The question then includes what do you do with NXT. You need to keep enough NXT stars so that they can tour successfully, because far more than the main brand, NXT touring, while not dependent on any single person, there are key difference makers who do help on the roster: Samoa Joe, Shinsuke Nakamura, Finn Balor and Bayley. There is also Bobby Roode and Eric Young, who are clearly good enough for main roster spots, but could be used more effectively right now in NXT which needs some talent depth if some of the guys leave.
Samoa Joe can, and should be, an A level heel, which helps balance things out. Plus, hes one of the few people who are heels that can have, with the right protection, and build, a viable program with Lesnar. Nakamura should be an A level babyface. Really, hes the most charismatic wrestler on the roster right now, and while he doesnt have the name value of Cena, he can and should, surpass the popularity of everyone, including Reigns, if used the way he should be.
Austin Aries can be used as a face or a heel, and should be a solid person on the B list. I could see Vince McMahon seeing him as a C level guy, but no way. Finn Balor is an interesting one. He can be a face or heel. My gut slots him at the A- level on either side, similar to a Sami Zayn. He should be on the main roster, and hes more of a natural babyface at first glance, and did great in the role in NXT. But his Japan role showed he has strong potential as a heel. Still, it may be tough to sell Vince McMahon on an 185 pound high flyer and strong technical wrestler being an A level heel.
The former La Sombra, Andrade Cien Almas, who isnt likely to be called up shortly, is a natural babyface, and can be the Latin star theyve been searching for, who isn't small. The reality is that Del Rio, at his age, has been slotted, and while he should be a face right now, because hes played out as a heel, hes not the future superstar they wanted him to be. Almas, who was actually a great, cool heel in CMLL, can be that babyface, depending on his interviews and his ability to adapt and fit in with the style.
On the tag team scene, Jason Jordan & Chad Gable should be an A level team. Id go so far as to have The New Day as the top face team on one brand, and Jordan & Gable on the other, and introduce Jordan & Gable quickly for the slot. But as the chart shows, they would be the fourth A level babyface team, with only one A level heel team. Of the current B level heel teams, the Dudleys could be an A level team, but theyve been badly abused already and the Vaudevillains may be put there, but arent going to have legs to stay there. That does seem to be an opening for Scott Dawson & Dash Wilder, who are a strong technical team, but they are weak on interviews.
On the womens side, the obvious names are Bayley and Asuka, who should be in the A category on the main roster. Nia Jax isnt ready, but looks different enough from everyone else, and shes Dwayne Johnsons cousin, so both help. Eventually, shell be there and pushed hard because they need A list women heels right now, not faces.
If Charlotte & Dana Brooke are kept together, unless all the women are put in the same brand, it means Paige, Natalya, Banks or Lynch has to turn to be top heel on the other brand. Paige has turned too often. Banks is a natural face and should be groomed right now as the face chasing Charlotte. Asuka can be a heel, but if she and Bayley are both brought up, that leaves NXT dead when it comes to being able to showcase the women as theyve done the past two years. Bayley should be introduced soon as a face because her uniqueness will be compromised the longer they wait as her character has a finite shelf life.