• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Game of Thrones *NO BOOK SPOILERS* |OT PART 2| Season 6 - [Read the OP]

Status
Not open for further replies.

Zereta

Member
Also: the reason we haven't seen Brienne back with the North Gang is totally because she is off being Captain Phasma right now, yes? Episode VIII is shooting right now if I'm not wrong.
 
is that the consensus, btw?

my girlfriend was like "uuuuuh, mountain rape? wtf?"

i was thinking it was more like, him breaking each of the bones in her body, one by one, with his brutish strength. Torturing her to death.

im with you

i didnt think 'rape' when the door was closed. more like violent torture. where did rape come from suddenly?

He doesn't matter to anyone.

awwwww :<

he's the true baratheon heir that could challenge cersei's reign...

....no? :<
 
seeing as he's utterly irrelevant for EVERYTHING by now ...
he might have been some fancy plot-twist seeing as he's the one true heir of ol' Bobby B., but noone in their right mind would try taking away the throne from Cersei now

didnt lilfinger / varys know of his bobby b's lineage though

maybe lil finger / the spider can worm it into their side's advantage

*wishful thinking*????
 

fisheyes

Member
What say you, friends

Will GENDRY return in S7 or not?

Of course he will.

Literally every other major character that isn't dead has come back this season. Gendry is, as far as the audience is concerned, the rightful holder of the throne. There must be something planned.

I'm thinking the red woman runs into him and something something.
 

Fliesen

Member
didnt lilfinger / varys know of his bobby b's lineage though

maybe lil finger / the spider can worm it into their side's advantage

*wishful thinking*????

Stannis had that 'advantage'.

lineage is all but irrelevant now. It's entirely about power now. (see: houses of the north refusing the call of house Stark, Kartstarks and Umbers even siding with house Bolton))
 

watershed

Banned
Awesome Season Finale, loving the fact that they are just going lightspeed now.

After that final shot with Cerci on the iron throne, I couldn't help but wonder if next season we'll maybe get a scene were Dany and Tyrion will get to kings landing, fight their way to the iron throne, smash open the doors and find none other then Jaime sitting on the throne once again with the "mad queen" dead at his feet. Just like all those years before.

I don't have any guesses as to the exact details, but I do think Jaime will kill Cersei just like he did the mad king and for the same reason of madness. Then I think he will kill himself.

Also, Sam has to be in that library to discover an ancient prophecy right?
 
Of course he will.

Literally every other major character that isn't dead has come back this season. Gendry is, as far as the audience is concerned, the rightful holder of the throne. There must be something planned.

I'm thinking the red woman runs into him and something something.

ooooh yes, melisandre ! and she's on her way south, too! interesting :>

Stannis had that 'advantage'.

lineage is all but irrelevant now. It's entirely about power now. (see: houses of the north refusing the call of house Stark, Kartstarks and Umbers even siding with house Bolton))

yeah, but im thinking maybe someone in ~power~ can use him as their pawn???
 
is that the consensus, btw?

my girlfriend was like "uuuuuh, mountain rape? wtf?"

i was thinking it was more like, him breaking each of the bones in her body, one by one, with his brutish strength. Torturing her to death.
I think its clear that rape was the main goal, I mean the mountain has already been established as a rapist and I can't see him mending her broken bones etc from torture and the way cersai spoke was along the lines of 'here is your new play thing to have your fun with'

Plus him taking his helmet off was the equivalent of him undressing to get down to business.
 

Fliesen

Member
ooooh yes, melisandre ! and she's on her way south, too! interesting :>



yeah, but im thinking maybe someone in ~power~ can use him as their pawn???

someone in ~power~ doesn't need some "maybe-maybe-not-the-bastard of the king we had 2 kings and a queen ago", i think.
LIINZFl.png

not a book reader, but does that commenter have a point?

I think its clear that rape was the main goal, I mean the mountain has already been established as a rapist and I can't see him mending her broken bones etc from torture and the way cersai spoke was along the lines of 'here is your new play thing to have your fun with'

Plus him taking his helmet off was the equivalent of him undressing to get down to business.

oh, ok. .... ewwww.
 

Einchy

semen stains the mountaintops
Why even discuss the show if you can wave away all logic and make up your own standards because "it's a show"?

Because I think it's ridiculous to tell someone, "you're cheering on a terrorist" almost as if this isn't a show and almost like we don't routinely cheer on horrible people. If we did this then all discussion would just boil down to, "you like The Mountain? Well, that means you're cheering on a rapist!.

I'm all for discussion every inch of this show, like anyone who has been following the GoT thread this season, but I find it a bit insulting to almost paint someone as a terrorist sympathizer because they like Cersei.

This reeks of people actually thinking thinking someone is a real life sociopath or a lesser human being in real life because they liked Walter White at the end of the show.

If that terrorist comment was purely in jest than I apologize but I've seen this same line of thinking in Breaking Bad discussions and I'd hate for people to bring it here.
 
I think Littlefinger was mocking Sansa in that scene. He was smiling at the fact that Jon the bastard was named King instead of Sansa the trueborn being named Queen. Sansa was also the one that won the battle for the Starks yet she still did not get the support of the Northern lords.

That's why her smile fades. She realizes that Littelfinger was right. The Northerners are her half-brother's army not her army. The North is loyal to Jon Snow not Sansa Stark. Sansa feels that she should be the one that is in charge but she's not.

That look from Littlefinger to Sansa was him saying that "I told you so". That's why her smile fades. This scene thus shows that there is potential for future conflict between Sansa and Jon over who should lead the North.
And that's some CW level drama. That's not what happens. Sansa knows who little finger is and what he wants. Jon being named king of the north means that little finger may not have the births support when he pushes for the crown. Sansa realized that Jon is a threat to what little finger wants. That's why she looks the way she does.
 

Monocle

Member
Because I think it's ridiculous to tell someone, "you're cheering on a terrorist" almost as if this isn't a show and almost like we don't routinely cheer on horrible people. If we did this then all discussion would just boil down to, "you like The Mountain? Well, that means you're cheering on a rapist!.

I'm all for discussion every inch of this show, like anyone who has been following the GoT thread this season, but I find it a bit insulting to almost paint someone as a terrorist sympathizer because they like Cersei.

This reeks of people actually thinking thinking someone is a real life sociopath or a lesser human being in real life because they liked Walter White at the end of the show.

If that terrorist comment was purely in jest than I apologize but I've seen this same line of thinking in Breaking Bad discussions and I'd hate for people to bring it here.
Oh, alright. I see where you're coming from and I agree. Cheering on fictional villains doesn't make an audience member a fan of real life tyrants or their atrocities.
 

Nibel

Member
is that the consensus, btw?

my girlfriend was like "uuuuuh, mountain rape? wtf?"

i was thinking it was more like, him breaking each of the bones in her body, one by one, with his brutish strength. Torturing her to death.

Why does he take his helmet and armor off then when he's perfectly capable to hurt someone with his armor on?

I think the implication here is clear tbh
 

Atomic Odin

Member
Anyone has that gif of the expression Mel gave Jon after Davos asked him to kill her?

It was the most perfect description of "Have mercy pleeez"
 

Einchy

semen stains the mountaintops
So just two left on Arya's list right? Cersei and Melisandre.

The Mountain

Beric Dondarrion

Thoros of Myr

Llyn Payne (the actor got cancer so he stopped being on the show but he has since beat it, who knows if he will ever come back)

I'm sure there are more but those are the ones that are still alive and that I remember.
 

Joco

Member
The Mountain

Beric Dondarrion

Thoros of Myr

Llyn Payne (the actor got cancer so he stopped being on the show but he has since beat it, who knows if he will ever come back)

I'm sure there are more but those are the ones that are still alive and that I remember.

I've forgotten a lot I see. Thanks for the refresher. Been a while since she's recited it on the show.
 

Paertan

Member
Mountain Rape? My first thought was he was gonna tear her eyes out. "Last face you will ever see" Ok she saw the mountains face but he aint exactly living. So my thought was he is gonna tear her eyes out and torture her and keep her in the dungeon until she dies.

I saw no sign of him moving into a position of raping her or any of the sort. I mean I would not put is passed Cersei or the Mountain, I just saw no inclination of rape.
 

EatChildren

Currently polling second in Australia's federal election (first in the Gold Coast), this feral may one day be your Bogan King.
Spent all day distracted at work thinking about this episode.
 

Heshinsi

"playing" dumb? unpossible
"You'll be queen. For a time. Then comes another, younger, more beautiful, to cast you down to take all you hold dear."

Poor Cersei. She was so certain the queen the prophecy referred to was Margaery and failed to see who was truly coming to put an end to her reign of terror.

tumblr_mn9xe1OJmc1rzxujso1_500.gif
 

Einchy

semen stains the mountaintops
"You'll be queen. For a time. Then comes another, younger, more beautiful, to cast you down to take all you hold dear."

Poor Cersei. She was so certain the queen the prophecy referred to was Margaery and failed to see who was truly coming to put an end to her reign of terror.

giphy.gif

g75GCd2.gif
 

watershed

Banned
Mountain Rape? My first thought was he was gonna tear her eyes out. "Last face you will ever see" Ok she saw the mountains face but he aint exactly living. So my thought was he is gonna tear her eyes out and torture her and keep her in the dungeon until she dies.

I saw no sign of him moving into a position of raping her or any of the sort. I mean I would not put is passed Cersei or the Mountain, I just saw no inclination of rape.

I think the implication was definitely rape. I think most people saw that scene that way because that's how it was intended.

Another musing, does Sansa have what it takes to out maneuver Little Finger? She only just started playing the game of thrones. He's been doing it his whole life. What if she somehow kills herself as a way to deny Little Finger what he wants and to expose him to others? Though I'm not sure he needs exposing.
 

hoos30

Member
It's kinda weird that people instantly concluded rape specifically. I mean... yeah, the mountain is going to torture her. So rape could be part of the package... but... why do people instantly think rape and rape only? Weird.
Remember Oberyn's speech at the Trial by Combat. The Mountain is infamous for raping and killing his sister. No need for it to take the mask off if the job is just to break Unella's bones. Cercei was going full throttle there. Disturbing.
 
For how much the show likes to make us suffer for killing off beloved characters they really have paid off with spectacular deaths of the most hated.

Viserys Targaryen- A Crown For A King
Joffrey Baratheon- Purple Wedding
Meryn Trant- Mutilated at the hands of Arya
Ramsay Bolton- Fed To the hounds
Walder Frey- The Rat Cook

Who's next?
 

Heshinsi

"playing" dumb? unpossible
The damage is done.

lol I'm sorry.

For how much the show likes to make us suffer for killing off beloved characters they really have paid off with spectacular deaths of the most hated.

Viserys Targaryen- A Crown For A King
Joffrey Baratheon- Purple Wedding
Meryn Trant- Mutilated at the hands of Arya
Ramsay Bolton- Fed To the hounds
Walder Frey- The Rat Cook

Who's next?

Cersei Lannister- Poisoned by her enemies.
 

Paertan

Member
I think the implication was definitely rape. I think most people saw that scene that way because that's how it was intended.

Apparently but what implications? I am gonna watch that part again this evening and check but I don't remember any part of the dialogue or his movement to suggest rape. Not like they haven't shown rape before pretty straight forward.
 

Einchy

semen stains the mountaintops
Apparently but what implications? I am gonna watch that part again this evening and check but I don't remember any part of the dialogue or his movement to suggest rape. Not like they haven't shown rape before pretty straight forward.
It's more to do with who The Mountain is and his affinity to raping and murdering.
 
But seriously, the whole "teleportation thing" could have been mostly fixed with a few nods of arriving or leaving at/from a certain location. Like when Theon and Yara suddenly appear in the throne room could have been salvaged by a tiny scene of their ships arriving at Mereen. Or the confusion of Varys on the ships could have also been remedied by putting Oleanna or the Dorne crew on another ship.
 

Paertan

Member
It's more to do with who The Mountain is and his affinity to raping and murdering.

Hmm true. I just don't really consider him The Mountain in that sense anymore since they revived him. I think of him as a mindless zombie who just follow orders.
 

Fliesen

Member
Apparently but what implications? I am gonna watch that part again this evening and check but I don't remember any part of the dialogue or his movement to suggest rape. Not like they haven't shown rape before pretty straight forward.

searching for "S06E10" in youtube, you can watch pretty much any scene from the last episode.
I just watched it again - he takes his helmet off, and you hear him do something with his armor (which could indiciate him loosening his belt or something like that) - multiple instances of chainmail rattling.
then again, he stands next to Unella when she already starts screaming in pain.

But seriously, the whole "teleportation thing" could have been mostly fixed with a few nods of arriving or leaving at/from a certain location. Like when Theon and Yara suddenly appear in the throne room could have been salvaged by a tiny scene of their ships arriving at Mereen. Or the confusion of Varys on the ships could have also been remedied by putting Oleanna or the Dorne crew on another ship.

this is the first time that i actually cared about the teleportation. Other times it's very nitpicky, but Varys 'appearing' in Dorne just to, minutes later, 'appear' on a ship going from Mereen back to Westeros was kinda jarring.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom