Had a great time with my goody two shoes playthrough, and am having twice as much fun on my evil expert run. As I took care of all the completionist stuff in the first playthrough (all shards, cleared all districts, etc), its so much more relaxing (and intense) to just move through the world and missions organically, to have a real solid feel on the traversal and how the city is designed to get you moving easily, best of all: not having to worry about collateral damage at all.
This game could have been more, sure - but my God, Sucker Punch has improved so many facets of the series here in so many ways, and set such a high quality bar on those improvements that if the worst thing we can say about this game is that it plays like Infamous, then Sucker Punch should be extremely pleased with their handiwork.
I haven't vidya game binged like this in years and years. Hot damn.