despite same release day/no arcade release/great netcode so no barrier to access, etc, some of y'all need to realise the players from asia are simply more talented in fighting games than their western counterpart.
i'm not saying they're inherently talented but more like their 'work ethic' or how they approach fighting games is what propelling them above western players. idk, maybe this is more of a cultural thing.
Yeah I'm of that thought. I don't know what exactly they're doing differently but it's working.
You probably shouldn't have used the word talented then, since most people associate that with being "naturally good". Their general success (as a group, not individuals) has to be attributed to culture. The way they approach fighters is definitely superior, and having a strong arcade scene just pushes it further.
This is what I think. I think arcades are the best way to produce talents. Information sharing is there because of the offline nature of them and because it's very easy to see players playing. So whether or not you want to share something, it will be revealed. Secondly, the competitive nature is ramped up because it costs money to play. Finally, they're in cities and thus get a good amount of players all playing at a single arcade.
These arcades developed players for Japan 10-16 years ago and in some cases 20 years ago when they were much bigger. So let's say hypothetically Japan produced 50 great players. In that same period, US developed 20 great players. Naturally, there will be players that rise to the top of that player pool. Because the player pool is deeper in Japan, Japan produced the most talented player rather than the US.
Arcades in the US have been virtually dead for a long time now. Up until SF4, US hasn't had a big pool of players to draw talent from. Japan still had arcades producing talents in a lot of games before the SF4 era. Those players are Nemo, Mago, Fuudo, etc...
All of those players do not need arcades anymore to be godlike at the game. They already understand fighting games at a master level and are the cream of the crop of their respective communities in regards to footsies, spacing, reading, etc... The fact that SFV is not in the arcades is irrelevant. Does Justin Wong need the arcades to remain one of the top talents in the US street fighter scene? No. His ability in footsies, defending, etc... was already developed a long time ago.
So Japan and Asia have all these monsters that were created from the arcades decades ago still competing in SFV. That number is larger than the US talent pool. The talent pool is deeper, so Japan will produce the better SFV players. So I do believe Japan has the more talented players due to the arcades producing a larger amount of top players. And like in anything, there will always be some that rise to the top making them the most talented. I ask the question, if you were to put up Asia's best 100 players and go against America's 100 best players in a SF4 100v100 exhibition, which team will win? Why? Now why, if those same regions make the jump to the new game, would the result change in 2016? It makes no sense to believe the US would do better.