Is the show It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia a good representation of Irish comedy applied to a modern American palate?
Besides the fact that the characters and their creator are of Irish descent, I think it could be considered a wackier extrapolation off of the avuncular tradition of Irish humor. There's a big emphasis on absurdity of expression, rather than absurdity of the situation. The plots in It's Always Sunny can be funny, but the real value comes from the way the characters experience these situations. Many plots are just a framework for funny dialogue or behavior.
This is in contrast to a show like Seinfeld, where the dialogue itself is pretty tame, and the humor comes from the situation. The plot of a Seinfeld is usually the source of an episode's value, instead of being a framework. Dialogue in Seinfeld usually just explains the plot.
Could I be onto something?
Besides the fact that the characters and their creator are of Irish descent, I think it could be considered a wackier extrapolation off of the avuncular tradition of Irish humor. There's a big emphasis on absurdity of expression, rather than absurdity of the situation. The plots in It's Always Sunny can be funny, but the real value comes from the way the characters experience these situations. Many plots are just a framework for funny dialogue or behavior.
This is in contrast to a show like Seinfeld, where the dialogue itself is pretty tame, and the humor comes from the situation. The plot of a Seinfeld is usually the source of an episode's value, instead of being a framework. Dialogue in Seinfeld usually just explains the plot.
Could I be onto something?