IGN Top 100 Animated Series

Status
Not open for further replies.
not only is Gummi Bears not on that list, but neither are Heathcliff, Eek! the Cat, and Bobby's World!


BAH!


Well shit, even Garfield is missing....
 
omg rite said:
I'll ignore the Family Guy part (since it's great). But uh..

You think Ren and Stimpy is bad? WTF?
Click to expand...
This post makes no sense. You'll ignore FG because it's great, but you won't ignore Ren and Stimpy because...? Help me out here.


DMczaf said:
30kzhxc.gif
Click to expand...
The letters are all jumbled! IT'S A DREAM! BAILOUT!


I have to admit that. even though Batman is one of my favs, the first few eps are unapologetic elementary school fodder and the animation is subpar at best.

Christmas With the Joker is so bad... you have The Joker escaping Arkham on a rocket Christmas tree. :lol And that's not even the campiest part of the episode. I still like those episodes for what they are, but it's kind of embarrassing watching them with others around.
 
Duck Amuck said:
People consider those top 100 material? I'd agree with Eek, but the rest?
Click to expand...

compared to some of the ones on that list? Yes... Along with Rocko's modern life, Aaaah Real Monsters, and quite a few others people have already mentioned like Doug. But this is a list, and not everyone can be satisfied.
 
Rorschach said:
The letters are all jumbled! IT'S A DREAM! BAILOUT!


I have to admit that. even though Batman is one of my favs, the first few eps are unapologetic elementary school fodder and the animation is subpar at best.

Christmas With the Joker is so bad... you have The Joker escaping Arkham on a rocket Christmas tree. :lol And that's not even the campiest part of the episode. I still like those episodes for what they are, but it's kind of embarrassing watching them with others around.
Click to expand...
I thought that mad hatter episode was actually pretty good.
And yes, there plenty of bad episodes but there were some really great ones which is the reason gaf is all over Batman: TAS like stds on a hooker.
 
Evangelion and Cowboy Bebop don't belong anywhere near the top ten on any lists unless it's a list for most overrated anime of all time. One didn't know how to tell its own story and the other was far too episodic to be epic in any way shape or form.
 
Rorschach said:
This post makes no sense. You'll ignore FG because it's great, but you won't ignore Ren and Stimpy because...? Help me out here.



The letters are all jumbled! IT'S A DREAM! BAILOUT!


I have to admit that. even though Batman is one of my favs, the first few eps are unapologetic elementary school fodder and the animation is subpar at best.

Christmas With the Joker is so bad... you have The Joker escaping Arkham on a rocket Christmas tree. :lol And that's not even the campiest part of the episode. I still like those episodes for what they are, but it's kind of embarrassing watching them with others around.
Click to expand...

What?!? The series premiered with the Feat of Clay episodes. I think you picked out the one episode from the first season that was campy and poorly animated. That series was gold from the start, and was never at any point "elementary school fodder". Totally deserves to be in second place. Should still be in the top ten in a real globally conscious ranking of animated series.

I actually would argue that Looney Tunes doesn't belong in this list though. I would consider it disqualified since the "series" just consists of mostly short films made for theatrical release.
They really were never intended to be aired on television.
 
Good to see samurai jack on there. Not sure what the big deal with family guy is though... Futurama should definitely be higher.
 
my name is ed said:
I thought that mad hatter episode was actually pretty good.
And yes, there plenty of bad episodes but there were some really great ones which is the reason gaf is all over Batman: TAS like stds on a hooker.
Click to expand...
Don't get me wrong. I love TAS. I'm a huge whore for it.

Big Icarus said:
What?!? The series premiered with the Feat of Clay episodes. I think you picked out the one episode from the first season that was campy and poorly animated. That series was gold from the start, and was never at any point "elementary school fodder". Totally deserves to be in second place. Should still be in the top ten in a real globally conscious ranking of animated series.
Click to expand...
I'm not talking about the whole first season. I'm talking about the first few episodes.

On Leather Wings, Christmas with the Joker, Nothing to Fear, The Last Laugh. I love the Gray Ghost ep and that one's in the first season too.
 
slade said:
One didn't know how to tell its own story and the other was far too episodic to be epic in any way shape or form.
Click to expand...

Batman is episodic too. Do you think that's overrated? Bebop is one of the top ten anime's no question. It's kind of hard to put both japanese and western animation on the same list though.

I haven't seen evengelion...
 
Futurama is highly over-rated IMO. It doesn't deserve to be in the top ten. I want to see some Venture Bros. in that top ten. That's a show that does nerd humour right, without any ham fisted saccharine love story BS that Furturama has been ruined with.
 
Big Icarus said:
Futurama is highly over-rated IMO. It doesn't deserve to be in the top ten. I want to see some Venture Bros. in that top ten. That's a show that does nerd humour right, without any ham fisted saccharine love story BS that Furturama has been ruined with.
Click to expand...

Nothing makes me happier than to see Family Guy a spot ahead of Futurama.

Oblivion said:
Have you ever seen the episodes on Spike T.V.?
Click to expand...

What does that have anything to do with it? That's like saying Batman: TAS sucks because The Batman sucks.

They are different shows.
 
Oblivion said:
Have you ever seen the episodes on Spike T.V.?

Sorry, I'm not a huge fan of this dude's work.
Click to expand...

Seriously. It's the original two Nick seasons that are damn brilliant.

There's a bunch of shit that shouldn't be on that list. Not because they suck, because a good 2/3s of that list sucks. But because they weren't animated series to begin with. Stuff like Looney Toons were theatrical shorts re-packaged for the zillionth time into a TV show.
 
Duck Amuck said:
What's wrong with being episodic? Being "epic" isn't the point of Bebop. I always like it when anime fans bring up Bebop being episodic is some kind of dent against it.
Click to expand...

Episodic is too boring to watch in marathon sessions. You get sick and tired of the characters and their same old schticks. I watched Bebop after the show had been out for at least two or three years and I watched it in a marathon session. Almost didn't get to the end of the session because the damn thing ended up being too boring. Now the movie, that was good and not because of the Bebop characters.

Batman is episodic too. Do you think that's overrated? Bebop is one of the top ten anime's no question. It's kind of hard to put both japanese and western animation on the same list though.
Click to expand...

I loved Batman when I was a kid. I would not watch it now even though most of my primary viewing these days is anime.
 
OMG, you guys are a bunch of elitists/nerds/losers. Death Note is awesome.

I cannot honestly get over Naruto is Harry Potter with ninjas :lol
 
Duck Amuck said:
The episodic nature for Bebop makes it my most rewatched anime. I know most of the lines by heart.

I watched Black Dog Serenade maybe once a day for the span of a week.

Best anime tv series ever.
Click to expand...

I'm with you on that one. The stuff slade is calling boring is the stuff that makes the show good. They characters actually have character -- motivations that drive them to do what they do and say what they say. Plot (especially in anime) is mostly contrivance.
 
slade said:
Episodic is too boring to watch in marathon sessions. You get sick and tired of the characters and their same old schticks. I watched Bebop after the show had been out for at least two or three years and I watched it in a marathon session. Almost didn't get to the end of the session because the damn thing ended up being too boring. Now the movie, that was good and not because of the Bebop characters.
Click to expand...

lol I loved the series but didn't like the movie. maybe try not watching it in a marathon?
 
bitq said:
lol I loved the series but didn't like the movie. maybe try not watching it in a marathon?
Click to expand...

slade said:
most of my primary viewing these days is anime.
Click to expand...

There's no point in trying to get him to like one of the few genuinely good anime shows if he thinks the rest are just fine.
 
So can we just stop posting top whatever of whatever lists from now on? No good comes from them.

NO AEON FLUX AND DARIA?!?!?! RAAAAAAAAAAAGE!!!!!
 
Yay for ignoring European animation. The 90s Tintin series is still one of the most faithful adaptions I've ever seen on screen.
 
That's awesome, my 2 favorite animated series took the top 2. Same order too. :D

Not a bad list at all, although I think Animaniacs should be somewhere in the Top 10.
 
No my list at all... The top 10 does nothing for me. Ducktales should have been higher, for example! Also the lack of anime near the top ten is disturbing. I guess in my country that list would have looked much different =)
 
How in the bloody fuck can anybody question Ren & Stimpy's place among the best cartoons?

Maybe it's not your thing, but that doesn't mean it isn't influential and loved by countless others.

So many people seem to think the original R&S show is now somehow bad because of the Adult Cartoon Party episodes.
 
DieNgamers said:
No my list at all... The top 10 does nothing for me. Ducktales should have been higher, for example! Also the lack of anime near the top ten is disturbing. I guess in my country that list would have looked much different =)
Click to expand...

There shouldn't have been any anime on the list, period. There's just so many and they all have different standards than western-made shows. There is just no contest.
 
SonicMegaDrive said:
There shouldn't have been any anime on the list, period. There's just so many and they all have different standards than western-made shows. There is just no contest.
Click to expand...
I guess that's true. They could have called it the best cartoons or something^^ That said, all the 90s Disney cartoons need to be in (or closer to) the top ten! >:(
 
Honestly, the fact that Family Guy is #7 and King of the Hill, one of the best sitcoms ever, regardless of animation, is at #27 completely invalidates this list in my mind.

And putting The Simpsons at #1 doesn't even make sense unless you ignore OVER A DECADE of consistently horrible episodes.
 
Kinda weird having compilations of theatrical shorts on there. I mean, technically they were TV shows and that's how a shitload of people were introduced to them, but they were absolutely not created for television.

Samurai Jack needs to be way higher, and Neon Genesis Evangelion needs to get as far away from the top 10 as possible. Family Guy's way too high, but maybe makes the list.
 
SonicMegaDrive said:
Maybe it's not your thing, but that doesn't mean it isn't influential and loved by countless others
Click to expand...

Is that the criteria for what belongs on this list? Cause that would make FG being on here legitimate. Can you have such a thing on YOUR conscience?
 
Oblivion said:
Is that the criteria for what belongs on this list? Cause that would make FG being on here legitimate. Can you have such a thing on YOUR conscience?
Click to expand...

On this list?

yes.



on MY list?

Hell no. But Ren & Stimpy would be near the top, alongside Batman and Simpsons.

IMO, those three shows are the foundations of great 90's animation, which was the best decade for TV animation, imo.
 
Oblivion said:
Is that the criteria for what belongs on this list? Cause that would make FG being on here legitimate.
Click to expand...

Oh, it's perfectly legitimate. An insanely popular show that people continue to love? Sounds like a good criteria to me.

And putting The Simpsons at #1 doesn't even make sense unless you ignore OVER A DECADE of consistently horrible episodes.
Click to expand...

Having like 8-10 years of greatness kind of makes up for that. The popularity and influence of the show, mixed with the quality it showed for like 10 years? Nothing shocking about that being #1.
 
omg rite said:
Oh, it's perfectly legitimate. An insanely popular show that people continue to love? Sounds like a good criteria to me.



Having like 8-10 years of greatness kind of makes up for that. The popularity and influence of the show, mixed with the quality it showed for like 10 years? Nothing shocking about that being #1.
Click to expand...

First 5 seasons were good, after that it went to shit. It's just fact.
 
thetechkid said:
First 5 seasons were good, after that it went to shit. It's just fact.
Click to expand...

Season 2 through 9 were all pure gold.

Seasons 10 and 11 had their moments, too. I stopped watching after that, because the show stopped being consistently funny, so I lost interest.

But it did have a solid 9 or 10 years.
 
List should be unordered. It'd save on internet hysteria and a legitimate discussion on what should be on the list would hopefully happen without the "It's shit because I dislike popular shows".
 
7Th said:
At the 2003 Laputa Animation Festival, 140 animation artists and film critics from around the world were asked to list the 20 best animated productions. These lists were then combined into one with 150 titles on it. The list was widely reported in the Russian press because places #1 and #2 were taken by Yuriy Norshteyn's films "Hedgehog in the Fog" and "Tale of Tales". It's obviously a much better list than IGN's.
Click to expand...
Now THAT'S an animated top 100, this IGN list is more "Top 100 rose tinted nostalgia cartoons by everyone in their 20-somethings". I've seen worst lists, though.

..why is there two Star Wars: Clone Wars entries? Is one of them the 3D series? Ugh.
 
Gagaman said:
Now THAT'S an animated top 100, this IGN list is more "Top 100 rose tinted nostalgia cartoons by everyone in their 20-somethings".
Click to expand...
But that's who made the list and that's who they made the list for. Why does everything has to be culturally relevant? Don't get me wrong the ones he named are classic and have inspired many great filmmakers, but this list is just for fun and for a big audience. I do believe most people haven't even heard of Hedgehog in the Fog. That's not to say it doesn't deserve its place, but in this particular list it would not belong.
 
Admit what you all ctrl+f'ed after looking at #1. Mine was Duckman. Can't believe it's only at 48!

Never got into Family Guy so I'm a little peeved it's above Futurama.

As for Simpsons? Well, as great as it can be I'm taking a straw-poll on worst episode ever (in comic-book guy's voice). As a general rule, any episode with a Lisa focus sux. Still deserves to be at the top of the list IMO.

Word.
 
thetechkid said:
First 5 seasons were good, after that it went to shit. It's just fact.
Click to expand...

FYI guys, this right here is what I'm talking about when I talk about people who try to hard to be negative.

Only the first 5? And it's fact? Christ. :lol
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

NBA's top 100 dunks of the last 25 years
20
968
fallingdove replied
Jimmy Carter dies at 100
2
71
4K
ADiTAR replied
TheWrap: Netflix and Zack Snyder's "Army of the Dead" Sequels and Animated Series "Quietly Cancelled"
19
2K
K' Dash replied
Beast Games IGN Review: 2/10
40
4K
Ozzy Onya A2Z replied
Ryan Coogler's 'Sinners' opens to a 100% critic score on Rotten Tomatoes
2
53
2K
ZehDon replied
Top Bottom