I posted this in the FUD gaming side thread but I figured I would post it here. The following are my opinions, and while critical I tried to be constructive-
Ok, so my first impressions are as follows: This has a high budget, fan student film project look and feel. Part of this is due to the youth of the actors, which of course has to do with the story, but none the less it gives that vibe. The color correction honestly feels a little cheap, it really has that made for youtube vibe, and while yes I know this is meant to air on the internet, that doesn't mean it should look like it. I hope the color correction is just placeholder until they finish the actual editing of the project. The dialogue in the trailer felt very cheesy, but sometimes trailers cause that issue. Also, I'm not super fond of the editing cinematography, but its not awful by any count.
Master Chief looks awkward in action, he was just filmed in a weird, kinda of cheesy way. (he looks near perfect in this behind the scenes footage though!) Another issue, IMO, is the visor. While I know it was made by Oakley, it just doesn't looks right. It feels very out of place unfortunately.. Im not exactly sure what the issue is per say, but I don't like it. On the flip side, the visors on the Spartans in "Deliver Hope" did not suffer from this. "Deliver Hope" also highlights that the paint app on MC's suit could look a bit better, a more metallic and worn look would have been more natural IMO.
The ARs seen in the trailer also suffer from the same issues as MC, they kinda look awkward and out of place. The paint app looks more plastic if anything, and they seem to have no weight behind them and come off more like a toy.
Anyways, I know this is still in production, so Im sure a lot of the issues may feel minor after its all said and done. Also, that Warthog looks amazing, both in detail and in action.. Awesome stuff there! Im still really excited for this, but visually compared to past Halo live action shorts I am a bit underwhelmed. Still, I can't wait to see the Covenant in action, it really seems they nailed the way MC moves from the BTS stuff, so I expect the same with them.
Agreed, although I understand the budget has to go a lot further with FUD, the style doesn't have to take such a huge hit. Shame MC looks so cheesy.
My favorite scene ever in a Halo Liveaction.
So good.
Posted by Grizzlei over at HBO's forum - holding off until morning for front page:
http://www.youtube.com/user/solocorps?feature=watch
Top 4 vids are interviews with cast/crew of FUD.
Cool, thanks!