Hey I'm open to it.
Shit's fascinating.
Reddit's a craphole.
Aiite I hope this isn't super wall of texty. Also I didn't proofread it cuz it's long and I'm lazy.
What NEL Was
The reason NEL worked and people played it was not just a higher quality of game, especially after RMM came out and high 5k players would have low 4k teammates, NEL gave them a place where your minimum teammates skill would be above 5k so consider that like Match Making with a skill floor. The other reason it worked is it gave random pub players chances to play with pro players, you can name drop them, tell stories of them, get flamed by them, listen and improve with them, and the slim slim chance that you play really well over an extended period of time and get noticed. Not always by a top tier pro like Sumail and EG, but to smaller degrees like BSJ, Ritsu, B9, Jah etc...
Types of Games
NEL had about 2 MM styles, Sign games where you sign and get matched on a team based on your nel rating, and Challenges where there were 2 captains who picked players who signed up, often picking only their friends. With challenges some players, tralf was big on this, would take "value players". A value player is basically just a player with a really low rating, doesn't matter if they are good or bad, you pick them because it skews the points system so a loss only loses you 10 points as opposed to 40, but a win gives you 70. The idea being that you can gain points by losing more games than you win even if your value players cost you a few games. One time I had a pretty decent rating and there was 1 spot left and 4 players, the 3 other players could all be "Value" as they had low ratings and i was like the 3rd highest rated player in this pool because it was probably the 4th or 5th day of the season and Tralf picked me instead of a value player. I did almost nothing and we won, but i felt really good being picked because my rating was higher and i was non-value and Tralf is a known player.
Real Games with Pros
Now within the SG (sign games) there were another 2 types of games. Real games and Reject games. When a pro hosted a game, they normally had a massive forbid list, or if you signed it and they didn't know you they would forbid you from that game to get a friend or known player in. If you did get into that game you pretty much were on thin ice, say the wrong thing, take somebodies core, fuck up too many times, you knew it was going to be harder to stay out of a forbid list and get into another real game. So you end up with a bunch of 5k core spammers playing supports and supporting real support players who notice all of your fuckups and instead of helping you they mostly just shit on you and forbid you. So don't fuck up! Most of the flame is joking however and in good fun. There would be good players, pro players with low ratings because all they played were these real games, most new players got a few shots at these games before ending up on a forbid list for a season, so in comes the reject games.
NEL Reject Games
Reject games are the shit you have to wade through to earn your way back into anybodies good-graces. The best reject games were ones where one team had a good player or pro player who noticed you handled yourself well in this game and might stick up for you in signing a real game or a Challenge game. Most of the time it was just 5 rejects vs 5 rejects, some nel ladder climbers feasted on reject games picking themselves that metas 1v5 hero and massing over a hundred games in the season winning 55% of them but still ending pretty high up in the standings. These are you Zenokaia's, anybody who watches higher mmr streamers or plays in that bracket knows this kind of player. Me, I was just an average reject game player, won a few more than i lost when I played safelane, tried my best as a support, sometimes made it into a real game, sometimes got drafted in challenges.
Why it Died
Players like ixmike88 would honestly be some of the lower skilled player in a reject game, but because he built the league and was a pro at some point he was always in real games, always forbidding players, shit like that. It's his league nothing wrong with it, but he often had some of the lowest point totals for having hundreds of games a season. When FPL came in there is no forbid list and they made it way harder to get in, you pretty much had to be on a team that was in qualifiers for things in NA, or make it thru the FPL qualifier which was a shit-show, a 1 week long tour of old NEL. However FPL basically in my mind ended the reject vs real game, because they cleaned up the player pool there were essentially only real games. People tried to bring back NEL as other NA invite inhouse leagues FAL, NAAL, but these died quickly. They died because it was all reject games with 0 CHANCE TO PLAY A PRO. NEL was about the chance to play with pros, get noticed as I said at the beginning. Without this there is no reason to play an inhouse invite league, it's no different than any other RMM game at that point.
Random Musings About Chat
I also forgot to mention that people who qualified through ixdlo, the open league, to nel were consistently the worst performers. Almost all of them were bottom of the standings because to be honest, beating 3ks, and trolling NEL players in ixdlo is a lot easier than grinding mmr. Most of them were low 4k players who couldnt make 5k, 5.1k, or 5.3k so they got in thru abusing ixdlo challenge system and the low quality of game. Generally within a week of them making it into NEL they were on every single forbid list imaginable, these guys even got rejected by the Reject games. And the chat was mostly joking flames, angry KZZ making valid points about play but argued with calling people apes, complaints about Jubei game ruining, throwing, and spamming GG, and late night Bloody9 AMA's because that guy never sleeps and when he gets tired he gets a little too earnest.
TLDR; Idk it's pretty long read the headers of things you find interesting? Also I was in the last "real" NEL game ever ticketed (some people have been ticketing random games with old nel tickets from march,april and other months), and the league died a true NEL death, with a dire ragequit resulting a radiant win, then the rest of radiant leaving and resulting for 6 in favour of radiant, 4 for dire and a radiant win in a game the entire radiant left
http://www.dotabuff.com/matches/1484601182