-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
For the entirety of last gen up until now, Naughty Dog hasn't created a single new IP.
- Thread starter Eddie-Griffin
- Start date
Cryio
Member
So since 2013:
Remaster Last of Us. 2 Uncharted games. Last of Us 2. Patch for Last of Us 2. "Remaster" for Uncharted 4 and Lost Legacy. Remaking Last of Us 1. Working way too long on the MP for Last of Us 2.
I can't say they've staying still.
But agreed, no new IP is underwhelming.
Remaster Last of Us. 2 Uncharted games. Last of Us 2. Patch for Last of Us 2. "Remaster" for Uncharted 4 and Lost Legacy. Remaking Last of Us 1. Working way too long on the MP for Last of Us 2.
I can't say they've staying still.
But agreed, no new IP is underwhelming.
Clear
CliffyB's Cock Holster
For the scale/budget of their titles, ND are pretty productive. As to IP generation, the issue is that they are the originators of 2 franchises which are highly significant to the Playstation first-party line-up, so taking them off of those properties isn't easy from a quality control PoV. From a PR standpoint the new game would need to match or exceed the quality of previous entries so as not to be viewed as damaging to the brand, and frankly whoever takes over is inheriting a lot of pressure to achieve.
Transferring production to another studio also isn't ideal given that they are based on bespoke tech, meaning that they'd almost certainly need to be involved to some degree to hand over and support the new devs while they find their feet. This is basically how studios get kinda stuck with being single-property shops - success can really lock a team in.
Transferring production to another studio also isn't ideal given that they are based on bespoke tech, meaning that they'd almost certainly need to be involved to some degree to hand over and support the new devs while they find their feet. This is basically how studios get kinda stuck with being single-property shops - success can really lock a team in.
elcapitano
Member
Why do people only complain about this for Naughty Dog more so than others?
Loads of Devs hardly ever make new IPs.
Some basically never do!
Loads of Devs hardly ever make new IPs.
Some basically never do!
Trazyn the Infinite
Member
I don’t get that either. They have gameplay, its just incredibly shallow and mindless. Which is fine depending on the rest of the experience. Works great for a game like Uncharted 1-3.
TLOU2 on grounded is far from shallow and mindless.
Trazyn the Infinite
Member
No, it really is still just as mindless and shallow as played on any other difficulty. The core mechanics and piss poor level design doesn’t change. Just the “intelligence” of the AI, which isn’t very intelligent to begin with.
If you want a game that has actual depth and strategy, play MGSV. It does everything in TLOU 1 and 2, but far better (Strictly in terms of gameplay).
Physiognomonics
Member
I disagree as they actually created a new IP in then end of PS4 gen: TLOU2.
Sid Of Bee
Member
Arms. I honestly loved that game for the unique fun romp that it was/is.
But yeah, I would love to see a completely new IP from them up there with Mario, Zelda, and Metroid. All IPs developed over 30 years ago.
Hawking Radiation
Member
To create AAA games takes alot of time money and resources so naturally if you have a successful formula that resonates with audiences you'll stick to that formula and milk it for all that it's worth.
New IPs are a risky, expensive business and very few studios have the talent to always pull off a successful new IP.
No one likes to see projects fail and money waisted.
New IPs are a risky, expensive business and very few studios have the talent to always pull off a successful new IP.
No one likes to see projects fail and money waisted.
Last edited:
custardbun01
Member
Neither of these were first party studio games (when they were made), but credit where it’s due. We’re still missing any exciting announcements for PS5 exclusives.
LiquidMetal14
hide your water-based mammals
Lemonade drive for Rockstar electricity bill and girl scout cookie crusade to help Naughty Dog pay sewer bill.
darkangel-212559
Banned
The woke game critics loving the wokest game of all time.
I'm shocked it got those reviews and awards! Shocked!
JoeyWestSide
Member
Rockstar has also been busy creating the highest grossing entertainment property in history, they can do what they want. At least they released another game during this time.
JoeyWestSide
Member
During this time I remember hearing from the Sony fanbois about how Xbox's biggest names didn't have any new ip, which the same could have been said here. I'm glad some old studios like Rare and Bioware have tried something new like SoT and Anthem (under rated btw).
Topher
Identifies as young
The "wokest game of all time"? You can't be serious.
darkangel-212559
Banned
Name me another game that is more woke than this one.
tmlDan
Member
Topher
Identifies as young
So if a game has characters that do not completely line up with your filtered outlook of the world then its woke? Ok then.....
Last edited:
Kabelly
Gold Member
people crying over ellie's lesbianism is always hilarious to me since it was established since the first game.
People that whine about the possibility of a black James Bond or whatever always say "just make your own characters if you want diversity! none of this forced stuff" and when developers do create an original character that's not a white heterosexual it's "woke."
Funny how language changes fast on the internet too. Before it was the SJWs. Now it's the wokeists.
️
Trazyn the Infinite
Member
You are absolutely correct. Nothing in this is “woke” except, maybe it could be argued that the entire story-line with Lev is written with a slacktivist bent as it would make very little sense to keep a trans person around in a post-apocalyptic world.
However, given how terrible the writing is across the board for this game, I don’t see that being the case. Its just a bad character written poorly in a terribly written sequel that should never have existed.
Trazyn the Infinite
Member
Yep. I still remember the Uncharted 3 launch. Was my first collector’s edition I picked up at launch. I was enraptured for and played for two days straight to finish everything. Then I played the MP for years after.
Then came TLOU. I was beyond excited. The next big thing after my personal favorite game of the studios’ portfolio (and yes, I understand its problems - still my favorite). Was beyond disappointed. Then Uncharted 4… then TLOU2… I just can’t bring myself to be excited for *antyhing* this studio does anymore. Each release more disappointing and mindless than the last.
