-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Forza 3 vs Gran Turismo 5 Comparison Thread of John, Chapter 11, Verse 35
- Thread starter bishoptl
- Start date
I whipped out GTR: Evo and did a lap around The Ring. Amazing.
I then raced Nurburgring in NFS: Shift. Insulting coming from GTR:Evo. I can't type words to explain. Afterwards I remembered how terrible it was in Forza 3.
SHIFT
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dLkOY3jQLnM
F3
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GwhYWsjUB0c
Forza is embarrassing.
Sad that Forza makes Shift look godly. Turn-10 has mastered things like rewind and livery and yet each entry in the series pushes them closer to bankruptcy. Maybe they should focus on what actually gets games off shelves, the actual racing experience.
Failure 3
I then raced Nurburgring in NFS: Shift. Insulting coming from GTR:Evo. I can't type words to explain. Afterwards I remembered how terrible it was in Forza 3.
SHIFT
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dLkOY3jQLnM
F3
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GwhYWsjUB0c
Forza is embarrassing.
Sad that Forza makes Shift look godly. Turn-10 has mastered things like rewind and livery and yet each entry in the series pushes them closer to bankruptcy. Maybe they should focus on what actually gets games off shelves, the actual racing experience.
Failure 3
Forza 3 Sales Surpass 2 MillionInsertia said:
Please just stop. Nothing you are saying is well-thought out or the least bit objective. None of your screenshots are examples of what you'd actually see while playing either game.
I'm surprised you're not banned with these kind of posts.
eso76
Member
reposting for the new page
absolutely, my car is the M3 coupe you see behind the C63 and the 8C competizione is from the same replay.
Yes, from a geometry standpoint they're still very good (cars introduced with fm3 generally are).
One of T10's mistakes was recycling Fm2 models for older cars, since they DID remodel them too in 'premium' detail for menus, they certainly could have obtained a much better lower poly mesh from those. Apart from that i believe T10 can improve the overall visual impact tenfold by working on colors, lighting and shaders alone, in the end most GT5 standard cars don't look THAT bad from a normal viewing distance, thanks to general accuracy of colors and shaders.
Oh, and Insertia, can't you do better than that ? like, what about putting that image through a gaussian blur filter, then through a sharpen more filter (4x, just to make sure) then increase size 4x and save as quality 1/12 jpeg and post the 5120x2880 100kb result here ?
shinnn said:
absolutely, my car is the M3 coupe you see behind the C63 and the 8C competizione is from the same replay.
Yes, from a geometry standpoint they're still very good (cars introduced with fm3 generally are).
One of T10's mistakes was recycling Fm2 models for older cars, since they DID remodel them too in 'premium' detail for menus, they certainly could have obtained a much better lower poly mesh from those. Apart from that i believe T10 can improve the overall visual impact tenfold by working on colors, lighting and shaders alone, in the end most GT5 standard cars don't look THAT bad from a normal viewing distance, thanks to general accuracy of colors and shaders.
Oh, and Insertia, can't you do better than that ? like, what about putting that image through a gaussian blur filter, then through a sharpen more filter (4x, just to make sure) then increase size 4x and save as quality 1/12 jpeg and post the 5120x2880 100kb result here ?
Slayer-33
Liverpool-2
Gtfo with that nfs shift bullshit, fake fucking over exaggerated cockpit movement shit is meaningless, try harder next time.Insertia said:I whipped out GTR: Evo and did a lap around The Ring. Amazing.
I then raced Nurburgring in NFS: Shift. Insulting coming from GTR:Evo. I can't type words to explain. Afterwards I remembered how terrible it was in Forza 3.
SHIFT
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dLkOY3jQLnM
F3
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GwhYWsjUB0c
Forza is embarrassing.
Sad that Forza makes Shift look godly. Turn-10 has mastered things like rewind and livery and yet each entry in the series pushes them closer to bankruptcy. Maybe they should focus on what actually gets games off shelves, the actual racing experience.
Failure 3
Edit- oh hey look, the clowns are back with their meaningless hollow FM 3 mockery, how original.
sdornan said:
Only because Forza 3 had to be given away for free. In a lot of cases Forza 3 had to be bundled with ANOTHER game. That's how much it sucks at selling itself. :lol
Looking at Forza Kinect I see Turn-10 has learned nothing. At least they are good at making successful games that can be bundled with Fable II and given away for free.
theignoramus
Member
look at the comments and the change of targets between this page and the last one.:lol :lolcgcg said:
If Forza 3 was a success Che Chou would have still been at the company. Unfortunately they lost a lot of money, giving their game away for free and whatnot, and he had to be relocated to another place that has a better shot at making a successful title.
A better community manager than Che? There was none.
Unfortunately he couldn't save the stale series.
Turn 10 has been very successful and consistent at making failure after failure with great rewind features and rich livery editors. They are much more successful than Polyphony in that area.
:lol :lol
Loser
A better community manager than Che? There was none.
Unfortunately he couldn't save the stale series.
Turn 10 has been very successful and consistent at making failure after failure with great rewind features and rich livery editors. They are much more successful than Polyphony in that area.
:lol :lol
Loser
flyinpiranha
Member
Insertia said:If Forza 3 was a success Che Chou would have still been at the company. Unfortunately they lost a lot of money, giving their game away for free and whatnot, and he had to be relocated to another place that has a better shot at making a successful title.
A better community manager than Che? There was none.
Unfortunately he couldn't save the stale series.
Turn 10 has been very successful and consistent at making failure after failure with great rewind features and rich livery editors. They are much more successful than Polyphony in that area.
:lol :lol
Loser
You're dumb. Really, really dumb.
RedRedSuit
Member
Insertia said:
Solid warrior
Banned
does neogaf tolerate this type of posts? am i missing something?Insertia said:If Forza 3 was a success Che Chou would have still been at the company. Unfortunately they lost a lot of money, giving their game away for free and whatnot, and he had to be relocated to another place that has a better shot at making a successful title.
A better community manager than Che? There was none.
Unfortunately he couldn't save the stale series.
Turn 10 has been very successful and consistent at making failure after failure with great rewind features and rich livery editors. They are much more successful than Polyphony in that area.
:lol :lol
Loser
REMEMBER CITADEL
Banned
Insertia said:
Jesus. Can we skip over the retarded image comparisons and move straight onto the violent account suicide meltdown? We can all see it coming.
D
Deleted member 47027
Unconfirmed Member
wow Insertia's 31 flavors of crazy now :lol I wonder what made him snap?
Glowingmonx
Member
zedge said:I have to agree, Forza has not sold very well. And the only reason its likely at 2 million is due to it being bundled with consoles. And only 2 million? GT5 will likely sell that in a month or two.
BTW I like Forza 3 but I am enjoying GT5 more.
The article was posted at February 9 2010...
MrPink93485
Member
jedimike said:
No, I believe it was bundled with Elites along with Halo 3 ODST during the Spring.
REMEMBER CITADEL
Banned
h3ro said:
They should both take a nice stroll through countryside. It's relaxing.
zedge said:I have to agree, Forza has not sold very well. And the only reason its likely at 2 million is due to it being bundled with consoles. And only 2 million? GT5 will likely sell that in a month or two.
Forza 3 sold 2 million, bundled copies not counted, four months after the launch. Of course GT5 will do much better, but Forza 3 still did reasonably well.
jedimike said:
There were Forza 3 bundles at launch.
Captain Pants
Killed by a goddamned Dredgeling
shinnn said:
I don't remember any fans trying to hide the standard cars. It isn't like Polyphony showed them off for all to see.
Well you apparently think that the screens aren't flattering for GT5. Care to specify what elements look inferior to Forza in those shots?skybaby said:
What I personally think the screens highight is Forza's problem with the saturation of its car colors, the crushing of blacks, the weird orangeish skybox reflections on red cars, self-shadowing quality, windshield opacity, and other lighting-related flaws.
REMEMBER CITADEL
Banned
Shurs said:
So you think you know better? Come on now, we're all aware of the LOD incident, but that doesn't mean Che lies as soon as he opens his mouth. Besides, what he said actually makes a lot of sense.
