Support NeoGAF

[Lucifers Beard]

I'm not betting my default avatar but as much as I absolutely love God of War Ragnarok so far. Elden Ring is something else and probably my favourite game of all time. Unforgettable, intense gaming experience that only comes around every so often.

 

[Vick]

I'm amazed how many people either got early copies or stayed up and completed GoWR already.

Only member of this Forum who legit completed both, that I know of at least, is also a reviewer and said Ragnarok is his GOTY over Elden Ring.

 

[Denton]

Neither. But of these two, GoW.

 

[Vick]

97 is outdated score, it's 95

It's actually 96 for the PS5 version.
But it only got 84 reviews vs a whopping 126 for Ragnarok, that's basically 50 additional reviews. With a similar number of entries the game was 95.

Still, doesn't mean much. Just leave the fanboys be.

 

[Shubh_C63]

Its a win win situation.

If Elden Ring wins, I win. If GoWR wins, I get to rock a Gow avatar so I win again.

 

[Tg89]

Elden Ring. FROM is the best dev in the industry.

GoW is cool, though.

 

[Thief1987]

It's actually 96 for the PS5 version.
But it only got 84 reviews vs a whopping 126 for Ragnarok, that's basically 50 additional reviews. With a similar number of entries the game was 95.

Still, doesn't mean much. Just leave the fanboys be.

Or 94 for pc version. For multiplatform titles it's reasonable to use opencritic as they are not separating by platforms.

 

[Die Namek Ability]

It's going to be Elden Ring:

1. Higher MC scores
2. Geoff is friends with Miyazaki
3. Ragnarok is very similar to it's predecessor.

Rip i didnt read doh. Its just Geoffs award and your points are bang on.

 

[MadPanda]

I'm not saying GoW will win but Red Dead Redemption II had a higher metacritic than GoW 2018 and GoW still won Goty lol

And RDR2 was robbed, let's be real. Completed both games but RDR2 is one of a kind game.

 

[Ghost of Caelid]

So 150 randomly generated caves in every openworld game become a norm? Please no.

More so a focus on superb visual design instead of relying on UI to tell you where everything is. Also interesting activities and rewards for exploration that isn't "enemy camp".

 

[Kacho]

Team Miyazaki

 

[James Sawyer Ford]

And RDR2 was robbed, let's be real. Completed both games but RDR2 is one of a kind game.

Minus having fun gameplay

Pretty important

 

[kyliethicc]

Rules

• Votes are publicly available
• You CAN NOT change your vote
• Voters are able to suggest losers' avatar
• Only participants (voters) are able to make avatar suggestions
• Honorable judges will pick and make available a pool of the suggested avatars for losers to use
• Losers' avatar should be changed upon losing the bet
• Avatars must be used until 12:01am 1/1/2023
• OP won't participate in order to be unbiased in avatar selection. His vote is only to be able to see voters list.
• BY VOTING YOU ARE PARTICIPATING IN THE BET
• NO OTHER GOTY CONTENDERS WILL BE CONSIDERED
• AVATAR BET IS VOIDED IF NEITHER WIN
• VIDEO GAME AWARDS ON DECEMBER 8th (Hosted by Geoff Keighley)

The avatar bet thread for GOW:R was such fun, I thought, why not create another one?

(Shoutout to .Pennywise for the excellent thread template)

the goty award ... at what award show?

 

[Topher]

And RDR2 was robbed, let's be real. Completed both games but RDR2 is one of a kind game.

RDR 2 wasn't robbed at all. It received 178 GOTY awards that year.

 

[GhostOfTsu]

They had more than enough 10/10 to make a full image but the graphic designer was too humble. It's dumb.

97 > 94

97 > 94

2 year old can figure it out.

Spoiler

Not that I care

It's not 97 anymore, they made it too early. You replied too early too. Go check next time

 

[MidGenRefresh]

They had more than enough 10/10 to make a full image but the graphic designer was too humble. It's dumb.


It's not 97 anymore, they made it too early. You replied too early too. Go check next time

Bravo. Exactly. So can we stop mentioning Metacritics average as you just proven it means shit?

 

[BootsLoader]

Lmao same here. Oh well. Hope Elden Ring wins or i might have to take a break from Neogaf till next year

A word once given…..
I will play by the rules.

 

[lughnasadh123]

"More of the same" seems to unfairly wear more on GoWR than it does Elden Ring. For that alone I'd wager ER getting GoTY.

 

[ResurrectedContrarian]

The narrative for Elden Ring is original and much harder to pull off than God of War.

Just like with Bloodborne before it, I agree.

These games give you sense of entering a truly other world, with an overwhelming tone of danger of strangeness that is unlike anything else.

The GOW franchise is more like a typical TV show or movie plot. It's not where gaming should go... gaming sucks at movie plots and should go the exact opposite direction, move hard into environmental storytelling and let devs stop fooling themselves, even the highest budget games would make B-tier movies at best if you play them on a screen without a controller.

 

[Boneless]

True gods love both. Ive put 100 hours in Elden Ring. GoW? I dont know, Ive just started.

 

[NeoIkaruGAF]

Why do PlayStation fans always come up with such images? I don't get it. Do they really care that game got 10s from We got this covered, JVL, nextgenbase and similar?

A hole is a hole.
A ten is a ten.

The amount of sweat and salt to come out of this year's Game Awards will be more epic than both games combined.

 

[The Stig]

Not voting but I just want to register how weird it is that people are fighting over this GOTY stuff. The games aren't even similar.

Also as a veteran of the true great console war (SNES/Megadrive) it's depressing watching people get tribal over which console they own.

 

[Madflavor]

Elden Ring. GoW:R is more of the same, but a bit better. That's a great thing btw. But Elden Ring was one of those generation defining games. It landed in the gaming scene like a fucking meteor, and it's impact cannot be denied. As great as GoW:R is, people will play it and then move on. Elden Ring will still be played and discussed for years to come, and the gaming community will collectively lose their shit when the trailer for the sequel hits.

 

[bbeach123]

They're both more of the same ,but atleast Elden ring is not a expansion dlc .

 

[proandrad]

ER is better but GoW will win most awards because it will be more fresh in people's minds.

 

[rickybooby87]

the goty award ... at what award show?

It's the Video Game Awards on Dec 8th. I need to enlarge that text lol.

 

[kyliethicc]

It's the Video Game Awards on Dec 8th. I need to enlarge that text lol.

you mean The Game Awards?

 

[rickybooby87]

you mean The Game Awards?

Yeh. I need to edit that.

 

[hemo memo]

• You CAN NOT change your vote

I didn't think this through…

 

[EverydayBeast]

I don't care how good elden ring is everyone says it's good, kratos is a crucial character to Sony.

 

[KungFucius]

After playing only an hour of GoW, it will be ER, though I generally hate soulslikes. Maybe GoW will click and suck me in, but ER had great exploration just shitty gameplay and story outside of that that effectively just made the game a chore after 40 or so hours.

 

[Raonak]

perfectly paced masterpiece >>> another openworld game with the same copy-paste same souls combat since 2009.

 

[Thief1987]

perfectly paced masterpiece >>> another openworld game with the same copy-paste same souls combat since 2009.

It's not the same, there is jump button now!

 

[ZoukGalaxy]

but at least Elden ring is not a expansion dlc .

You're right, it's an open world DLC

 

[Imtjnotu]

God of War has this in the bag

 

[ElCasual]

When the end credits of Elden roll out I really thanked god for finish that repetitive game.

 

[Madflavor]

perfectly paced masterpiece >>> another openworld game with the same copy-paste same souls combat since 2009.

I'm 20 hours into GoW:R and I can't agree with this.

 

[Rush2112]

funny how GoW fans call elden ring repetitive.

 

[fart town usa]

I've never played GOW 2018 and don't plan on playing Ragnarok so please discard my opinion but Elden Ring is the GOTY. The game is just absolutely brilliant with its exploration, coop, PvP, etc. GOW looks polished beyond belief but I just don't see at all how it can rival what it offers when compared directly to ER.

ER is near endless with things to discover. I've put in almost 200 hours of pure gameplay and still find all kinds of areas and items I overlooked. It's straight up an 11/10 game.

 

[Orpheum]

Elden ring was good but i didn't enjoy it nearly as much as other Fromsoft titles. I've only been able to play the intro from GoW ragnarök but this shit slapped so hard that if the rest of the game is better than the first one, i have to go with God of war here

 

[Dynasty8]

Love both games, but I'll give it to Elden Ring.

 

[Boss Man]

Ragnarok so far is just a God of War (2018) expansion with training wheels on.

Elden Ring was a proper evolution of a series that has created its own genre. It was an international phenomenon and will heavily influence other games throughout the rest of this generation.

Ragnarok will probably win GOTY though and everyone knows why.

 

[Danjin44]

I enjoyed Elden Ring and currently enjoying GOWR but for me personally Bayonetta 3 is my GOTY but if we are talking about VGA shows I guess it going to be between Elden Ring and GOWR.

 

[Borowski_1]

Mid Ring

 

[Thief1987]

GOW looks polished beyond belief but I just don't see at all how it can rival what it offers when compared directly to ER.

It's not that hard to rival a 7/10 game, you know. And if you haven't played GOW your opinion is disqualified, sorry.

 

[Agent_4Seven]

Spoiler

A Plague Tale: Requiem

 

[fart town usa]

It's not that hard to rival a 7/10 game, you know. And if you haven't played GOW your opinion is disqualified, sorry.

7/10 for ER is a bait reply but to each their own.

FWIW, I didn't play GOW 2018 because Kratos, to me at least, is arguably one of the most irritating characters in all of gaming history. I know the new games address that directly but it's still not enough to make me interested. I have no interest in father/son melodrama when the character was awful to begin with.

 

[Thief1987]

7/10 for ER is a bait reply but to each their own.

FWIW, I didn't play GOW 2018 because Kratos, to me at least, is arguably one of the most irritating characters in all of gaming history. I know the new games address that directly but it's still not enough to make me interested. I have no interest in father/son melodrama when the character was awful to begin with.

It's not a bait, it's my opinion. I played, finished and platinumed this game, so it's perfectly valid. Contrary to your "don't know how GOW can surpass it". And, mind you, i still never said that GOW is better, because i played very little of it. I'm only arguing with indusputability of Elden Ring's "victory".

 

[fart town usa]

It's not a bait, it's my opinion. I played, finished and platinumed this game, so it's perfectly valid. Contrary to your "don't know how GOW can surpass it". And, mind you, i still never said that GOW is better, because i played very little of it. I'm only arguing with indusputability of Elden Ring's "victory".

fair enough, can't argue with that.

 

[thegame983]

10 hours into GOW and i was a tad dissapointed. 12 hours in and I'm quite underwhelmed. I assume it will pick up but Elden Ring for me.