Perfect Blue
Banned
Try again, m8.
On what planet is Mbappe "overrated"? The kid is 18 and already has more CL goals than players like Costa and Hazard.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Football Thread 2017/18 |OT| Relegated to Community
- Thread starter Lunar FC
- Start date
- Status
cartographer
Member
Time will tell if this is a real "next few hours" or a Coutinho "next few hours."
Official statement from Bosz is that "Dembele was not in training. We do not know where he is and we could not reach him."
GoldenCrow
Member
I think he is massively overrated. He is really good but he hasn't shown anything to suggest he is actually worth the level of hype he is getting. His best game was against Dortmund, many of his best games were before teams became aware of his quality and was often given the freedom to play. Once teams became aware of this (especially that he needs to turn to play) or Monaco adapted their tactics so he had to do a job and couldn't just float about he wasn't anywhere near as good.
When you look at the teams that he is linked with Real, Barca, PSG, City, Arsenal and Liverpool he isn't going to be given the freedom he gets at Monaco unless there is a big change in their play style and is against teams that will happily just knock him every time he goes for a ball or man mark him all game (PSG being the exception).
Very much reminds me of young players that have a great WC or Euro, become hyped and make a move to a big money club but they can't do what is asked of them when they get there.
Lashley
Why does he wear the mask!?
This planet.
Lashley
Why does he wear the mask!?
Perfect Blue
Banned
I think it's frankly absurd to say "he hasn't shown anything to suggest he is actually worth the level of hype". If that was even remotely true he wouldn't be wanted by every club in Europe and commanding a 9 figure fee at the age of 18. Mbappe is a special talent and has shown that in Ligue 1 (which people who criticize him never watch...) and in the CL.
Lacazette fits the description of overrated more than Mbappe does. Penalty merchant with 0 physicality.
It is an odd one bud, especially when the manager has openly and constantly expressed the urgent need for players to compete for the league, let alone Champions Leaguen. We signed three very high quality players but we sold/loaned out more players than you can imagine. We have only 14 first team regulars I believe.
I can see Drinkwater happening. Don't think Arsenal would budge on Ox - if anything, they should renew his contract as he is very good. VVD makes little sense to me, he'll cost a fortune and is not in a position we need players in 🤔
It's been a while bud, good to see you again. Let us Chelsea fans weather this potential chaotic season together 🙈🙈🙈
The colour is pretty dope, the rest of the weird shit on it can go
The masters of unsettling players they want to sign
Lashley
Why does he wear the mask!?
Morata is just as overrated. I'd much rather have Lacazette at the club.
We can do this all day sunshine
Perfect Blue
Banned
Joke's on you m8 no one likes Morata and besides I wanted Belotti instead
Lashley
Why does he wear the mask!?
Yeah, he's decent
Everything is always a matter of hours over there lol.
McMoneyman
Member
Gotta love when there's transfer speculation in Liverpool land, every Tom, Dick and Harry becomes a professor in facial expressions.
Van Dijk walked down the road in a pissed off way... he going to Liverpool. Same with loads of people on transfer tbf. It's weird
Good thing you do. Although I expect Arsense a few years down the road to say he tried to sign Mbappe.
A Serious Man
Member
20th Anniversary PS4 controller is the only one anyone should ever need.
Tbf half a dozen of Europe's top clubs, and Arsenal attempted to sign him.
Lashley
Why does he wear the mask!?
He did. He just did a shit job of it. Kid isn't worth 100m plus
Lashley
Why does he wear the mask!?
Grey One? Yeah I love that one. I have that and the v2 ps4 pro one.
Come one man, If Coutinho is worth £100m then Mbappe is easily worth £150
Best job ever, just spew bullshit and look what sticks.
Sun Bather
Member
Because no sane club, would let Costa go for the shit money Atletico are willing to pay. It has been handled poorly especially by Conte, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't try to get a fair price out of it.
Because that is what Chelsea do. Win league, then decide the squad is pretty much perfect despite there clearly being a need for new players rotated in and out, then fire manager when he fails and doesn't use youth players.
GoldenCrow
Member
Money means nothing in the transfer market anymore. The clubs are only prepared to fight over the fee for potential (which he does have), that they don't want that potential to go anywhere else, that Monaco have sold most of their squad and he is in a strong contract. Clubs balked at the 60 million Monaco stated in the winter window when it was only City and Real interested and he didn't get any better. In fact many clubs, especially PSG showed how to stop him playing doing a basic man marking job.
If you look at his independent market value which is at just over 30 million which is an accurate estimate considering the talent he displayed. He wasn't turning games around, he wasn't creating something from nothing, he wasn't freeing up other players when teams were doing a job on him. He is a young player with a lot of potential but a huge amount to work on yet he is being hailed as a player comparable to Henry, he's nowhere even close to that level.
Of course because he is fucken 18 and scores a goal roughly every 100mins. Sure the sample size is small but if he does it for another year or two, we are talking about the best young forward in the game. It is a moot point as we all know Arsenal are never going to pay that sort of fee for him.
His Majesty
Banned
sell chalobah
buy drinkwater
Chelsea board surpassing all expectations again
buy drinkwater
Chelsea board surpassing all expectations again
MrS
Banned
He is, but he plays in the exact same position as the player PSG have spent £198m on and nobody's taking Cavani's spot either. So why sign him? Mbappe would be wasted at PSG.
WhateverItTakes
Banned
Surely whoever gets Dembele, the other gets Mbappe?
Of course...and sometimes people wonder why I'm a bit of a class warrior. Fuck most rich people, seriously
WhateverItTakes
Banned
Barca definitely going for Dembele, rejection of a bid officially confirmed by the club.
If PSG want Mbappe he will go there. No one can compete with them.
The good thing about publicly traded companies. No need to rely on shitty papers.
MrS
Banned
That may well be the case, but he is far more potent playing on the left. That's where the majority of his goals and assists came from. He would be wasted not playing in his best position.
The system is created by the same rich people. No wonder everything works great for them.
ambar_hitman
Member
Don't forget Matic too.
Lashley
Why does he wear the mask!?
Coutinho isn't worth 100m
WhateverItTakes
Banned
Market's fucked mate, we need to adjust our internal metrics to compensate.
Lashley
Why does he wear the mask!?
Its is aye, but I find both Countiho and Mbappe highly overrated
People overrate Sanchez too
They will have to overpay next year as well. Rarely are elite players going to transfer below market value in today's market. You stole Kroos.
He is worth whatever some team is willing to pay for him. I look forward to seeing what the market looks like in 5 years.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked