• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Gametrailers Thread: Good Night and Good Game

U

UrbanRats

Member
IdreamofHIME said:
We're not really allowed to talk about the game at the center of this weeks Mandatory Update, but I found it pretty ridiculous 5 people knew almost nothing about the game outside of a vague basic concept were boiling it down to "well you shoot cops in gta".
I really love you guys, but MU nights is fast and loose...but that was pretty poor journalism.
Click to expand...

lil said:
Is it bad that I don't even have to watch it to know what game it must be? The thing is infamous at this point.
Click to expand...

Postal would've been a better comparison than GTA.
Hatred just blew out of proportion because of the developers' background, in my opinion, otherwise nobody would've given a shit.
There are far "worse" games out there, especially since they brought up porn games, lol.

Anyhow, i don't think even they would classify that as a journalistic talk in any way shape or form.

I do think going in with the mentality of having to do a comparison, like Huber said he'll do, is the wrong approach tho.
As shitty as you think a game is, it should be getting a fair chance still, IF you're going to review it, otherwise don't bother, which is also fine.
As Ian mentioned, "don't go in with an hypothesis".
 
B

Brad Grenz

Member
It's a total rerun of Postal in every way. Game looks the same, appears to play the same and the developers have courted the exact same controversy for the exact same reason. That's the worst thing about it: it's completely unoriginal.
 
M

Mariolee

Member
Holy shit I just started watching Tabletop Adventures and am now convinced it is one of the most hilarious content ever put out by GT. I laugh consistently and Huber's one lines SLAY ME.
 
H

Hasney

Member
Mariolee said:
Holy shit I just started watching Tabletop Adventures and am now convinced it is one of the most hilarious content ever put out by GT. I laugh consistently and Huber's one lines SLAY ME.
Click to expand...

Did you start from episode 1? If so, amazingly, Huber only gets better.
 
H

Hasney

Member
Mariolee said:
No I started on last week's episode and then watched this week's. So good.
Click to expand...

Still need to watch this weeks but yeah, last week was great!

There's a recap episode on the YouTube playlist too if you ever feel like hearing what happened in the previous episodes.
 
H

Hasney

Member
Finally got the latest episode of tabletop done, holy shit. Can Ben make a plan without Hoggar ruining it? It's fantastic.
 
Fbh

Fbh

Member
IdreamofHIME said:
We're not really allowed to talk about the game at the center of this weeks Mandatory Update, but I found it pretty ridiculous 5 people knew almost nothing about the game outside of a vague basic concept were boiling it down to "well you shoot cops in gta".
I really love you guys, but MU nights is fast and loose...but that was pretty poor journalism.
Click to expand...

I really don't know where gamers got this idea that as long as you record yourself talking about something it automatically becomes "journalism".

When Bradon goes to E3 Judges week (or someone else to some other event) and comes back to talk about what he learned about the games he played or when he uploads an interview with the devs of Diseny Infinity or when he interviews someone in GT Live, that's journalism. Reviews and previous too, like Ben reviewsing Splatoon or when Bloodworth went to the preview event and made the preview

But just sitting in fron of a camera in a pretty relaxed way and record what's basically you and a few friends talking about videogames is hardly "Journalism"
 
S

SeanTSC

Member
Fbh said:
I really don't know where gamers got this idea that as long as you record yourself talking about something it automatically becomes "journalism".

When Bradon goes to E3 Judges week (or someone else to some other event) and comes back to talk about what he learned about the games he played or when he uploads an interview with the devs of Diseny Infinity or when he interviews someone in GT Live, that's journalism. Reviews and previous too, like Ben reviewsing Splatoon or when Bloodworth went to the preview event and made the preview

But just sitting in fron of a camera in a pretty relaxed way and record what's basically you and a few friends talking about videogames is hardly "Journalism"
Click to expand...

Yeah, besides, GT has never really been a "Journalism" site. They're Critics and Enthusiasts. They've never really (seriously) done News or Editorials or Investigation pieces. They were primarily about Reviews and Hosting Trailers before and now they're about that and Personality Shows. There's also a big difference between being a Critic (which is what they've always been) and a Journalist.
 
S

so1337

Member
Huber's display of warm caress on ManUp Nights was truly beautiful.

gIHhvst.gif


If you don't get this, look at the Youtube comment section of any (and I mean any) video with Huber in it.
 
I

IdreamofHIME

Member
Fbh said:
I really don't know where gamers got this idea that as long as you record yourself talking about something it automatically becomes "journalism".

When Bradon goes to E3 Judges week (or someone else to some other event) and comes back to talk about what he learned about the games he played or when he uploads an interview with the devs of Diseny Infinity or when he interviews someone in GT Live, that's journalism. Reviews and previous too, like Ben reviewsing Splatoon or when Bloodworth went to the preview event and made the preview

But just sitting in fron of a camera in a pretty relaxed way and record what's basically you and a few friends talking about videogames is hardly "Journalism"
Click to expand...


Huber says he wants to do the review because he wants to directly compare it to GTA. That's journalism...and it's bad.
 
G

grounded_dreams

Member
I got into Tabletop Adventures when I saw episode 25 appear, watched about 20 minutes loved the style etc and decided to backtrack and watch from the very beginning.
I'm currently upto episode 4, and it is incredible to see how they have progressed in regards to how their characters interaction with each other and GM from these early stages upto the present day.Also early on all of them seemed very unsure of the game mechanics and the description of what is currently happening goes go into way to much detail, which is vastly refined from what I saw in episode 25.

In episode 4 they are using a whiteboard and a second camera to show all of Ben's drawings/area layouts etc. Anyone know why they stopped using this device? It wasn't there on episode 25. Seems to enhance the viewing experience greatly.

Not sure why I never watched this earlier, love D&D and always watch everything else Gametrailers publishes, think it was due to getting into this later and thinking it was too late to catch up [which it isn't of course].
 
H

Hasney

Member
grounded_dreams said:
I got into Tabletop Adventures when I saw episode 25 appear, watched about 20 minutes loved the style etc and decided to backtrack and watch from the very beginning.
I'm currently upto episode 4, and it is incredible to see how they have progressed in regards to how their characters interaction with each other and GM from these early stages upto the present day.Also early on all of them seemed very unsure of the game mechanics and the description of what is currently happening goes go into way to much detail, which is vastly refined from what I saw in epsiode 25.

In episode 4 they are using a second camera to show all of Ben's drawings/area layouts etc. Anyone know why they stopped using this device? Seems to enhance the viewing experience greatly.

Not sure why I never watched this earlier, love D&D and always watch everything else Gametrailers publishes, think it was due to getting into this later and thinking it was too late to catch up [which it isn't of course].
Click to expand...

I think it was because it turned into a Hubers Face cam, plus Ben has simplified most of the recent encounters and exploration to not need a map.
 
A

Auctopus

Member
Probably the best LITL so far.

Elyse really surprised me in this episode. It's really weird how she explains her love of the underdog character and it's edited in with friggin' Batman...but I'm definitely with her that Ellie is an overrated character. I wasn't expecting her comment about Quelaag, I'm sure Iain can tell her the backstory.

N.B. I will never understand comments like Andrea's: "I never got in to this series, I don't get what's so great about the protagonist?" Well... play the games and you'll find out?
 
D

Don Draper's Hat

Member
Stephanie Bayer (I think her name is (the red haired one)) was at it again. Every single time she appeared she laughed at her own comments. EVERY. SINGLE. TIME. I have no idea why it annoys me, but it does.
 
A

Auctopus

Member
Supermanisdead said:
lmao, that guy is everywhere
Click to expand...

I thought it was weird at first, then sorta funny, now it's sort of sad. I think it's just someone crying for attention.

I don't like how he sees himself as part of the community, when people confront him about it, it's clearly not a joke. He doesn't like Huber.
 
I

IdreamofHIME

Member
I'm gonna be talking about game endings, if you don't want to be spoiled...just fastforward until a new game title appears at the top of the screen.

Great idea Huber!

Talks about the last games ending in the next game section

*face palm*
 
Y

yoplay

Member
The staff height section was marvelous. I laughed when bloodworth showed up like "come at me."

But damn, I'm 5'8-5'9 =T
 
V

Volotaire

Member
Given Geoff is not cohosting this year's SPIKE and Gametrailers E3 Coverage this year from a press conference viewpoint, I was wondering what GT's plans are for this year.
 
L

lil

Member
One of the best Bosmans in a while. Solid advice all around. :)

I watch every press conference every year, but there's no way I'm watching the "PC Gaming Show." No way. I won't do it and you can't make me. *hairflip*
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

  • Locked
Easy Allies |EZOT| Good Vibes and Good Hype
396 397 398 399 400
20K
2M
Auctopus replied
  • Locked
Former GameTrailers Crew Announcement 03.21.2016
5 6 7 8 9
425
70K
MMarston replied
GameTrailers to close after 13 years
98 99 100 101 102
5K
669K
GamingOblivion replied
Top Bottom