Gouda Jouji
Member
I always assumed it was just GT2's assets running in a higher resolution/frame rate, like on a PC or something.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Forza 3 vs Gran Turismo 5 Comparison Thread of John, Chapter 11, Verse 35
- Thread starter bishoptl
- Start date
I always assumed it was just GT2's assets running in a higher resolution/frame rate, like on a PC or something.
SolidSnakex
Member
Well, that's basically what GT3 was early on. GT2000 was going to be a juiced up version of GT2. But PD kept working on it and started remodeling and adding things and eventually it just evolved into the next full game. And both previous PS generation transitions they've had plans to release an updated version of their last game (GT2000 and GTHD) but they've both been scrapped. Hopefully a GT6 PS4 release will happen.
I read somewhere (maybe OPM) many years ago that the GT2 intro was mostly GT2 models but rendered in an eary version of the GT3 engine on GT3 tracks. Hence the higher quality looking tracks, reflections, etc. It obviously used the same high quality rendering technique that we still see today though, so it's not as if it were captured in real-time on Ps2 hardware.
Is that really called for?
Metalmurphy
Member
This could be shopped as GT5.
Nope. Besides, it's already heavily shopped.
You noticed the 3D tree. Shame on you.
Metalmurphy
Member
GT has 3D trees on the track theme that looks most like that Horizon shot so...
But hey, if you add an even more intense noise filter, and make it even smaller, maybe someone will be fooled.
Chance Hale
Member
Was just playing, am an American dog myself
Ah, I figured. My bad!
Are we really comparing a portion of a open world track to that track in GT5? I get what you're saying... But in Horizon it has geometry far into the background that you can drive to.
Metalmurphy
Member
Erm... you made the comparison? And when I disagreed you attacked GTs trees. When I showed how wrong you were again you turned the comparison on me? What?
I'm just saying that portion of whatever is in Forza Horizon is not really a traditional track.
NullPointer
Member
Would that be bad?My prediction of how this thread will turn come E3.
My prediction of how this thread will turn come E3.
Seeing the comparison thread for a PS3 and a Durango game is going to be fascinating.
This could be shopped as GT5.
No. PD would never use light that look as ugly as that.
I would frame in night time GT5 if I could. It's sooooo pretty *-*
Glorified G
Member
The lighting in GT5 is amazing.
les papillons sexuels
Banned
they should remake initial d in gt5/forza because the animation would be so much better.
SolidSnakex
Member
Evolution_1ne
Banned
Gouda Jouji
Member
les papillons sexuels
Banned
This is sweet though I actually think forza would be more effective since you have the customization and level options that are more appropriate.
Give us some sweet looking replays and then do that Turn 10!
Oh, and make a Fujimi Kaido where you can actually hit the throttle every now and then to go along with it and eurodance.
CrunchinJelly
formerly cjelly
Saw this GT5 vs REALITY vid last year. GT5's lighting is super smexy in that vid. Might fool you at first glance.
what does this even mean? lol
Psycho_Mantis
Banned
Holy shit that smoke in the bottom gif. The smoke in Forza 4 is pitiful they need to improve the volume of it. It makes drifting look all the more better.
Angelus Errare
Banned
Yo....dawg...damn that was beautiful
Evolution_1ne
Banned
This needs to happen in GT6
I'd kill to get the whole 07 / 10 roster and it's only 12 cars a piece PD you can do it
eso76
Member
it's fun and provides eye candy !
Now though, show me a PCARS gif that looks as good as those GT5 ones. HAH !
(wow, you were downgraded to junior ?? wtf ???)
The mods felt my joke thread warranted a demotion. I thought it was harsh and so did other posters in the thread.
I guess someone was having a bad day...
Psycho_Mantis
Banned
Are you just going to pretend like thats a valid comparison when the Forza photo is edited.
No I just posted lol. You're reading too much into my posts.
Even if it was photoshop, does it matter? Neither title has that IQ in game.
It's pretty obvious GT5 has a more robust photo editor tool.
MrCookiepants
Member
This thread makes me wanna play GT5. Never did give that new Corvette a proper drive.
Psycho_Mantis
Banned
Good. I knew you were better than that. GT5's photo editor is better because it tries to mimic an actual camera. Well thats why I like it.
Metalmurphy
Member
I don't even know why people keep posting the same kind of comparisons.
It's pretty obvious that no matter how good FM4 looks, GT has it beat. Shaders and lighting is just too good..
Ultimately though, neither game can compare to these visuals
That draw distance!
I really wanna feel immensed. Like the violent shaking, bobbing and weaving of the car when accelerating. It's present in GT5 though it's very subtle.