PvP guy. I got carried to the Lighthouse Year 1, but I honestly felt that if I kept my head down and practiced and learned I could go back again without a carry. Now the Lighthouse feels an order of magnitude harder. There are guys bragging on r/CruciblePlaybook about gatekeeping and being the final boss to keep people from the Lighthouse and that's just so frustrating. I love Sherpa-ing people through raids and helping friends wherever they're stuck. This is the exact opposite of that. Carries won't be a thing like last year, but also teams aren't going to take chances on new guys.
Trials gear is more attainable through bounties, but that makes it feel like there's "real Trials" and there's "bounty Trials". Real Trials is for teams of solid players who play every week and won't take a new guy. "Bounty Trials" is for scrubbing it up. There's not a spot for a new non-experienced guy who wants to try a serious ticket.
In a broader way, it's disappointing to see folks I look up to in Trials down on the mode as well. People excited about the mode and wanting to include others is what got me to get into Trials in the first place. Unstable is quitting. Drizz & Ape are downbeat, etc.
Mark Noseworthy and Luke made a big point about trying to make Destiny's community less-exclusionary. That's one of the reasons the light system is so granular, so that people aren't seperated by big gaps from one piece of armor. Trials was already incredibly tough, and they just made it more exclusionary.
It was such an amazing feeling for Drizz and Rubenov to say to me "I believe we can go to the Lighthouse together." That people believed in my potential. But that won't happen this year.
You can argue I'm too focused on Mercury and the new system is better for low(er) skilled players. But I feel like that's saying I'm too focused on beating the Raid and should content myself with beating everything through the Daughters. That beating Oryx is only for the best of the best. Wouldn't you want to beat Oryx? (I know, I know, PvP and PvE are different. PvE is a known encounter and is a gear check, etc.)
The point is: the Lighthouse was so special and I wanted to believe I could get there without a carry. But now I feel like that won't happen ever.