No it doesn't. People just want to be melodramatic. Almost every single post in here is about the series or the games now. Who cares if it's extremely negative? It's still on topic and about Halo. No one is really being super hateful or insulting either.
Plus, issues are being worked out amongst ourselves rather than people PM'ing several mods for intervention.
If anything complaining it's too negative, saying people are whining is probably the stuff that shouldn't be said.
Seriously. God, I mean I'm not remotely old guard and people think HaloGAF is bad
now? There were pages where people were posting their ignore lists for Christ's sake and it seemed like half the people hadn't played Halo in months (this is in the 4 days).
Lots of people are being negative because Halo 5 is already looking like it's changed things a lot, and so far changing Halo's formula has not really worked out for most hardcore fans (which if you're here, you are almost by definition such a fan). And then there's MCC, which barely functions for a lot of use cases (like trying to play with your friends).
We can pretend that things are sunshine and lollipops or we can talk about interesting issues, which are often negative (or we could all pick something good and agree on it,
exciting).
As for Halo
, the H2C Carbine is broken in MM (thank you's go out to the scrubs I played on Ivory Tower the other night), but since it's not too common on the maps it's hasn't been a huge deal
so far. The second a 49-49 tie is broken by it though, it's going to be rage time.