I think the only thing I've really disagreed with them on is Street Fighter V. I can see where they're coming from in terms of being disappointing and being a hot mess, as boy are there a bunch of issues surrounding that game, but as a casual fan I still really like playing it. I got it during the first week of release, well aware of the issues and shortcomings, and kind of just accepted it. It's a game I've been returning to throughout the year, and I can thank it for being the catalyst that helped my cousin and I to start hanging out again.
I also rather play it than Street Fighter 4. 4 just never clicked for me, even during the brief time I went back to it prior to 5's release. Prior to 5, when I wanted to play SF I just played Third Strike or Alpha 3.