Support NeoGAF

[hythloday]

I knew it was gonna happen, but Grey Wind got me.

 

[jett]

I got a bit of chills and dem feels, I have to admit. But I don't think they nailed it. Still a good episode. Wish this show was better than it is.

 

[Fey]

"Ned loves my hair" was just in her thoughts, though, right, in the books? But I suppose it would have been nice/sad to see her say it.

 

[Zabka]

That was awesome. And terrible. I felt sick just knowing what was coming.

 

[Vio-Lence]

To be honest, TV Show Robb was a poorly developed character. I can't imagine the reactions will be as bad as when Ned was killed in season 1.

I think the Red Wedding was much more effective in the book.

 

[Forsaken82]

some people just don't understand how to enjoy this

oh well

There is no enjoyment in this moment... Not in the books, not in the show. It is a punch to the gut in both formats. That isn't to say its bad of course... it is certainly a moment that defines this series. But i fail to see how people get enjoyment from this. First time reactions are great and all, but who gives a shit if it ruins the moment?

With all that being said (asos)

Spoiler

I was disappointed with how they left Arya's arch at that moment. I liked the uncertainty to her fate, even though in the book it was pretty clear that she just got knocked out, the fact that the last thing she sees is the axe head makes it pretty ambiguous

 

[Count of Monte Sawed-Off]

The non-readers in the other thread loved this show, when loving it was safe.

 

[Willkiller]

I started shouting 'oh my god' when they started stabbing Jeyne in the stomach. Brutal

 

[Backwards Marathon]

"I'm not going to work tomorrow, they can go fuck themselves. I'm hurt."
-My roommate

 

[KINGofCRA5H]

I feel like I need a cigarette. I don't even smoke. I haven't even watched it yet!

 

[exYle]

To be honest, TV Show Robb was a poorly developed character. I can't imagine the reactions will be as bad as when Ned was killed in season 1.

I think the Red Wedding was much more effective in the book.

Dude, read the no book spoilers thread.
Three pages of meltdowns.

 

[DrForester]

I knew this would go down badly. Robb was built up so much more than in the books.

 

[Hystzen]

Robb Stark dies....

LOOK, It's not behind spoiler tags!

ASOS

Spoiler

by next year we don't have to hide Joffery, one spoiler de tagged at a time

 

[Uriah]

There is no enjoyment in this moment... Not in the books, not in the show. It is a punch to the gut in both formats. That isn't to say its bad of course... it is certainly a moment that defines this series. But i fail to see how people get enjoyment from this. First time reactions are great and all, but who gives a shit if it ruins the moment?

More like a stab to the gut amirite

 

[duckroll]

To be honest, TV Show Robb was a poorly developed character. I can't imagine the reactions will be as bad as when Ned was killed in season 1.

I think the Red Wedding was much more effective in the book.

I dunno, Robb is kinda cute. It's always a shame when a pretty boy dies!

 

[David Incorporated Esq.]

That look Bolton gives Catelyn. Ice cold.

 

[RELIGHT]

Hi guys, I'm from the No Book Spoilers thread and I just wanted to come in here and say how upset and disgusted and hurt I am over what just took place. I'm still in tears and I'm still shaking. I am contemplating not watching the show anymore because of this. First Ned in Season 1 then this. It's unbearable. I just need to know one thing right now in order for me to keep watching. Just answer yes or no:

Do the good guys get any justice whatsoever? And by justice I mean dead Joffrey. That's the only thing that can keep me watching at this point. I don't care if I'm spoiled. I want that piece of shit dead. And come to think of it I want all the Lannisters dead at this point.

Anyway. I'm going to go cry some more. FUCK!

 

[DrForester]

To be honest, TV Show Robb was a poorly developed character. I can't imagine the reactions will be as bad as when Ned was killed in season 1.

I think the Red Wedding was much more effective in the book.

Robb was a minor character in the books. He was elevated to main character in the show.

Hi guys, I'm from the No Book Spoilers thread and I just wanted to come in here and say how upset and disgusting and hurt I am over what just took place. I'm still in tears and I'm still shaking. I am contemplating not watching the show anymore because of this. First Ned in Season 1 then this. It's unbearable. I just need to know one thing right now in order for me to keep watching. Just answer yes or no:

Do the good guys get any justice whatsoever? And by justice I mean dead Joffrey. That's the only thing that can keep me watching at this point. I don't care if I'm spoiled. I want that piece of shit dead. And come to think of it I want all the Lannisters dead at this point.

Anyway. I'm going to go cry some more. FUCK!

Yes. There are lots of Starks left.

 

[fallengorn]

God, they did a great job. Everything leading up to it, I was starting to cringe slowly and slowly... and then the Rains of Castamere. It was just a bloody mess.

And the other thread. LOL.

 

[Mortimer Brewster]

I know they're glorious haha

Its amazing over there. Everyone threatening to quit watching. I got to hand it to the show producers, aside from a few nitpicks they pulled off the Red Wedding brilliantly. Now onto

Spoiler

The Purple Wedding and all the other awesome ASOS bits

.

 

[Zabka]

The book thread sends it's regards

 

[StriKeVillain]

Oh man, that left me a bit teary.

 

[ShinAmano]

So Cat's plea was hard to watch

 

[Willkiller]

Hi guys, I'm from the No Book Spoilers thread and I just wanted to come in here and say how upset and disgusting and hurt I am over what just took place. I'm still in tears and I'm still shaking. I am contemplating not watching the show anymore because of this. First Ned in Season 1 then this. It's unbearable. I just need to know one thing right now in order for me to keep watching. Just answer yes or no:

Do the good guys get any justice whatsoever? And by justice I mean dead Joffrey. That's the only thing that can keep me watching at this point. I don't care if I'm spoiled. I want that piece of shit dead. And come to think of it I want all the Lannisters dead at this point.

Anyway. I'm going to go cry some more. FUCK!

Series

Spoiler

He's still alive, and still killing people

 

[jett]

To be honest, TV Show Robb was a poorly developed character. I can't imagine the reactions will be as bad as when Ned was killed in season 1.

I think the Red Wedding was much more effective in the book.

It's the opposite actually, the show attempted to develop Robb much more and give him a bigger presence than in the books. However, I do agree that it wasn't as effective, not even close. Not that I'm surprised, this show is pretty mediocre by HBO standards.

 

[Erico]

I've read the books years ago, but have never seen a single episode of the show. I'm in a hotel and just happened to catch this episode on HBO.

Wow, this show is quite good. But I seem to remember in ASOS Cat Stark

Spoiler

killed a jester, not Frey's wife?

 

[TCRS]

copypasta

I really don't get book readers in here. You guys are really ruining the visceral reactions. In fact, gloating and castigating the tv-only viewers in here is counterintuitive to the schaudenfraude you all desperately want.

 

[Mortimer Brewster]

Hi guys, I'm from the No Book Spoilers thread and I just wanted to come in here and say how upset and disgusted and hurt I am over what just took place. I'm still in tears and I'm still shaking. I am contemplating not watching the show anymore because of this. First Ned in Season 1 then this. It's unbearable. I just need to know one thing right now in order for me to keep watching. Just answer yes or no:

Do the good guys get any justice whatsoever? And by justice I mean dead Joffrey. That's the only thing that can keep me watching at this point. I don't care if I'm spoiled. I want that piece of shit dead. And come to think of it I want all the Lannisters dead at this point.

Anyway. I'm going to go cry some more. FUCK!

All I can tell you TV show watchers is to hang in there and you will be rewarded.

 

[Deku Tree]

The Northerner's will never forget...

 

[Ingeniero]

Damn man, I will not sleep today, Cat's blood man for fuck sake.

 

[exYle]

Hi guys, I'm from the No Book Spoilers thread and I just wanted to come in here and say how upset and disgusted and hurt I am over what just took place. I'm still in tears and I'm still shaking. I am contemplating not watching the show anymore because of this. First Ned in Season 1 then this. It's unbearable. I just need to know one thing right now in order for me to keep watching. Just answer yes or no:

Do the good guys get any justice whatsoever? And by justice I mean dead Joffrey. That's the only thing that can keep me watching at this point. I don't care if I'm spoiled. I want that piece of shit dead. And come to think of it I want all the Lannisters dead at this point.

Anyway. I'm going to go cry some more. FUCK!

Edit: you know what, nevermind

 

[Wizerd]

That was awesome.

 

[dubq]

There is no enjoyment in this moment... Not in the books, not in the show. It is a punch to the gut in both formats. That isn't to say its bad of course... it is certainly a moment that defines this series. But i fail to see how people get enjoyment from this. First time reactions are great and all, but who gives a shit if it ruins the moment?

It's enjoyment because its a great fucking piece of writing. Both the lead up and the event itself.

 

[TCRS]

YO BRANN BETTER GET HIS FUCKING LEGS BACK MAN

I'm in tears haha

 

[Willkiller]

Oh shit. Edited. To be fair I'm quite drunk and very tired

 

[Atlantis]

So Cat's plea was hard to watch

Michelle Fairley is amazing.

 

[jett]

copypasta

People really need to stop being douches over there.


...


Then again, the people over there should think about reading a book one of these days. They don't bite!

 

[shadowkat]

Well done.

 

[DrForester]

http://insidetv.ew.com/2013/06/02/red-wedding-interview/

 

[fallengorn]

Season 4 MAJOR Spoilers:

Spoiler

Joffrey will die. He will die pathetically, just as he lived.

I'm sure once emotions (ASOS)

Spoiler

people will put two and two together and realize who else is going to get it.

 

[dubq]

Hi guys, I'm from the No Book Spoilers thread and I just wanted to come in here and say how upset and disgusted and hurt I am over what just took place. I'm still in tears and I'm still shaking. I am contemplating not watching the show anymore because of this. First Ned in Season 1 then this. It's unbearable. I just need to know one thing right now in order for me to keep watching. Just answer yes or no:

Do the good guys get any justice whatsoever? And by justice I mean dead Joffrey. That's the only thing that can keep me watching at this point. I don't care if I'm spoiled. I want that piece of shit dead. And come to think of it I want all the Lannisters dead at this point.

Anyway. I'm going to go cry some more. FUCK!

lol. this guy.

 

[Wazzy]

I haven't seen the episode yet but did they also

Spoiler

"kill" Arya?

I know that might be a bit too much for viewers but I thought it would just be another big blow.

 

[Pollux]

When is this on HBO GO?

 

[Forsaken82]

It's enjoyment because its a great fucking piece of writing. Both the lead up and the event itself.

I am talking about the enjoyment people are getting from gloating to non book readers about "OMG Been waiting years to see these reactions!! SUCK IT TV VIEWERS!" It is just over the top and unnecessary and turns an otherwise excessively dramatic moment into arguably a joke. In my opinion it diminishes the moment. Thankfully I read it before i saw the show, but I can't help to feel if I was a non book reader, reading through that thread, id be kind of pissed at how the moment has basically become an inside joke.

 

[Ingeniero]

Well done.

10/10

 

[Atlantis]

I haven't seen the episode yet but did they also

Spoiler

"kill" Arya?

I know that might be a bit too much for viewers but I thought it would just be another big blow.

No.

 

[Atsumi]

This was the first episode my mom decided to sit with me while I watched it.

My heart was pounding the entire episode and when I heard Rains of Castamere I was literally shaking. She had to hear me heave and see my tears and I'm really embarrassed.

 

[Admiral Bone to Pick]

Hi guys, I'm from the No Book Spoilers thread and I just wanted to come in here and say how upset and disgusted and hurt I am over what just took place. I'm still in tears and I'm still shaking. I am contemplating not watching the show anymore because of this. First Ned in Season 1 then this. It's unbearable. I just need to know one thing right now in order for me to keep watching. Just answer yes or no:

Do the good guys get any justice whatsoever? And by justice I mean dead Joffrey. That's the only thing that can keep me watching at this point. I don't care if I'm spoiled. I want that piece of shit dead. And come to think of it I want all the Lannisters dead at this point.

Anyway. I'm going to go cry some more. FUCK!

The revenge you seek shall be yours in time.

Maybe.

 

[Willkiller]

'The Lannisters send their regards' is now my favourite TV show line of all time.

 

[Lonestar]

Karmic Justice, perhaps, but not True justice.

Tywin Love him some Letter Writing.