England player ratings from the Times. 4 for Hart is generous.
Joe Hart 4/10
Poor positional sense for the free kick for Scotlands first goal from Griffiths, being too near his right post. Reacted too slowly for the second free kick from the same player. Big mistakes.
Jake Livermore 6/10
Gave away the foul that led to Griffiths second goal. Had been tidy until then without being spectacular. Saw a deflected shot hit a post early in the second half.
Kyle Walker 6/10
Was never given the true licence to show what he can do going forward. England needed more of his pace and penetration on the right flank. More to offer than he showed on this occasion.
Adam Lallana 7/10
Lovely, silky feet, he always looked dangerous. Came close to scoring in the first half, when he opened up the Scotland defence and saw his shot tipped into the side netting.
Gary Cahill 6/10
Made a right mess of a challenge on Griffiths in the 86th minute. That gave Scotland a lifeline, when the same Scottish player curled his free kick past Hart. Had been composed before then.
Dele Alli 5/10
Anonymous. Took an early kick from Brown and never really settled into the game. Spurned a decent chance in the 50th minute and his vision was off and his passing poor.
Chris Smalling 6/10
Not the most difficult of afternoons for the Manchester United centre-half facing an unambitious Scotland side with just Griffiths up front. Did his job alongside Cahill.
Marcus Rashford 6/10
Was on set pieces, which seemed strange. Has the pace to have done more than he did. Withdrawn to be replaced by a player who was more purposeful and direct and scored.
Ryan Bertrand 7/10
Gave a good attacking option down the left and his crosses were a key element for Southgates men going forward. Will be happy with what he did for the visitors.
Harry Kane 8/10
Did what good captains do: rescued his team in their hour of need. A massive strike, three minutes into stoppage time, with composure. Had missed three chances before then.
Eric Dier 5/10
Was not the dominating presence England expected him to be in midfield. There is more to Diers game than he showed. Should have been the platform in front of his back four for victory.