Tomofdahook17
Member
I also love some of the areas people don't really pay attention too in this game.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Party McHardy
Banned
I love westerns but I’ve tried to play this game on three different occasions and having to fight the controls made me drop it each time.
Gaiff
SBI’s Resident Gaslighter
Being fun to play is a good start.
Bring Back Scalebound
Banned
It's genuinely sad to me that when people are going on about how RDR 2 is the best game ever made (Like many are doing in this thread), they don't mention a single word about the gameplay, general game design of the controls, missions, fluid and not-time-wasting animations, so on...
Because when it comes to RDR 2, there's nothing to talk about there. The GAME part, of this video GAME.
But you guys, knowing that, still proceed to call it the best game ever made, or one of the.
All I will say, is that I hope you play more games...
And... I hate to say stuff like this, but I'm happy that developers aren't listening to you.
Because when it comes to RDR 2, there's nothing to talk about there. The GAME part, of this video GAME.
But you guys, knowing that, still proceed to call it the best game ever made, or one of the.
All I will say, is that I hope you play more games...
And... I hate to say stuff like this, but I'm happy that developers aren't listening to you.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
I play a ton of games, have for over 40 years. Still one of the best game expereiences ever made to me.
Bring Back Scalebound
Banned
Missed my point... But I won't say anything. Happy for you.
Salty Popsicle
Banned
Definitely the most intricately crafted open-world ever created with many complex systems that came together perfectly to make the immersion into the wild-west all the easier. Every dev team who is attempting to make an open-world game with high production values should study this game intimately.
Danjin44
The nicest person on this forum
Easy, in GAF graphics has more value over everything else, you can have crappy gameplay but it has high tech graphics then all forgiven.
But boy if the graphics don’t meet their standard, they will whine and cry about it multiple threads, like first Elden Ring was coming out.
Last edited:
oji-san
Banned
Nonsense. You didn't enjoy it and that's fair, but don't call others who liked it being disingenuous. See
Stafford
post in previous page.. that's how i also feel, a bit like Killzone 2 was heavy on movement and it felt good, so does RDR2, are there cons to the game? Yes.. things like skins gets rotten over time is frustrating when you are exploring, but the gameplay to me match the amazing world they created, the shooting is very good to me, i have no reason to pretend i enjoy something i actually don't as i will only be fooling myself.
Last edited:
oji-san
Banned
Whatever... millions of players played it and enjoyed the gameplay but are lying to themselves, ok.
Isn't it more possible that people actually liked the gameplay? i can speak for myself that i liked the combat very much.
Pimpollo818
Member
I tired of playing as that Yes-Man. Good riddance. Hated the linear mission design, but the open world is jaw droppingly gorgeous. Would like to revisit this gameworld with mods in the future once I have the hardware to run it at max settings.
Last edited:
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
I didn't miss a thing. To each their own. Thanks! I'm happy for me too!
And I was even more happy to have experienced one of the greatest games of all time.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
Same. This was a more laid back game game than a lot of twitchy styled there that I found myself immersed in every single time I played, lost hours of time (over 1,000) in this game. When you master the systems, especially the combat, the game feels highly rewarding as a cowboy simulator.
Last edited:
ThatOneGrunt
Member
The comments in this thread have helped me understand the average gaffer better than any other discussion on this whole site.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
Explain.
_Ex_
Member
RDR2 is my all time most favorite game ever. This is coming from someone who has been gaming since 1982. It truly is a masterpiece within this medium. The amazing graphics are just the icing on its cake of awesome. It's a phenomenal experience but I'll add some caveats: I love westerns and nature in general, which makes me biased towards the theme. I played the game 99% of the time in first person view, which I found to be far more immersive than the third person view. So play the game in first person view, with the field of vision slider set to max. Brilliant game.
Ocean Dweller
Member
Obligatory draw distances are insane for a game that came out on PS4.
rockstar dev magic
vodka-bull
Member
I tried to play the game like 5 times, always lost interested past the first few hours but now on the 6th try I‘m totally addicted to the game, it‘s amazing how authentic the world seems, how R* made a totally believable, lively open world game. And it looks amazing too, unimaginable that it‘s just a PS4 game without a PS5 upgrade.
EverydayBeast
ChatGPT 0.001
The focus on the western theme already happened with red dead revolver, you could argue redemption doesn’t evolve the genre. Redemption 2 became about the graphics, pace is important and Redemption 2 breathes heavy.
Humdinger
Gold Member
I tried to get into it recently. It's been in my backlog forever. I appreciate the graphics, character models, the attention to detail, and immersion in the world. However, I struggle with controls and the amount of time investment required. Also, it seems to be another of those highly cinematic games, where you end up spending hour upon hour watching cutscenes. I rarely watch movies as it is, so I certainly don't want to watch the equivalent of 6 movies within one videogame.
Anyhow, I just don't find myself in the mood for a game like this. Maybe some other day.
Anyhow, I just don't find myself in the mood for a game like this. Maybe some other day.
Last edited:
Windom Earle
Member
this tbh. Such amazing presentation such lack of gameplay.OP in a nutshell.
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
I liked the first one all the way up to Jack. Did not want to play as Jack, so a backup save is important.
Raven117
Member
I mean, thats the end....I don't even think of that very much (other than I appreciated the arc).
The vibe of RDR1, to me, was more "western", while RDR2 was more "southern", and yes, that matters. RDR1 felt like I was playing a clint eastwood movie in all of the best ways. RDR2, while absolutely excellent in its own right, felt more...I don't know....forced soap opera.
Last edited:
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
I meant for "free roam" after. You are locked into Jack and can't have John back.
charles8771
Member
Look out how the first game ran on PS3 and Xbox 360
Whetever its 30fps or 60fps, people will buy it anywhere.
In 7th gen, games ran like 15-25fps and people still enjoyed it
Raven117
Member
I know what you meant. I appreciated it for the whole arc...especially the VERY end with Jack (But, like you, would rather play as John).
Gamer_By_Proxy
Member
I got RDR2 and Cyberpunk when they were both like $10 a piece and haven't booted up either one.
I'm a rebel!!!
I'm a rebel!!!
Marvel14
Banned
Not even close. Try getting a legendary pelt, then get mauled by a bear and lose your horse and the pelt down raging rapids.
The pelt will magically appear in some pelt dealers storeroom for you to pick up killing all immersion.
Also hunting and faffing about with your tent and appearance are boring.
Chuck Berry
Gold Member
Currently replaying. It’s been over a year. It’s time. Pics to come.
Fun fact - This game made 765 million dollars the week of release.
Now, imagine how much GTA6 will do on its first week.
First billion dollar making game in shortest time ever?
Fun fact - This game made 765 million dollars the week of release.
Now, imagine how much GTA6 will do on its first week.
First billion dollar making game in shortest time ever?
Come On Tars
Member
salva
Member
I'm LTTP for this and also only started a couple of weeks ago. For what ever reason I didn't play it at release, I bought it, played it a bit and dropped it.
Was going to play it on PC but remembered I had the Xbone disc. Playing it on Series X, yes it's only 30fps (4k at least) but geez it's a good looking game.
Was going to play it on PC but remembered I had the Xbone disc. Playing it on Series X, yes it's only 30fps (4k at least) but geez it's a good looking game.
Last edited:
Fortress of Regrets
Member
I'm always in awe when I fire this up to play on my Steam Deck. It runs and looks far better than I ever hoped it would in portable format.
Of course it looks and performs maximum incredible on my desktop PC, but it's so great to take such a vast and beautiful game world in your hand and hit your favorite comfy armchair.
I never got the gameplay complaints, it's perfectly good fun as far as I'm concerned.
Of course it looks and performs maximum incredible on my desktop PC, but it's so great to take such a vast and beautiful game world in your hand and hit your favorite comfy armchair.
I never got the gameplay complaints, it's perfectly good fun as far as I'm concerned.
Wolves hunt in packs
Banned
I'm still waiting for the next-gen upgrade Rockstar.
Grildon Tundy
Member
GTA V made $1bn in its first three days. I'm thinking VI will make $2bn in its first week. That's also the rumored cost of its development.
Chuck Berry
Gold Member
DanEON
Member
Not only that, PC also fixes the laggy controller.
Queso de Grande
Member
It took me a long time to finally get into this game. Once I did, wow, this game is truly a masterpiece. The thought and effort put into RDR2 worked out perfectly. One of the best written games, best acted games, and one of the most immersive with world.
gow3isben
Member
Truly alongside Witcher 3 and Mass Effect trilogy it completes the trio of greatest side quests in video game history.
This is how you do side quests Ubisoft you cucks
Mixture of long chain quests and short one-off quests. Variety of gameplay and encounters in these quests not found in the main story. Unique scenarios that range from laugh out loud hilarious to gravely emotional. Some of them even link with the main narrative.
Simply outstanding.
Upon replaying this game I realize how this game is looked upon way more fondly now than on first release. Potentially the greatest game of all time.
In many individual facets it isn't even close. From acting and narrative, immersive open world, incredible physics and variety of activities. Characters in your main group with jaw-dropping development and multiple layers.
Of course the drawback is the basic gunplay is average and the constant riding around and ultra focus on realism can make it boring in places. But what it does right it is unparalleled.
This is how you do side quests Ubisoft you cucks
Mixture of long chain quests and short one-off quests. Variety of gameplay and encounters in these quests not found in the main story. Unique scenarios that range from laugh out loud hilarious to gravely emotional. Some of them even link with the main narrative.
Simply outstanding.
Upon replaying this game I realize how this game is looked upon way more fondly now than on first release. Potentially the greatest game of all time.
In many individual facets it isn't even close. From acting and narrative, immersive open world, incredible physics and variety of activities. Characters in your main group with jaw-dropping development and multiple layers.
Of course the drawback is the basic gunplay is average and the constant riding around and ultra focus on realism can make it boring in places. But what it does right it is unparalleled.
Last edited: