I would love to call out Ian sometime.
"So why is it okay for you to play Nier in a way that exploits a certain move to make combat easier, against creators intent probably, but Dark souls and bloodborne aren't allowed to be easier games because of creators intent? What if I don't care about the combat and just want to play for the story/world"
I don't necessarily believe that but I would love to hear his response.
I don't understand your point.
Having that move in Nier WAS author intent, if you want to exploit it, you're free to.
In the same fashion, having many of the exploit in Souls games IS creator intent (aside from the more obviously buggy examples maybe) which also means the developers left those elements in for those who want to exploit them.
I mean, i don't get Ian's fascination with Souls combat myself, i love those games, but i don't think the combat in them is the "end all be all" at all, and i especially don't see what "Nier Automata with Bloodborne combat" even means (i wish Ben had challenged that statement, since we're on that topic, lol).
But i'm not sure what you mean, when you say "
Dark souls and bloodborne aren't allowed to be easier games because of creators intent?"... Platinum's intent was to offer easier ways to get through the game, From's wasn't.
How is that inconsistent?
Honestly that episode of Frame Trap felt like Ian wanted it to be a psychiatrists couch it was filled with so much 'Ian-ness' and projection.
I think you're doing some projecting of your own.
Everybody is aware that Ian's attitude (this or that is trash, Souls make you a better person, etc) is tongue in cheek, he said so himself plenty of times.
I do wish the other allies would push back more in general though, as it has been said in the last page, it would make for more interesting discussions on topics that have been eviscerated plenty of times at this point, but it's not just a Ian thing.
I think the only one that gets significant (and positive) push back for his odd views, is Kyle, probably because he's good at fishing for it.