JimboJones
Member
Seems like a very very slight loss in detail or blurring via pssr but the image stability is much better.
PSRR is fantastic
I'd take the image on the right anyday.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
DF - Ratchet and Clank: Rift Apart PS5 Pro vs PS5 Image Quality Face-Off
- Thread starter HeisenbergFX4
- Start date
I'd take the image on the right anyday.
Fbh
Member
Yup.
I think we'll see some bigger differences once the system is out and places like DF can start to freely look at all supported games.
In this pre release period I think Sony is trying to find a way to showcase the improvement of the pro without necessarily shitting on the base model, which is why they focus on relatively old games that already look good on the current console.
They probably want the message to be "this game looks great on the base Ps5 but even better on the Pro" instead of "this game looks like shit on the base Ps5 but great on the Pro"
It's probably why we haven't seen that many third party games showcased either. Third parties just want to sell their games, they don't care on which console so they probably don't want some video that highlights how bad it looks on the more common machine.
semiconscious
Member
The machine is not designed for everyone
Its made for people that want the absolute best place to play console games
Plus its a test bed for devs to get better at PSSR for the PS6
So from all us early adopters to make your PS6 better...
Calm down dude. I'm a huge PS fanboy and I ordered my unit the morning the preorders went live on playstation. I also have the disc drive and stand in my possession in anticipation of the pro.
I've seen a huge difference in some games like ff7r. Ratchet and clank is not one of them.
I feel like insomniac dropping the sharpness on the pro here is not doing it favor in these zoom in shot. In some shot it can even look softer than the performance mode. But overall image stability is much better. It a trade off I guess, but most people like myself prefer the pin sharp image.
The pro cpu essentially is still the same The base ps5, so taking the whole fidelity mode with RT is still not doable because the cpu isn't there.
The pro cpu essentially is still the same The base ps5, so taking the whole fidelity mode with RT is still not doable because the cpu isn't there.
HeisenbergFX4
Gold Member
I am totally fine and don't blame anyone who may or may not buy into this machine, I get both sides
Calm down dude. I'm a huge PS fanboy and I ordered my unit the morning the preorders went live on playstation. I also have the disc drive and stand in my possession in anticipation of the pro.
I've seen a huge difference in some games like ff7r. Ratchet and clank is not one of them.
jonnyp
Member
More than twice the price and can barely see any difference unless you zoom in 300%. I know this isn't optimized for the Pro specifically or a remake. But so far I have seen nothing to make me shell out that kind of money. Sorry Sony, first time since the PS1 I'm not there day 1.
Last edited:
sncvsrtoip
Member
Rift Apart is nothing special but DD2 and Rebirth are real graphics killers
Anchovie123
Member
I expected better from insomniac tbh. There better be at least a significant FPS increase in the unlocked VRR mode.
Joel Was Right
Member
So VRR can negatively affect performance?
Last edited:
Mibu no ookami
Banned
This is an awful video.
He compares Fidelity mode to PS5 Pro Performance mode except one of these runs at 30 fps.
He also misses an obvious opportunity to compare the game running on a 4070 on PC... I wonder why...
Mister Wolf
Member
Rift Apart is nothing special but DD2 and Rebirth are real graphics killers
More impressive than Rift Apart an extremely linear game.
Crispy Gamer
Member
Alex is doing the vs PC video...yeah it wasn't one of Oliver's better videos but the source material wasn't great either with Insomniac providing a relatively meager upgrade
Last edited:
Teh Chosen Juan
Member
anyone else think the fat dude from DF has the most annoying dork voice of all time or is it just me? fucking guy's tongue is too big for his mouth and then BAM! give him a lisp. i just have gemini give me summaries of all the videos now as i can't listen to him.
anyways, looking forward to the Pro!
anyways, looking forward to the Pro!
Gaiff
SBI’s Resident Gaslighter
Because it's a Pro video and should be compared to the regular PS5 as that's the comparison that is the most relevant?
What matters is how it stacks up to the PS5 since that's what it's upgraded from.
Last edited:
Mibu no ookami
Banned
LOL... the amount of milking/farming they're doing on a console they said didn't need to exist is hilarious.
This could easily have been one video.
Comparing performance RT that runs at 40 fps or fidelity that runs at 30 with Pro Performance that runs at 60 is such fools game for an entire video. In one case you're getting double the frame rate and in the other you're getting 1.5x the frame rate, yet nearly the same visuals... largely downplayed in this video by the rare mention of actual framerate... something they're normally hyper fixated on.
Luipadre
Member
Wait until the system is out and you can see the much bigger upgrades like FF7 rebirth... Its sonys fault that their advertisement campaign for this is dogshit
Mibu no ookami
Banned
Insomniac is busy working on Venom and Wolverine. I'm not surprised they're not doing a ton of work for their multitude of games.
They're updating
Spider-Man Remastered
Spider-Man Miles Morales
Ratchet and Clank Rift Apart
Spider-Man 2
That's tremendous work given their busy schedule and how many games need to be updated.
Square Enix updated FF7 Rebirth but where is FF16?
Where is Cyberpunk 2077?
I'm not sure who else is out there updating 4 games.
saintjules
Gold Member
Hopium that Sony will make a 'we hear you' post and then drop the price.
They'll see a difference at $599 with disc drive
Crispy Gamer
Member
I agree it should've been PS5 vs Pro vs PC instead of making 2 videos for an upgrade that's not substantial compared to others we've seen.
It's the difference when compared to a game that on PS5 used a decent resolution scaling method versus when compared to cases where scaling method turned out to be oddly bad despite starting from relatively high base resolutions. Ratchet had a very good IQ unlike FFVII. But not all games on PS5 have an IQ as good as Ratchet and not as bad as FFVII.
I suppose that, as happened in the last generation, the results will be varied and will depend on the circumstances of each game and its particularities.
I suppose that, as happened in the last generation, the results will be varied and will depend on the circumstances of each game and its particularities.
Mibu no ookami
Banned
It's a 4 years old game, it's not going to be massively improved. Comparing it to similarly beefier hardware gives you an idea how how much of hardware boost is involved here.
Making a video on visuals for a 4 year old game while largely ignoring the performance boost is laughable.
Again 1.5x more performative than Performance RT and 2x more performative than Fidelity. That isn't being conveyed sufficiently in this video.
This is a horrible showing for a Pro enhanced game but it’s mostly likely not the fault of the pro. I don’t know what Insomniac is thinking
removed the sharpening pass
New noise and dithering patterns that feed into the RT reflections
Maybe it will look different/better in person but all I’m seeing here is a loss of detail and I never found the old perf RT mode to look bad
The only clear with imo are the particles
removed the sharpening pass
New noise and dithering patterns that feed into the RT reflections
Maybe it will look different/better in person but all I’m seeing here is a loss of detail and I never found the old perf RT mode to look bad
The only clear with imo are the particles
Last edited:
Mibu no ookami
Banned
Not sure how 1.5-2x framerates is meager... We're really moving the goalposts for a midgen refresh now.
Gaiff
SBI’s Resident Gaslighter
That'd just be DLSS vs PSSR. PC settings vs PS5 has already been done.
No, because the Pro's extra GPU performance isn't even being utilized here. They only swapped out IGTI for PSSR. The 45% better rendering and faster RT aren't doing anything. It'd be basically a DLSS vs PSSR comparison.
This game just doesn't have enough improvements to bother visiting again. I'm not even sure why Alex is doing a PC vs PS5 video if he is doing one. There really isn't anything to discuss. It's RT Performance Mode with much better IQ. No need for a 15 minutes video.
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
If you can't see a difference, you're blind.
I mean .. you're kinda proving his point with this.
It's taking a 3X zoomed in image and you still have to pick specific parts of the image to show that there's an improvement. This is barely above PS5/SX comparison differences in this case.
Thebonehead
Gold Member
It's a enhanced version of the Ps5 version that was a remastered version of the PS4 enhanced version that was remastered from the PS3 version.
I think...
Skifi28
Member
Lysandros
Member
Well, it must be said that in this case the direct comparison with PS5 fidelity mode mostly serves to hurt PRO's initial messaging, not the best look. It all comes to down to "If you want to play at 60 FPS, you still have to compromise in IQ/settings but less than before." essentially. There are much more impressive upgrades like F1 2024.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
Literally every DF and PC faceoff thread more often than not.
I wonder why that narrative is now being adopted? Hmmm, wonder what it could be?
Newer and current developed games will have more of an impact as well. They're not going to break the bank on 4 year old games. Just set the PSSR to on and forget it.
No wonder Alex was licking is chops and hyper suggesting this one. Engagement wars.
Last edited:
James Sawyer Ford
Member
Doesn’t matter, as each remastering was taking advantage of the new hardware
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
It's the same narrative in all DF threads. In PC threads the console folks ask about console equivalent comparison while chastising expensive rigs because that exceeds the console price point. On console comparisons it's usually small differences in most cases with some rare games that show notable differences. This is a Pro console, 3x zooms to point out differences is not exactly a good selling point. But I guess it's harder to show performance differences in screenshots.
SkyHighTrees
Member
like someone said above. If they let us use Fidelity mode unlocked on PS5 Pro, it will probably reach 60 fps already.
They are just showing the difference for the PSSR.
They are just showing the difference for the PSSR.
FUBARx89
Member
Nice. Now Sony need to show other games.
PSRR is fantastic
Need to see Silent Hill 2 running on pro. Cause them RT reflections (I presume?) Are dogshit.
A man also dreams of a world where CPDR use it to get rid of the awful ghosting with FSR.
Last edited:
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
The last sentence is the crux. Same with different model graphics cards. The very same PC gamer conundrum, but it will be argued until they're blue in the face, on here and other places.
sncvsrtoip
Member
Rather weak example of pssr here, 40 fps mode on ps5 amateur is still way to play
Senua
Member
mckmas8808
Mckmaster uses MasterCard to buy Slave drives
Mr Moose
Member
Romulus
Member
I think there be like 5-10 games that Pro owners will continually remind us of how great it is, but I see the vast majority just being something no one outside of a super gamer DF type will notice. Super zoom 300% lenses and frame counters needed to tell us its "better."
Not worth it until I see a huge batch of games with stark differences.
Not worth it until I see a huge batch of games with stark differences.
King Dazzar
Member
I keep a log of all my games in a spreadsheet as to what I set them too (TV settings and game settings). And the 120hz mode VRR will mean that its chroma output will be 422 rather than 444 and my TV's image quality is at its best when I dont use VRR too. In my notes I put "With VRR disabled, you can turn on 120hz mode for better latency. But image quality looked better with 120hz off and no VRR. Keep in normal non RT performance mode."
Similar threads
- Locked