I mean yeah I get it, Gambit system had all this flexibility and if you fucked with it enough you broke the game. That's cool and all, but at the same time the gameplay is so fucking slow to the point where that shit doesn't even matteryeah, a dynamic & connected world that begs to be explored wont do much for an FFX fan where you just clicked on where you wanted to go
character-wise, XII shoulda stuck with bash or ashce but we got a weak protagonist, though not as weak as tidus at least. most of X's cast are weed carriers except for that one goth chick with the tits, and yes, the gambit system which finally did something other than stale-ass ATB/just keep mashing X to win was really off-putting if you ain't wanna put time setting up your shit
storywise i mean what could possibly touch the masterpiece that was hey tidus may not've actually existed but he was a metaphysical fart through time because of his father or something lol
all love doe
all the other ffx complaints you've listed we've all seen before so it's not really worth arguing about. Despite the linearity and it being turn-based (this isn't even a bad thing since it worked so well) the game is still immersive. XII is bland as fokk
tho you're on some other shit for saying Lulu is the only legit character