Xamtheking
Member
Because since Nin never responded to the post I made, Ouro just pulled from the most recent post to blip on Nin's radar
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Gafia 2: The Bride of Gafia |Mafia OT| One Wedding, Many Funerals
- Thread starter RetroMG
- Start date
Also
Didn't I tunnel in on you in Batman somewhat hard?
Me? You agreed a lot with me in the late game and were voting Coppa IIRC. Early game you seemed mostly stumped by Kark.
Xamtheking
Member
You don't remember the time (albeit short) where I was on your ass?Me? You agreed a lot with me in the late game and were voting Coppa IIRC. Early game you seemed mostly stumped by Kark.
I'm not certain of whether it should be Xam or Nin that gets lynched, so I'm gonna refrain until I can be certain on one of them.Which is it?
weemadarthur
Member
You don't remember the time (albeit short) where I was on your ass?
Please tell me you're not working up to some secret communication, using an older game as a clue, to totally make another unnecessary role claim?
Despite the scummy vibes from Xam and Nin, I can't really commit to any lynching. I wanna be precise on this shit after Gryvan turned out to be town. We keep going on gut feelings when it comes to lynches, and that bites us in the ass every time. I can't even keep track on how many games Town has lost because so many people mislynched due to "This guy is posting weird, this girl is seemingly nervous, etc".
I don't disagree, but we don't really have much other stuff to go on yet. I would love to be more precise and use more facts in our lynch decisions, but at this point we simply don't have those. Even things like "pr can only target at the same table" is just speculation at this point.
Xamtheking
Member
Not this time, no, don't worryPlease tell me you're not working up to some secret communication, using an older game as a clue, to totally make another unnecessary role claim?
You don't remember the time (albeit short) where I was on your ass?
I actually don't. Was it just before you started agreeing with me?
Xamtheking
Member
This is pre-Trigger claiming Batman, when I was somewhat focused on the idea you were both scumI actually don't. Was it just before you started agreeing with me?
I do want to revisit something I meant to ask earlier:
Nin, what the hell are you talking about? Either they are town, neutral, or scum. There's no 4th option.
please for the love of god tell me there is no 4th option
Since xam said then
why didn't you say scum/neutral PR
I responded with burb maybe being another kind of pr (meaning town).
I'm not certain of whether it should be Xam or Nin that gets lynched, so I'm gonna refrain until I can be certain on one of them.
So...
Strong position that either is ok to lynch.
Strong position saying we shouldn't use gut feelings because gryvan D1.
Middle position that you were just unsure of which of the two to lynch.
VOTE: Bronx-Man
I'd like more from you when you have the chance.
----------------------------------------
This is pre-Trigger claiming Batman, when I was somewhat focused on the idea you were both scum
That rings a couple of bells. Not sure if it was because I was caught up in the Kark/gryvan lynch.
If you have the chance I wouldn't mind waking up to a more detailed read of Nin.
Xamtheking
Member
Then what the fuck did this meanSince xam said then
I responded with burb maybe being another kind of pr (meaning town).
What the fucking hell, NinPR does not mean that this person is Town.
I've given you my scum reads and opinions on lynching. Not sure what more you want from me.So...
Strong position that either is ok to lynch.
Strong position saying we shouldn't use gut feelings because gryvan D1.
Middle position that you were just unsure of which of the two to lynch.
VOTE: Bronx-Man
I'd like more from you when you have the chance.
Xamtheking
Member
I think he wants a voteI've given you my scum reads and opinions on lynching. Not sure what more you want from me.
Then what the fuck did this mean
What the fucking hell, Nin
I meant what it meant! If someone claims to be a PR that doesn't make him town! I just wanted to make it clear that you should keep the options open that you could be fooled. I mean was that so hard to understand :3
Gnight now.
Xamtheking
Member
BUT YOU THOUGHT HE WAS TOWNI meant what it meant! If someone claims to be a PR that doesn't make him town! I just wanted to make it clear that you should keep the options open that you could be fooled. I mean was that so hard to understand :3
Gnight now.
I think he wants a vote
No. Opinions that don't contradict.
For the most just thoughts on things, preferably in real time, when you have the chance.
BUT YOU THOUGHT HE WAS TOWN
I was talking about the option that launch could in the end be mafia after all. I just wanted to keep the option open. Xam
Xamtheking
Member
Launch?I was talking about the option that launch could in the end be mafia after all. I just wanted to keep the option open. You fucking moron.
We weren't talking about launch
We were talking about Burbeting
What are you doing nin
I already clarified a bit, but to correct my own post it should have said:I've given you my scum reads and opinions on lynching. Not sure what more you want from me.I'd like more from you when you have the chance.
"I'd like to hear more from you when you have the chance."
Xamtheking
Member
I don't know either, palI feel like I'm going insane reading these posts. What the hell is going on here?
nin didn't play like this in FF or in VI
It feels like people post things, try to create weak "gotcha" moments to each other (what Scrafty did to weemad, what Launch did to roy yesterday), yet not really scum-hunt much at all. So many blender players right now out, and I'm bothered that I can't really grasp anything solid from this game yet, even though it's day 2.
I do re-iterate that I feel that nin is town right now. I mean, his posts aren't exactly encouraging, but I feel he is playing sincerely right now. What did bother me was that he said "I think Burb is PR". Look man, even if you'd think I was town PR, you wouldn't discuss those things out loud. That kind of discussion only helps scum, and not town.
Still, I feel more wary of the people going for nin, than nin himself. Xam especially. He seems so... eager and posts piles and piles of posts, yet most of them don't feel to actually say much value at all, and are there more like as a filler, to make him seem active when he actually is not. Yeah, there are some valid points in there, but it's clogged behind an endless stream of... posts.
Welcome back, Burb. And yeah I feel you with the gotcha shit. It seems like lots of people are doing that instead of hunting, which is why people that are doing that are kind of towards the top of my list.
Sorry I've been a tad blendy, I post when I have a chance, at typically have a couple hours, but it just seems like no conversation happens during the time I keep checking the thread heh.
As for reads and stuff, I'm still on Scrafy and Xam, in that order. But as I said before, I think it would help us to keep Xam alive tonight, so we can see if he gets any more notifications from his drinky thing...or if he dies overnight. That, too. I think we need to understand what this drinking thing is moving forward, at least to the best of our knowledge. With that in mind, my vote remains on Scrafty for now.
Who's your prime suspect, Burb?
I feel like I'm going insane reading these posts. What the hell is going on here?
Personally I think two townies overreacting to each other. In a game with so many in actives, I doubt scum would get involved in a 1 Vs 1 yelling match.
Personally I think two townies overreacting to each other. In a game with so many in actives, I doubt scum would get involved in a 1 Vs 1 yelling match.
You're probably right, but shit, talk about muddying the waters.
Who's your prime suspect, Burb?
Honestly? Ouro, but that's based on my gut.
Based on actual reads, Xam.
Xamtheking
Member
Who's your top town?Honestly? Ouro, but that's based on my gut.
Based on actual reads, Xam.
Who's your top town?
Launchpad for the role claim, and Ty4on for contributing to the town generally lots.
Xamtheking
Member
That's a good point about ty4on, he has been doing a lot latelyLaunchpad for the role claim, and Ty4on for contributing to the town generally lots.
That's a good point about ty4on, he has been doing a lot lately
Xam, who are your top town?
Xamtheking
Member
Honestly?Xam, who are your top town?
Launch and Terra
Honestly?
Launch and Terra
Anyone outside of them?
Xamtheking
Member
So you have two town, but when I have two town suddenly it's not enough, lolAnyone outside of them?
No, I don't have any other solid town reads.
Maybe you, maybe Ouro, maybe Fireblend
Xamtheking
Member
I see now.I asked because you only named people who had roleclaimed. I atleast had Ty4on too.
If I had to pick a non-claimed townie, it would probably be Fireblend
Fire's push for gryvan... I don't really know. I mean, it does look a little odd, but lot of other people were pushing for Gryvan too, like Launch who I read as town at the moment. But scum could also easily jump for the Gryvan train as well.
I had a bit of a town read on Fire last night. For the most part he felt quite genuine while pushing gryvan and I sympathized with being more aggressive after Batman.
I wanted to hear more from him though so I hope he chimes in before dusk.
Timing
I see now.
If I had to pick a non-claimed townie, it would probably be Fireblend
Xamtheking
Member
we don't lynch inactives thoughIs salva really not coming to post?
we don't lynch inactives though
There's no reason why we can't lynch an inactive. I would be confident that there's at least one or two scum in that group of low posters (I know I'm included in that list).
Xamtheking
Member
batman says hiThere's no reason why we can't lynch an inactive. I would be confident that there's at least one or two scum in that group of low posters (I know I'm included in that list).
batman says hi
I didn't follow Batman that much so what happened there?
Xamtheking
Member
more dropouts than high schoolI didn't follow Batman that much so what happened there?
I didn't follow Batman that much so what happened there?
Karu
Coppanuva
Pop-O-Matic
Sorian
Were scum. Karu was and Pop were inactives and Pop was replaced. Coppa was also much more inactive than normal due to real life. Sorian was still Sorian.
What was Salva's last post? I think it was the TB thing, hasn'thasn't come back since.
I asked for Salva to wake up, and he literally responded with "I don't want to".
I asked for Salva to wake up, and he literally responded with "I don't want to".
I'm too cool for school.
we don't lynch inactives though
I see no problem with lynching in actives if I think they are scummy, but lynching people purely because they are inactive is not a good idea. We have a lot of in actives in this game, so that would just be a lottery at that point,and a lottery where scum can very easily hide behind.
Xamtheking
Member
yeahI see no problem with lynching in actives if I think they are scummy, but lynching people purely because they are inactive is not a good idea. We have a lot of in actives in this game, so that would just be a lottery at that point,and a lottery where scum can very easily hide behind.
I know