• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Grand Theft Auto V |OT| It's Time To Go Home

Status
Not open for further replies.

Alienous

Member
Metacritic should automatically curve Tom Chick. Or just not count his scores, that's fine.

They do need a way to review, and potentially exclude, outliers that can skew the results. If your score isn't even close to the imaginary median score, over a multitude of games, then your reviews should be given less weight or even ignored, because you don't represent public opinion.

Skewing by publication doesn't make sense when you have individual baiting reviewers. And it is irritating when a standard isn't maintained across all of your scores; TLOU can be a 7, sure, but not when you give a game with far greater flaws and less ambition an 8.

Well, GAF impressions are what I go by now anyway.
 

FStop7

Banned
It'll get a 95 or so and then in 2 years people will look back on it and ask "WTF where they thinking?" just like they do for every high scoring game.
 

MormaPope

Banned
No year had the insane number of classics and just "good" games as 2004. These debates have started up a lot on gaf lately so I've gone back and looked at most of the years from 08 to 97 and 04 was ridiculously stacked. As great as some years were like 98 there weren't as many games being released back then.

On a side note when I was making goty lists for the years from this generation, just out of boredom one night, I thought I would struggle only picking 10 games from 2007. What I was surprised to find out was how overrated that year was. I barely squeaked 10 out before the end of the year and if it wasn't for November I would have ended with like 5 or 6 games total.

2004 will never be beat. 2007 was a good year but it doesn't come close to 2004, not at all.
 

lem0n

Member
It'll get a 95 or so and then in 2 years people will look back on it and ask "WTF where they thinking?" just like they do for every high scoring game.

There are some games that hold up. San Andreas, for example. That was a genuinely epic game.

I believe that V will be held in the same regard.
 
2004 will never be beat. 2007 was a good year but it doesn't come close to 2004, not at all.

1994 would like a word with you. Master of Orion and X-COM on the same day even. TIE Fighter, Master of Magic, Warcraft, Jagged Alliance, Super Metroid, Donkey Kong Country, Tekken, System Shock, etc. Oh, and Playstation.
 

lem0n

Member
Who are y'all most excited about playing as?

At first it was Michael but I'm all in with Franklin.

I'm looking forward to playing as Michael the most. But just barely, they all look pretty intriguing. I think I'll enjoy Franklin's missions the most, since I like driving more than anything else.
 

tookhster

Member
Who are y'all most excited about playing as?

At first it was Michael but I'm all in with Franklin.

I'm honestly in love with all three now. Michael because I wanna see how it feels like to be the rich family man. Franklin because he's young and I can relate to him, plus I like the whole gang war aspect. And Trevor because I wanna just do crazy shit with him.

BTW, great job on the OT, man! I thought I was reading something official lol.
 

Kvik

Member
Franklin. Mostly because I'd always imagine he'd be like Stringer Bell in his younger days. Smarter than everyone else around him.
 

gosox333

Member
After all the backlash reviewers got for their IV reviews, I seriously doubt everybody out there will be ready to plop a 100 or 10/10 or whatever a perfect score might be onto this game. There's no way V's getting a higher meta rating than IV because of that, regardless of the game's quality.

I'll guess....95
 

Lonestar

I joined for Erin Brockovich discussion
All 3 seem like they have interesting story and characters to them.

Seems like, if any of the 3 could be "good guys", it'd be Franklin. He understands the idiocy in his surroundings, and seems like he's using his smarts and abilities to better himself. While Michael is a bored, midlife crisis Bank Robber-turned Yuppie, and Trevor is Evil Charlie Kelly from IASIP (WILDCARD BITCHES)

Can't wait to see what kinds of side characters each will have. Not sure I like Franklins "buddy" (is it Lamar?) but I do hope for some similar characteristics to CJ's crew (Big Smoke 2.0 please). Michael's side seems to be his family, which could be interesting, since they seem to have Soprano-type traits. Trevor's friends...geez, they've got to be nuts to be friends of Trevor.
 

ironcreed

Banned
Who are y'all most excited about playing as?

At first it was Michael but I'm all in with Franklin.

I don't know. All three have a little something going for them that adds to the GTA flavor. Franklin is just a boss, Trevor is batshit insane and Michael has the vibe of an older, settled down Tommy Vercetti that wants back in the game. We are really getting a little of everything we could want with these characters, plus our own custom character for the online world. It's win-win.
 

JAY the BIRD

Neo Member
Hey this is RumblePhish from Reddit [different name on gaf]...

Posted some new GTA V stuff:

Pulp Fiction:
pNBGggy.jpg

Training Day:
 

AOC83

Banned
98

There is no way the gaming press can rate this lower than GTA IV without losing every single bit of credibility they may have left.

I agree btw that obvious clickbait and joke reviews like from polygon and this Tom Chick guy should be banned from Metacritic.
 
Kvikmyndahús;81162061 said:
I'll recommend watching Collateral as well. Say what you will about Cruise, but he was great in it.

"Collateral" kicks major ass!

As you said - say what you will about Tom Cruise - he may be ambiguous in some ways - but he can fucking act.

[SPOILERS FOR "COLLATERAL" TO FOLLOW]

I love the shootout/fight at Club Fever most of all; but delving deeper into the film, I love how Vincent is adamant that Max buy his mother flowers at the hospital gift shop - so much so, that he buys them himself.

A moment later, Vincent feels proud that Max's mother likes that he's the one that bought her the flowers - almost to assuage a mother/son anguish that he has felt his entire life.
[Michael Mann and Tom Cruise worked out a very elaborate back story regarding Vincent and this was a part of it].

I like how Vincent is a cold, calculating bad-ass; yet, if you pay attention - he has a slight desire to leave his life of work-ups, assassination and wetwork.

I especially like how the wolves/coyotes crossing the streets of Los Angeles have very different meanings for both of the protagonists at that moment in the film and most of all - I love how at the end, Vincent becomes the story he heard about years ago - he becomes the dead man at night on the MTA that nobody notices for hours.....as the train makes it's lonely rounds.

[END SPOILERS FOR "COLLATERAL"]

Only Michael Mann's "Heat" can top "Collateral" - and only "Grand Theft Auto V" can top them both because we as players will get to live through films like these due to the narrative of exceptional games such as GTAV.

I also love that both Neil McCauley [Robert DeNiro in Heat] and Vincent [Tom Cruise in Collateral] in Michael Mann's movies wear the same grey suit with a white Armani shirt - and how Michael in GTAV wears the same outfit. [Pacino's character in "Heat' is named Vincent Hanna, by the way.] All I need on my character-of-choice is some graying hair, or perhaps a DeNiro goatee for certain missions to re-immerse myself in Michael Mann's vision of L.A.

My movies to view before playing GTAV:

Heat
Collateral
Thief
Manhunter
To Live and Die In L.A.
Goodfellas
Casino
The Town
Drive
The Driver
The French Connection
Flawless
Oceans 11
Oceans 13
The Thomas Crown Affair
Now You See Me
The Italian Job
Scarface
Mission Impossible
Entrapment
Romancing The Stone
Sexy Beast
The Salton Sea
Training Day
Trance
Dog Day Afternoon
The Usual Suspects
Reservoir Dogs
Man On A Ledge
The Sting
The Score
Ronin
Lock, Stock and Two Smoking Barrels
Snatch
Inside Man
Heist
Layer Cake
The Getaway
Payback
Thunderbolt and Lightfoot
Jackie Brown
The Bank Job
Point Break
2 Days in the Valley
Donnie Brasco
Goldfinger
For Your Eyes Only
A View To A Kill
Catch Me If You Can [1989]
Catch Me If You Can [2002]
The Godfather: Part II
Pulp Fiction
The Departed
Eastern Promises
A History of Violence
Once Upon a Time in America
Carlito's Way
Léon: The Professional
Menace II Society
We Own the Night
American Me
King of New York
Blow
Suicide Kings
Confidence
The Cooler
Legend
Risky Business
Three O'clock High


[Currently listening to Coldplay's "Atlas" and Tangerine Dream's Sorcerer "Betrayal" [skip to 3:26] as I type this].
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom