It's especially ridiculous because Emily Rogers has one of the better track records of any Nintendo insiders but she still gets these "oh, attention-seeking" "oh, more BS" allegations. It's nuts.
Nobody can ever point to why they doubt her either, aside from rumours from years ago or which she had no involvement in. The past few things she's reported on have been right with no strings attached (i.e. they don't involve any backpedalling or sudden revelation of pertinent information that she allegedly knew all along but didn't reveal), so I think it seems fair that she's earned our trust.