A wrestling game that is clearly bad, yet you have a good time with it regardless.
My example, WrestleMania X8 on the Gamecube. The graphics suck, the gameplay sucks, the roster sucks, the music sucks, the CAW sucks, the animations suck, the singleplayer sucks. It's hot garbage.
But any time I go back to play the GC wrestling games, I still have a fun time with it. Maybe it's the way wrestlers with high agility fire twenty feet across the ring like they were launched by a rocket when doing a top rope dropkick. Or the way that, upon a successful pinfall victory, both wrestlers instantly stand up and awkwardly stare at each other as the victor's music plays. Or the steel chairs the size of tables.
It's Troll 2 for wrestling games. For GC WWE games, WrestleMania XIX (with that incredible Revenge Mode), DOR1 and DOR2 are actually good, but X8 has its broken hilarity.