-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Just Mafia |OT| Sometimes You Don't Need A Reason to Lynch Your Friends
- Thread starter CrimsonFist
- Start date
isaacnukem
Member
Checking in. I was doused. Not a drill.
VOTE: weedamarthur
She is lying or the arsonist gained two shots on the day with Karkador, which makes no sense to my poor brain. So I'm leaning with the easier explanation.
VOTE: weedamarthur
She is lying or the arsonist gained two shots on the day with Karkador, which makes no sense to my poor brain. So I'm leaning with the easier explanation.
Karkador said that he wasn't doused.
Blargonaut
Banned
deja you, didn't you already claim Doused?
I didn't even pick up on that. Huh.
Dusk Soldier
Member
Maybe melon? Don't think she's popped in yet.
If it was LP, that means we won't be told if players are doused when flipped.
I figured Isaac was just mentioning his old dousage. It's all they have talked about this game...
It's pretty simple. You claimed role cop so you should be the big target for the NK. Every night you don't die is suspicious. If you are scum and you false roleclaim someone as doctor you could just NK the other player and say that scum believed you and that you just did it to win another night, That way it won't be suspicious that you stay alive the following nights.
We don't know who was protected by LP last night. But if you are still alive for the next 2 night you should be lynched.
About the bolded. Anything to share about Launch?
CornBurrito
Member
Fair enough. I voted Zubz, and was a huge advocate for his lynch. I was on the outs of yesterdays conversation because everyone else refused to see weemad as scum and then went for Karkador.
What? Wee was in the lead for a while.
i mean just lie about being doused and then let town go nuts trying to find the arsonist
melonrabbit
Member
isaacnukem
Member
He said that?
isaacnukem
Member
I'm not claiming doused again today.
melonrabbit
Member
Yes, did you read yesterday at all?
He admitted to lying about being doused yesterday.
isaacnukem
Member
I wasn't around the past few days. Sorry. I wouldn't have left my vote on him if that was the case.
UNVOTE
I think we can assume the one that bit the dust got doused today. We don't have any decent leads for the arsonist now.
UNVOTE
I think we can assume the one that bit the dust got doused today. We don't have any decent leads for the arsonist now.
Blargonaut
Banned
CrimsonFist
Member
Weemadarthur (1)
CornBurrito (1808)
Isaacnukem (1853)
CornBurrito (1)
Kalor (1815)
Day Ends:
Majority is 8
CornBurrito (1808)
CornBurrito (1)
Kalor (1815)
Day Ends:
Majority is 8
weemadarthur
Member
I popped in to read the thread, between dealing with various personal thingies.
How's the scum hunting going?
.....I see.
Well, maybe we can finally ask rac what possessed him to end a day 12 hours early when a new role claim had just happened?
Fat4all, any contributions? Or just more incorrect renditions of Clue? I hate the fact that you have it all backwards and inside out. It makes me irritated so much. Flames. Flames. On the side of my face. Breathing. Breath-ing. Heaving breaths.
How's the scum hunting going?
.....I see.
Well, maybe we can finally ask rac what possessed him to end a day 12 hours early when a new role claim had just happened?
Fat4all, any contributions? Or just more incorrect renditions of Clue? I hate the fact that you have it all backwards and inside out. It makes me irritated so much. Flames. Flames. On the side of my face. Breathing. Breath-ing. Heaving breaths.
I think that makes everyone checking in.
So, no one claimed doused today. That means either no arsonist and this was a big lie, the arsonist targeted LP or the arsonist was roleblocked.
If the arsonist was roleblocked that mean that someone could know who is the arsonist. A roleblocker is a role that could be of any aligment.
Let's take a gamble: I still think we should leave the arsonist alone. If any of you is a townie arsonist block another target tonight.
If the arsonist dies tonight that means that scum has a roleblocker and, most likely, that Wee and/or Isaac are scum as scum will be very interested to kill the arsonist before a member of their team would die.
It the arsonist doesn't die tonight that means that the roleblocker is townie. If the roleblocker targeted another player and we have a new doused player the next day he will know who the arsonist is. If the roleblocker targeted another player and we don't get a new doused player that means it was all a lie and we should start lynching the doused players to see what we find.
So, no one claimed doused today. That means either no arsonist and this was a big lie, the arsonist targeted LP or the arsonist was roleblocked.
If the arsonist was roleblocked that mean that someone could know who is the arsonist. A roleblocker is a role that could be of any aligment.
Let's take a gamble: I still think we should leave the arsonist alone. If any of you is a townie arsonist block another target tonight.
If the arsonist dies tonight that means that scum has a roleblocker and, most likely, that Wee and/or Isaac are scum as scum will be very interested to kill the arsonist before a member of their team would die.
It the arsonist doesn't die tonight that means that the roleblocker is townie. If the roleblocker targeted another player and we have a new doused player the next day he will know who the arsonist is. If the roleblocker targeted another player and we don't get a new doused player that means it was all a lie and we should start lynching the doused players to see what we find.
isaacnukem
Member
But what if the arsonist still hasn't doused a scum? Wouldn't it be in their best interest to keep the arsonist alive and hope they light the match after dousing only townies?
isaacnukem
Member
Nope. Not me.
Not really as the arsonist is a risk. He may not have hit scum yet but he may in the future.
Blargonaut
Banned
hurry up
isaacnukem
Member
Yeah but if I were scum I would wait for as long as it takes. If the arsonist douses one of my teammates, then I'll go for the arsonist. So I kill the arsonist but he still lights up the match after dousing one of my teammates, it'll still be worth to take that chance if there is more than one doused townie. That's how I'd do it, anyway.
isaacnukem
Member
I won't be here for maybe 24 hours. Heads-up.
That's not true. There are more townies than scums. It usually is a 4/1 rate or something like that so the biggest loss would be for scum. Also you have to take into account the flip. A scum flip gives a lot more info than a townie flip as you can look for interactions and voting better.
isaacnukem
Member
I said that's how I'd do it.
there was plenty of role claims that day, no one else seemed to give a shit
p weak
I said that I would explain my vote for Corn but now that I'm rereading the game I feel less confident in it. The main crux behind it was that I thought people who initally voted for weemad yesterday were suspicious. The other two main lynch candidates had already claimed so scum would be inclined to lynch the person who hadn't claimed, since they could have been hiding a power role. However this reasoning is useless since we don't know wees alignment.
Blargonaut
Banned
Don't sweat it, we'll be here
Wee claimed too. In fact the 3 of them claimed vanilla so neither of they claims are really PRs.
They only claimed towards the end so there was a period of time where they were the only person who hadn't claimed.
Yes, but the 3 of them claimed vanilla, which is the less incriminating thing you can claim, either as town pr or as scum. Vanilla is a role that you can't prove until you flip do it's a good way to hide.
Is the 10 post rule still in effect? Because we may need several replacements for tomorrow at the rate this is going.
melonrabbit
Member
Everyone keeps talking about parties but no one is delivering.
Are you never getting back to us, Blarg?
Probably because I've been playing infrequently because of work.
But I am around this evening if you had anything you wanted to address with me, Fran.
That aside, do you guys think Isaac made up the arsonist as scum or is the arsonist claiming doused or idk something else entirely?
Are you never getting back to us, Blarg?
Probably because I've been playing infrequently because of work.
But I am around this evening if you had anything you wanted to address with me, Fran.
That aside, do you guys think Isaac made up the arsonist as scum or is the arsonist claiming doused or idk something else entirely?
If there were the only one that claimed doused I would believe that it was made up but wee claimed to be doused yesterday so that muddies the waters. There's a scenario where they could both be scum that lied about being doused but that seems unnecessary.
Lying about being doused is possible but I wouldnt be the first person to claim doused as the arsonist. The second or third person would get less suspicion.
Okay, I will take that:
Can you put the next players in a list from townie to scummy:
Wee, Kalor, Dusk, Acorhs, Launch and Isaac.
Also who is at the top of your scum list right now?
Regarding the question, arsonist not existing: maybe, arsonist claiming doused: not likely something else: it doesn't even matter. Let's hunt scum.
melonrabbit
Member
Town --> Scum
Kalor, Acorhs, Dusk, Isaac, Wee, Launch
My top scum(s)
Launch, Wee, Kit also, I need to hear more from her. And Blarg needs to clarify a few things before I'm comfortable with his supposed town-alignment.
NeckToChicken
Unconfirmed Member
I voice most of my theories, despite insanity (inanity?) and far fetched nature. There might be a more mundane/likely theory to be drawn from it.
Maybe all those calls for hot reveals have made him think twice? Or maybe Blarg figured he shouldn't crow whatever role it was from the rooftops this time.
Blargonaut
Banned
Absence makes the hearts grow fonder for contribution