Time to post final thoughts while the servers are currently down!
I clearly enjoy the game to some extent as I have about 130 or so hours in, but with that said I think I want to like the game more than I actually do. There's a core game here that can be super impressive, and similar to what's happened with Diablo 3 I think that after some time with patches and content updates (although let's not get into how much of that may be paid...) it could genuinely be a great game. I will be avidly following the thread and updates and notes from Bungie, but will be dropping the version I'm currently playing (360) until I can get a PS4, hopefully in the next few months.
The general and biggest complaints of extreme repetition, lack of content and the story being non-existent don't bear repeating. But I thought I would post some very specific thoughts I had, many of which are things I feel that they could seemingly address relatively easily.
Bounties
-----
-They need to greatly diversify Bounties; the insane amount of repeats we're getting is ridiculous. If you're going to keep throwing Fallen headshot kills at us, why not at least mix it up with Cabal or Vex headshots? Why not have both PvE and PvP Bounties for kills with weapons that we haven't seen yet (ex. X # of kills with Shotguns in PvE). They've immediately fallen into the shitshow that Halo Reach Daily Challenges were that drove me up the wall with constant repeats, and it's especially bad here since the breadth of possibilities here is way greater than it was in Reach. My crew already has running jokes about the factory making Sepkis Primes.
-Directly related, but they need to put more Bounty beacons in more locations. Completing bounties that take you under the Moon surface or to the end of maps like Venus sucks since you have to either go to orbit or hike way back. You should be able to reasonably keep the bounty train going.
-Stop offering bounties that are literally impossible, like having Bounties the first day of the Queen's even that requires you to wear her items (one of which you can't get until Rank 2 with her), Salvage bounties on days where Salvage isn't even available, etc. How is this even happening, much less continuing???
-Stop offering Bounties that incentivize bad behavior in the Crucible. They had the same problem in Reach as well and it continues here. Since most of my friends refuse to play Crucible anymore I usually have to go in solo, and half of my team is generally useless because they're going 0 and 10 trying to get Sniper headshots for a bounty. That does partially tie in to the Crucible not rewarding you based on how well you play, but it makes the Crucible more infuriating than it already is for me.
-As you're leveling from 1 to 20 you randomly (?) get Bounty Leads at the Postmaster which you can trade in to the Bounty Master for Bounties; why not keep this at post 20? Have it so you can semi-randomly get additional bounties per day in this fashion.
Crucible
-----
-They need to separate PvE and Crucible, at least balance-wise. I can respect their decision to make it all the same thing, but as someone who doesn't really give a damn about the PvP in the game, having weapons I use in PvE be nerfed because of PvP balance is fucking insane.
-They need to at least weight potential rewards based on performance. Right now it just encourages people going AFK since it doesn't matter, and it also encourages people to not try to win so they can complete horseshit Crucible bounties (see above) which actually DO provide tangible and set rewards. I like the idea from someone here (Ghal maybe?) that since there's two item slots in the post-reward screen, have the first item box be guaranteed if you win (maybe with random craftable items like Spinmetal etc) then the second box be a random item with some sort of weighting given to top performers. I definitely agree even if you are the bottom of your team and terrible as long as you are actually playing you should have a chance of getting something, but not at the cost of the person going 25 and 0 and carrying your team to victory getting nothing.
-This is purely a personal complaint, but I've never had the Crucible not be laggy for me. Have zero problems with any other games, or Bungie games in the past, but it's pretty bad for me. I'm seeing practically no one mention the 360 version here is what I'm playing, not sure if that has anything to do with it but it sucks.
Factions
-----
-Have faction reputation either carry across all of your characters, OR let you buy gear for other classes than your current one from the faction vendors. Having my Hunter at Rank 3/4 with all Factions but being unable to buy stuff for my other fresh level 20 characters with all of the marks and rep I have on my main is pretty crappy.
-It's been beaten to death, but the Mark cap is pretty dumb, at least at 200. Additionally they really need to either combine Mark currencies, or let you spend either one at a vendor. For people that don't want to play or are terrible at PvP, it sucks that you can get a Faction up to Rank 2/3+ in PvE but then need PvP marks to buy stuff from them. It's pretty dumb. It makes sense for the Crucible faction obviously, but that's about it.
Misc.
-----
-Patch both an in-game map and zone names in. It doesn't have to be a detailed map, but being able to open up even the map you see when you're in Planet View with zone names on it would be super nice. I still have friends who get lost, and outside of Earth I still don't know most zone names.
-They need to increase rewards for Strikes, most specifically the amount of Rep you get. With the patch increase engram drop rates for Strikes (I virtually always get at least 2 blue engrams on Tiger Strikes) I think that's fine, and 6 marks isn't amazing but for an average of 10-15 minutes that's within reason. But 25 Rep for that amount of time isn't; I don't think it needs a huge bump, but taking it from 25 to 35-40 would about balance it out with how fast you can get Rep by doing Patrols, and would put doing Strikes on fairly equal footing with doing Patrol.
-It's also been beaten to death, but for the love of God patch the Grimoire stuff into the game somehow. Having to navigate their website or app to see where I'm at for in-game challenges is absurd, at least get the Challenge stuff in there (like X kills for Rank 1/2/3 etc) if nothing else.
-what are these load times I don't even