Is Sony Next In Nintendo's Cross Hairs?

rick james cocaine GIF
 
Did they arguably violate any patents Nintendo holds? Because if Nintendo was going to sue them just for having a cute platformer, Sackboy would have been the one.
 
Zannegan said:
Did they arguably violate any patents Nintendo holds? Because if Nintendo was going to sue them just for having a cute platformer, Sackboy would have been the one.
Click to expand...
maybe but sackboy wasn't so critically acclaimed, I saw in an article that Nintendo's legal team picks and chooses it's lawsuits. I love Nintendo and Sony games I wish developers didn't live under this threat
 
MagusMajul said:
maybe but sackboy wasn't so critically acclaimed, I saw in an article that Nintendo's legal team picks and chooses it's lawsuits. I love Nintendo and Sony games I wish developers didn't live under this threat
Click to expand...
True, but they still have to have a leg to stand on, legally speaking. And it's not like Sony would be intimidated by Nintendo anyway.

Plus, picking and choosing cases probably has as much to do with making sure they winnable as making an example.
 
Zannegan said:
Did they arguably violate any patents Nintendo holds? Because if Nintendo was going to sue them just for having a cute platformer, Sackboy would have been the one.
Click to expand...
And then Sony countersue for Mario Maker having a level creator and online sharing like LittleBigPlanet. The suing shall never end!

Season 6 Knowledge GIF by Friends
 
Meh. This thread should have been about whether Nintendo and Sony will be in more direct competition after Microsoft's exit and the more powerful Switch 2. I believe they will be and I'm interested to see how it all shakes out.
 
Last edited:
Interesting comparison. So Astro Bot is both a homage to Sony IP's as well as to the worlds and mechanics from Nintendo's classic 3D games.
 
Last edited:
Zannegan said:
Did they arguably violate any patents Nintendo holds? Because if Nintendo was going to sue them just for having a cute platformer, Sackboy would have been the one.
Click to expand...

This. You can't (successfully) sue just for taking inspiration from existing games. If you could, the entire industry would have been consumed by lawsuits decades ago. There needs to be provable copyright or patent infringement.

Note that Nintendo is not even suing Palworld for its borderline plagiarized faux-pokemon designs, presumably because it doesn't think that case is winnable, but for patent infringement, which is much more clear cut, since the original patent application lays out, in some detail, exactly what it's supposed to protect.

So, no, there's a zero percent chance Nintendo is going to sue Sony over Astrobot.
 
Palworld is multiplatform now... no need to defend it anymore. It's a pretty crap game, baby's first unity project type of crap.

Nintendo will either win or lose and life will go on. The game had it's 2 weeks of popularity, that's more than 90% of indie games out there.
 
That's like saying Id tech should sue Bungie for Halo. Palworld situation is different as you could mistake the designs for actual Pokemon
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Animal Crossing for Switch 2 is going to be announced in a Nintendo Direct the next July (Rumor)
Rumor  2
66
2K
Inanilmaz replied
  • Locked
What's the next Sony AAA IP to go third party on Nintendo Switch/Switch 2?
32
476
StueyDuck replied
Donkey Kong Is Getting the AAA Treatment. What Nintendo IP Is Next?
2 3
110
558
TheChadOfGaming replied
  • Poll
Exclusivity is dead, NeoGAF - do you think Nintendo will release games on other hardware in the next 10 years?
2 3 4
156
359
daclynk replied
  • Poll
Sony, Nintendo and Microsoft- are they still rivals
2
79
228
PlayStaytion replied
Top Bottom