You've been incredibly helpful, thank you!
So after considering your post and doing some further research on my own, I've come to the conclusion that the most inexpensive upgrade to my current PC would be to get the GTX 960. I currently rock an i3-2100 and
Corsair CX430W PSU, and it's a surprisingly common combo with the GTX 960. Seems people can run nearly every game out there today at 1080p with max settings.
Opting for the R9 280 or 380 means I would need to buy a new PSU, and I just can't spend that money right now.
Again, here are my parts:
Does the GTX 960 fit in a Rosewill Challenger case? Is it compatible with my motherboard? And is
this the best RAM around $45 that I can get for my motherboard? And is it compatible with my current RAM? And finally, should I opt for the EVGA 960s since they come with MGSV?
Thanks everyone!