• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Fall Anime 2014 lOTl Unlimited Tomino Works

Status
Not open for further replies.

cajunator

Banned
So inferior versions of Boogiepop Phantom, NANA, Tenjho Tenge and Death Note.

Reading ANN's Princess Monoke's BD review makes me sad.



Superior picture quality or non-butchered subtitles. Hm.

I can deal with that. I only watched Princess Mononoke dubbed to begin with.

Fate Zero 7

As much as I hate Saber and wish she'd fucking die because she's an awful, awful concept on every level, is it so much to ask that they let the only female fighter actually win a fucking fight? Every, single, jam that she has been in she's had to be bailed out by a dude.

Gundam X 28: How Not to Write An Interesting Mecha Anime.

Once upon a time not too long ago, I watched an anime called Armored Trooper VOTOMs. Votoms was an amazing show, with a broad range of settings, tight pacing, hilariously large booties, a gripping storyline and an unforgettable cast. It was many things at once: an action movie, a dirty war story, a tale of international crime, a tragic love story, and a heroic journey to vanquish true evil. Votoms was one of the best mecha anime I've ever seen.

One of the show's most rightfully praised arcs is the Kummen Jungle War. As others have put it, "Space Vietnam." The arc follows Chirico's adventure in the middle of a bitter civil war, as well as the introduction of one of his major foes: Ypsilon. The arc is simultaneously remembered for its unflinching depiction of the horrors of jungle warfare and for the political intrigue which surrounded it.



Gundam X is nothing like that at all. Which, I suppose, should be obvious, except that Gundam X carries with it a number of ideas which really ought to be able to make it similar. Like the Kummen Jungle War, this current arc of Gundam X is about a bitter feud between two forces, one of which is backed by a much larger government and military. Traces of ethnic conflict, of fallout from a bigger and bloodier war, and backstage politics are all there in place.

So why is it that Gundam X is so utterly banal when Armored Trooper VOTOMS was one of the best I'd ever seen? Well . . .



1. What happens should matter to the cast. By this I mean that in VOTOMS' little proxy war, everything mattered to everyone somehow. Chirico met up with Fyana and encountered Ypsilon. Fyana began to escape from her masters' grip. Ypsilon's intense jealousy of Chirico began. Vanilla and Coconna's romance began in the bar he opened. Gotho's role as a peacemaker between them and as group financier is challenged from time to time, and his loyalty to Chirico begins to overtake his love of money.

But it isn't just the main characters. The side characters matter, too. Whether it be His Excellency or the guys on Chirico's mercenary squad, all of the side characters introduced are firmly established, developed, and play pivotal roles in the plot. At times making them seem more important than the main cast. After all, it's really -their- war.

This isn't the case in Gundam X, though. By and large, much of what happens doesn't effect the cast in any major way. From time to time a moment is tossed on someone's plate, but for the most part Tiffa Adil, Garrod Ran, Jamil Neate and the Frost Brothers are exactly where they were when they began. Side characters are introduced and slaughtered in a way that you'd normally see in Gundam AGE. Character actions aren't realistic, either. At one point Roybea shacks up with a girl he just met and stays in her home until she's shot in the chest for no discernible reason. The nattering princeling has stumbled from one scene to another, presumably under the pretense of learning to be a manly ruler.

2. What happened was rarely the same thing twice. In VOTOMS' arc, the team would sortie every day and fight in the jungles. But it was usually a new mission every time. Whether we were watching Chirico and Kan Yu beat each other senseless in the rain and muck, or a raid on a temple harboring insurgents, or watching Chirico fail to persuade Fyana to join him, no episode was dull.

In the Gundam X version of events, though, that's not going to happen. Virtually everything I can think to complain about is centered on the fact that the show has been caught in a quagmire of Monsters of the Week for four episodes now, meaning that the bulk of this war has just been "New prototype mobile suit piloted by yet another cliched nutbag is sent by the Frost Brothers to fail to kill Garrod while they act as positively incestuous as they can in a kid's show." Lather. Rinse. Repeat.

3.The writers took the time to explain things. The New Federation has been around for around ten episodes in Gundam X at this point, if not more, and its been made very, very clear that we're supposed to see it as the ultimate evil.

Except that it hasn't done anything evil yet at all. Oh, sure, it has done some weapon testing, and it has conquered some countries, but the show out and out tells you that this New Federation is made of the remnants of the Old Federation. The Old Federation owned those weapons anyway and had legal control of the entire war. Although there was a giant catastrophe, that doesn't mean that the Federation's right to world governance is rescinded, and it certainly doesn't remove the Federation's right to its own weapons.

The show just assumes that I'm some Zeon loving ass who automatically feels that the New Federation has to be evil. Its never explained. The Frost Brother's motives were brought up exactly once and have since never been expounded upon or clarified by any of their actions. Perhaps the show wanted to ride the Evangelion wave of vague = cool, but no matter the motivations, the end result is a conflict without stakes because there has been neither emotional nor logical build up of why either side should be rooted for.

And don't mistake this as a "neither side is right, because war is grey!" scenario, either. The New Federation is clearly viewed as evil, being attached with such stupid villain trappings as testing new weapons on their own men and employing sociopaths, but all of these things only crop up in the vicinity of the marvelously inept Frost Brothers, and never in connection with New Federation personnel.

Meanwhile, VOTOMS treated this war as a matter of great complexity, but with surprising clarity. The Prince had rebelled against the King, espousing the Old Ways, when his nation had made moves toward the new. The kingdom was aligned with the Gilgamesh government, the rebels with the Secret Society. Both sides were awful but employed good people. The final battle revealed the entire rebellion an elaborate set up to ensure that the Old Ways died for good. Adherents were rightfully dismayed, and many people's lives ended in frustration, but all of it was meaningful in establishing the overall tone and message of the arc. No longer was Chirico just someone who'd fought an off-screen war. We'd seen firsthand what war did to him, and to others.

Nobody had to stand around and look forlorn while someone browbeat the audience about how bad war is, because the audience saw first hand the sheer volume of horrors war created.

4. There was presentation. This isn't related to the writing, but as a final kick to Gundam X's nads, it's a damn shame that an anime as much older than it as VOTOMS looks so much better. Nothing in Gundam X looks good. It may well be the shittiest and ugliest looking Gundam series I've ever watched. And yes, I am including Hirai faces in that. Somehow, Gundam X has uglier fucking faces than either SEED or Destiny.



I mean shit, just look at that face. No wonder this show got cancelled. It's like some kind of freak show, but lazier.

regarding Saber in FZ, remember that
she was severely limited by that spell on her arm
Eventually she loses that but it was probably too late in the series.
Saber in FZ was actually largely irrelevant.

So I started watching Ashita no Nadja, not sure what to think of it yet. But the important part here is that everyone should be familiar with the impossibly cute ED, directed by Mamoru Hosoda no less.

Hosoda was really good with OPs/EDs it seems. The Samurai Champloo OP is also from him, and his own OP for Nadja is very nice too.

Yes it does have an adorable ED!
 

Midonin

Member
Aikatsu! Akari Generation 110

"Akari Generation" is the proper term for this part of the show according to the DVD listings, so I shall use it. Juri's first Premium Dress reminded me of the Spain arc of Nadja, only less harsh. I love her first original song, too. The Loli-Gothic songs remain my favorite, but any idol whose music heavily plays into a certain genre type is going to stand out a bit more. Juri's a fun addition to the cast. Her Cinderella-themed dress is an interesting fit with her persona, not the first fairy tale I would've thought of, but it works. This season is off to a great start.
 

JCG

Member
Yoshino did work on Guilty crown and Okuchi help out some.

Yeah, Guilty Crown was mostly Yoshino's work with Okouchi contributing on the side. That said, one problem is Araki is still too green as a director when it comes to making anime original projects, rather than those based on already successful manga properties (Death Note, Attack on Titan, Highschool of the Dead). Which, among other issues, makes the writing flaws more transparent. I have no clue concerning how this upcoming show is going to turn out, much less what's it about, but unless he's learned from the mistakes of Guilty Crown I'm not going to look for it on my radar.
 
881043oakwp.jpg
881046dbkk0.jpg
Less than 2 weeks until Date A Live Encore 3 and the Kurumi OVA. I'm as ready as I'll ever be, i.e. not ready in the slightest and drooling like I've just been lobotomised.

The Encore 3 cover'll show her with both hair 'down' and left eye uncovered, which is a real rarity for Tsunako art:

 

CorvoSol

Member

39 episodes of this.

I'm not even on Corvo's #TeamSuzaku, for whatever that's worth, but the character is quite interesting when you can dispassionately look at why he acts the way he does...including both where he started before the events of the show and where he ends up. It's too bad he's also often listed among the easiest to hate, though certainly not surprising given the whole setup.

#TEAMSUZAKU
#SUZAKUWASRIGHT
###
 
regarding Saber in FZ, remember that
she was severely limited by that spell on her arm
Eventually she loses that but it was probably too late in the series.
Saber in FZ was actually largely irrelevant.

Yeah, her role in F/SN to my knowledge is much bigger than it is in F/Z. Not that I'd ask Corvo to watch F/SN though.

But even so, Saber does get a really good shining moment later on once
the curse on her arm is lifted.

More known as Shirobako's day.

More like Yuki Yuna YUUSHA OH! day.

#TEAMSUZAKU
#SUZAKUWASRIGHT
###

#TeamOrange.
 

CorvoSol

Member
regarding Saber in FZ, remember that
she was severely limited by that spell on her arm
Eventually she loses that but it was probably too late in the series.
Saber in FZ was actually largely irrelevant.

I'll grant that her
arm got messed up,
but that in and of itself is part of what bugs me. They
crippled
the only female fighter from the start.
 

Midonin

Member
Denki-Gai 09

So many anime are going to start getting into the Christmas spirit. Denki-Gai, of course, celebrates it in the most perverted, anime culture-esque way possible, and I wouldn't have it any other way. The romantic elements with Hiotan and Sensei were also cute, especially the part where Sensei was messing around with Hiotan's laundry and was mystified by her
older sister's
underwear. G-Men's moment was also fantastic. Santa on a motorbike distributing porn for Christmas. Oh what fun it is to be in Akiba!
 
Parasyte 9:
WHAT THE FUCK? Is this the dumbest character in any horror story ever?
I was even ready to praise her for actually going to her brother and confirming about the monster's who could change faces, but then rather than saying anything about it, she's like 'well, I should talk to him first'. Who the hell does that? Worst character ever.
Just when you thought the female characters in Parasyte couldn't be portrayed any worse, this episode happened.

I do enjoy the speed the plot is moving at, and how Shinichi is kind of showing us a guy who gets superpowers but becomes a sociopath in the process, but a lot of this stuff is really frustrating me. That's to say nothing of the melodrama involved with
Shimada picking a fight with the punks at the exact same time Shinichi was trying to set things straight with Murano.

Parasyte had a lot of promise at the start, but I think that some of that has really evaporated over the last few episodes.
 

madp

The Light of El Cantare
Wow, that Moyashimon S3 trailer looks great. It's one of the greatest success stories of the anime industry that noitaminA has managed to retain their commitment to producing offbeat seinen programming after all these years.
 
Gintama 015


Talk about selling the bear's skin before one has killed the beast. :p

A pretty standard Japanese game show in this episode then... Maybe they should have waited with the new ED until the end of this one.
 
Parasyte 9:
I do enjoy the speed the plot is moving at, and how Shinichi is kind of showing us a guy who gets superpowers but becomes a sociopath in the process, but a lot of this stuff is really frustrating me. That's to say nothing of the melodrama involved with
Shimada picking a fight with the punks at the exact same time Shinichi was trying to set things straight with Murano.

Meh, school was over so it's not really much of a stretch that this would occur at the same time. Not like it would've been much different if he cursed and ran off a minute or two later either when walking back with her.
 

Midonin

Member
Shirobako 08

Not this show, nor WUG, is ever all about "suffering". Ema can find hope and the potential for the future as much as anybody else. Her emotional setback was real, but the ability to overcome that hurdle is real, too. I also want to take this chance to mention that there's a manga spinoff being published that focuses on the girls' animation club during their high school days. I'd be interested in someone translating it, because it could probably shed more insight on what the girls are like today. I think that may be a potential goal for the second half of the show - to create that anime with all five members of their club. Office life isn't going to be fun even if it's somewhere like where Kaori is working, but human relationships can save everything, as well as learning from the best.

I would like to see more of the VAs and writing side of things, but I'm enjoying this for what it says about creativity. I also can't wait to watch the first episode of Exodus when it arrives as DVD extra. It'll be many things, but "generic" is not going to be one of them. Just like this show, and many other shows, this season.
 

Clov

Member
I feel like it's been dead before, but this time seems worse. Pretty much everything looks like garbage.

The Perfect Insider seems cool from its description, but yeah, everything else seems pretty bad. They've been more or less like any other TV block showing late night anime for a while now. It's pretty sad to me, since a lot of my favorite anime came from noitaminA. Hopefully they'll find their way again; we had Ping-Pong this year, so maybe something as good as it will eventually make its way to it.
 

Acosta

Member
Less than 2 weeks until Date A Live Encore 3 and the Kurumi OVA. I'm as ready as I'll ever be, i.e. not ready in the slightest and drooling like I've just been lobotomised.

The Encore 3 cover'll show her with both hair 'down' and left eye uncovered, which is a real rarity for Tsunako art:

I am (not) ready.
 
Shirobako 8:
Another great episode. Iguchi's advice to Ema was pretty good, and I really enjoyed the scenes of them walking together, as well as some of the flashbacks from Iguchi learning how to animate. It's pretty good advice for anyone trying to get better in a specific field. Kaori's scenes from at her job were good, too. Seems like a place that would really wear down on you.

Tarou was barely in this episode, but he still found plenty of time to be just as unlikable as ever. And his goals were put out there in such an asshole way. It's interesting to see the different goals that each person has. It gives what everyone is doing a little more meaning.

Also, that mental image of Honda in the apron. The eyes will never be clean again.
 

Midonin

Member
Kokoro Library 08-10

The Hikari episodes were on the sugary side, but ultimately alright, and provided some contrast to the girls. Episode 10 was a lot heavier than I was expecting. Though this show was one of the first of its kind (at least as a late night anime), it was also influenced by the shows before it, and the heavier tone also feels like some of what I was getting in Seraphim Call. The threat of the library being closed is treated with some real weight, and the cliffhanger moment of episode 10 has made me want to pursue this further. I'm not expecting the secret to be earth-shattering, but it'll certainly be heartwarming.
 

fertygo

Member
Shirobako - 08

TBH I'm kinda disappointed, this eps felt like repeat of eps 6 for the resolution of mini-character arc, I know they don't want something that too heavy handed, but coming of previous eps that rather weighty, its not very satisfying the rather heavy theme concluded or at least for right now just like that.. the office joke is rather lame in this eps too, Oh well..
 
Shirobako - 08

TBH I'm kinda disappointed, this eps felt like repeat of eps 6 for the resolution of mini-character arc, I know they don't want something that too heavy handed, but coming of previous eps that rather weighty, its not very satisfying the rather heavy theme concluded or at least for right now just like that.. the office joke is rather lame in this eps too, Oh well..

Being heavy handed is probably my only complaint with the show. It's not as bad as a few weeks ago when the dialogue felt like an authorial intrusion.
 

fertygo

Member
Being heavy handed is probably my only complaint with the show. It's not as bad as a few weeks ago when the dialogue felt like an authorial intrusion.

Yeah, in this eps I feel they had "we overdoing it in eps 6" too much in their head tho lol, there's lack of confidence in those Ema scene delivery I feel.. I still like eps 6 much better because of that.
 

jman2050

Member
Shirobako 8

Okay Aoi if you start hallucinating your dolls conversing with you while in the middle of driving then you really need to see a doctor. Like, ASAP.

So Ema is still suffering and can't break through her block but her senior animators are there to save the day! With some help from Iguchi, some fresh air, and a wandering cat seems she's back in business. And she also gets the best advice possible: Copy everyone else as much as possible until you're good enough that you don't have to.

The show also did a rather effective job characterizing Aoi's sister in so little time, remarkably without actually explicitly saying anything about her. Contrasting just a snippet of her daily work life with her Tokyo tour with Rii says everything that needed to be said.
 
Chaika S2 8
Well they went through fighting each other fairly quick as well as a poor conclusion to what happened to Gillette.. Otherwise, kind of solid start to wrap-u
 

Clov

Member
Dreaming Machine isn't going to fund itself. :|

Sad, but true. Anything for that, really. Though I wouldn't mind if they adapted Pluto in the meantime.

On the topic of Project Itoh, it's really exciting seeing Micheal Arias return. I loved Tekkonkinkreet, so it will be interesting to see the work he'll do here.
 
Parasyte - 09

Yes, let's confront the shape shifting alien in a room alone and try to reason with it. Also let's stand with our back against it, it's not like theres a chance it would stab us in the back, right?
Why wouldn't he change his looks when he went in and "changed clothes". Instead he goes like a few steps into an alley and goes full on transform.
Besides these things, I enjoy the episode, I liked Shinichi's little outbursts
 
Yu-Gi-Oh! ARC-V Episode 33
B3d2gbSCQAAokQW.png
B3d0qBOCcAA2RLr.png

Finally the duel we've been waiting for. So many shiveru the whole episode with Futoshi getting us all into it. Wow it was exciting. Kurosaki kills the mood, but Sora made it as exciting as expected. He's a great match for Yuuya oniichan by entertaining in an exciting manner.

Can't wait to see him get serious
since Des Toy Scissor Bear seems to not be his true Trump Card
 

No one gives a shit about Gaara's flashback

Almost time for the movie tie-in special with best girl Hinata and her little sister Hanabi!

Can't wait for all those moments that make me go "awwwww" like a little 12 year old.

1417102799681iuilb.gif
 
But... are male characters really better written in this series? Not counting the MC.
No.

If you think about it, there are barely any supporting characters in the story in first place, it's all Shinichi's journey and his relation with Migi and other parasytes.

Well, I actually agree with this. I was actually going to mention this if someone disagreed with me! Shinichi and Migi (and Ryoko to a lesser extent) are the only characters that really have any depth to their characters, in my opinion. Everyone else kind of just exists as a plot device.

Though I do like Murano, but I think I might be the only one.
 

Midonin

Member
Twintail 08

Sentai often has marriage episodes, with the marriage meeting involving a Yellow plenty of times. One of the first examples that comes to mind is Gekiranger's with Ran, though they've been around for much, much longer than that. Also, everyone in this show is much quicker about figuring out secret identities than a regular toku show would have. Certainly longer than it took for Kouta to realize what his best friend was doing in Gaim. The whole discussion of light novels and literature was also an interesting and meta one. This series no doubt has things to say, it just may not be the things that Western anime viewers would gravitate towards, or are getting. Like I said, I love this show, but I can't tell how much of the other internet appreciation for it is ironic/sarcastic. Because it's not as dumb as it looks.
 
Well, I actually agree with this. I was actually going to mention this if someone disagreed with me! Shinichi and Migi (and Ryoko to a lesser extent) are the only characters that really have any depth to their characters, in my opinion. Everyone else kind of just exists as a plot device.

Though I do like Murano, but I think I might be the only one.

You forgot the father.
 
Pyscho-Pass 2 08

I agree with someone who stated earlier that one of the biggest problems with this show are scenes where they come up with hypothesis. Except they aren't hypothesis because they are always right and they're actually just exposition scenes. Even something as dumb as a guy being made of 180 different people and their extracted brains (while they were still alive?) isn't contrived enough for them to get the perfect, also contrived explanation. And that's this entire episode in a nutshell.
However, that ending. My God that ending. Duckroll was right, but I'm not sure if he can comprehend how right he was.

This show is turning into The Evil Within now. I wouldn't be surprised if Kirito-kun started doing psychic shit.
But I guess it already was in the first season. Just grab the barbwire and we're set!

Shirobako 08

This show gives me feels.
The suffering has been overcome, maybe being an animator isn't so bad. Although you still have to deal with Tarou.
I never have a lot to say about this show, but I think I like it more with each episode. Others like Bahamut (although I still think that's my top this season) and Parasyte fluctuate from being great to being a bit weak, but this has stayed consistent throughout.
Of course G-Reco is the most consistently amazing show of the season but that's just not fair
-----------------------------------

Psycho-Pass movie trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Baj4-fhA4Jk

Animation looks pretty good!

Mika is still alive so I'll assume this will be bad. Can't wait to see her complain about tanks and armed terrorists because nobody told her there would be tanks and armed terrorists.
But it has engrish and Metal Gears so that's a plus
 

Midonin

Member
April 08

A break from Kousei for a change. I was paying more attention to Emi's performance - Hayamin is just drawn to the dark-haired Japanese beauty types, isn't she? - but both of them were pretty interesting. Everything's connected. I know the show has its share of problems, but I like the theatrical aspect of the presentation. It's one of the things that makes it feel like anime, and in turn like something I wanted to watch.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom