Appreciating his ability and talent is different.
Hernandez isn't a great player, countless forwards better than him but I love having him play for us cos I feel like I can support him and relish his performances.
Rooney might play well but he isn't interested in sticking around. He's already tried to lead for our rivals, lied about it, spend a summer pussy footying about.
I appreciate what he's done for the club but no I don't enjoy watching him anymore cos as fans we'll just end up getting burned. Part of supporting the club is placing an investment into it - with Rooney there are no returns anymore, for me.
Pulga doesn't even understand the above point. His argument is that Rooney is good so we should cherish him. That's fine - but that's not how a lot of fans minds' work. If I'm remembering correctly, the whole affair was done though the papers and SAF making it public.
Would you take RVP back for example? I doubt it.