My main thought was that I didn't get what the big deal was. CCS made pretty much the same "trust me, XXX is town" read in Pop and even suggested we'd lynch him there too (less serious as we were close to/in LyLo). He was ordinary town. Acohrs seemed to just play along and I didn't read it either way.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Legend of Zelda Mafia |OT| A Lynch to the Past
- Thread starter Sawneeks
- Start date
melonrabbit
Member
He self-voted there too?
Can't wait for them to adopt it into a Netflix series. With you as the Lemony Snicket-esque narrator.
Nope, but it was during Lylo. He did say this though:
Self voting isn't that weird to me. I've self voted myself tho that was to stir shit up and not because I gave up
Looks like it is going to be CCS in the end.
I certainly can understand why anyone would vote him out since this would clear the air about him.
I still can't decide who to vote for ( I do not want to vote out CCS )
Can anyone put down the vote count for me?
I am on mobile until the rest of the day
I certainly can understand why anyone would vote him out since this would clear the air about him.
I still can't decide who to vote for ( I do not want to vote out CCS )
Can anyone put down the vote count for me?
I am on mobile until the rest of the day
Zelda Fact of the Day #6: Did you know that Twilight Princess' art style is a direct response to the criticisms of Wind Waker's art style? Or that Skyward Sword was a direct response to critics saying Twilight Princess was too 'dark and realistic'? Now you know!
Current Vote Count:
natiko (0)
cabot 1130 (1234)
bronx-man (0)
czartim 1131 (1620)
ccs (5)
kawl_usc 1143
bronx-man 1209 (1644)
*splinter 1546
ynnek7 1654
stanleypalmtree 1689
melonrabbit 1750
cabot (0)
nin1000 1152 (1208)
melonrabbit 1553 (1750)
*splinter (0)
cabot 1234 (1260)
ty4on (1)
cabot 1260 (1295)
kyanrute 1755
magnumboy20xx (0)
absolutbro 1282 (1687)
ynnek7 (0)
cabot 1295 (1476)
kawl_usc (0)
ccs 1301 (1377)
stanleypalmtree (3)
ccs 1410 (1604)
czartim 1620
ty4on 1676
natiko 1690
melonrabbit (2)
cabot 1476
ccs 1604
nin1000 (1)
bronx-man 1644
absolutbro (1)
magnumboy20xx 1668
Majority is 8
Day 2 Ends in:
Vote Count is HERE
Current Vote Count:
natiko (0)
bronx-man (0)
ccs (5)
kawl_usc 1143
*splinter 1546
ynnek7 1654
stanleypalmtree 1689
melonrabbit 1750
cabot (0)
*splinter (0)
ty4on (1)
kyanrute 1755
magnumboy20xx (0)
ynnek7 (0)
kawl_usc (0)
stanleypalmtree (3)
czartim 1620
ty4on 1676
natiko 1690
melonrabbit (2)
cabot 1476
ccs 1604
nin1000 (1)
bronx-man 1644
absolutbro (1)
magnumboy20xx 1668
Majority is 8
Day 2 Ends in:
Vote Count is HERE
Is Sophia a null to you? I didn't like how she mostly stayed quiet regarding me and then immediately jumped onto your analysis. Felt more interested in the agenda than actually finding scum.
Why don't you have a vote down?
Logically that would be because I don't know who I want to vote for.
Sophia is a town lean, thanks to her contributions and suspicion towards acohrs.
Oh and this I feel is not true. There are multiple posts from Sophia on day one where she comments about her suspicion towards you.
Reminds me of my own play when I'm scum. Worst part of being scum.
Why are you uncertain and who are your town reads?
Ok, thanks. What is it about her contributions that looks town to you?
I was talking about D2. Don't remember and couldn't find anything.
Post D2 examples if you have any. I tried searching for it, but couldn't find anything.
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
ayyyyy im actually awake for the days end today.
And im second in the running for being lynched!
aint this fun.
And im second in the running for being lynched!
aint this fun.
This interaction is interesting from a W/W perspective. It's a little weird to parrot a mate's line like that and in my experience scummies often copy plays from townies.
My issue with you is I haven't come across anything I find particularly townie and your actions make more sense from a scum PoV.
melonrabbit
Member
I like how Magnum and AB are voting for each other. Adorable.
melonrabbit
Member
Nevermind, guess AB unvoted and ruined it.
melonrabbit
Member
Any other thoughts, Stan, about this game? World at large? Deepest desires? Etc.
Nothing really on Day 2, save what I've said in regards to Kyan's posts on you.
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
So I am probably not going to be around for day end so I'll have to leave my vote now.
VOTE: CCS
I'm not entirely satisfied with this choice but the fact that we are back here again goes to show that this will just be a distraction if we don't finish it and move on.
VOTE: CCS
I'm not entirely satisfied with this choice but the fact that we are back here again goes to show that this will just be a distraction if we don't finish it and move on.
Part of the issue Stan is that you've not shared much analysis and mostly just views.
Like is there more to the bolded?
Like is there more to the bolded?
I'm kinda tunneling on Sophia rn, but I feel like I'm onto something. Reminds me of scum I've played with in the past. More interested in doubting than figuring stuff out and generally not that proactive. Haven't found anything that really stands out from town!Sophia tho yet.
She leaves her mark on the game. She follows multiple lines of thought, backs them up with quotes, arguments and theories. She shares her opinion on things willingly. She shows effort. I do not see her trying to lead the discussion towards some end. The last bit of course is both a good and a bad thing. I do not get the feeling that she is trying to lead the discussion in a scummy way, but also I am disappointed that the effort she shows with her thoughts towards others does not extend all the way to voting. I am bit worried about the fact that she seems to be leaving some room for herself when it comes to committing to a vote.
AbsolutBro
Member
Heading out to dinner so I will make this quick.
At the very high risk of sounding sheepy, I am going to
Vote: melonrabbit
for reasons I have stated (and echoed) previously. The cabot tunnel and the early survey that went nowhere except distraction chief amongst them. I will try to be on mobile, but I do not know how long we will be.
At the very high risk of sounding sheepy, I am going to
Vote: melonrabbit
for reasons I have stated (and echoed) previously. The cabot tunnel and the early survey that went nowhere except distraction chief amongst them. I will try to be on mobile, but I do not know how long we will be.
What is this supposed to say, melon?
Sorry for highlighting typos, but I didn't quite get what it was supposed to say.
My closest guess is:
Kinda interesting that we're on the precipice of a CCS lynch despite all the early opposition to one in D2. I strongly dislike his play though so I'm not entirely opposed to one. My main concern is a lot of people will argue it was a policy lynch if he flips town and that could muddy any insight to gain from the votes. Plus town could very well find themselves taking a three person hit by D3 which isn't a great position to be in with the info we'll have.
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
yeah, i always play mafia much more with my gut than with my logic, but i def have taken that much to far this game.
talking about sophia specifically, irritatingly no there hasnt been anymore to that feling, frustrating given that i have been paying more mind to her posts and still havnt gotten more to push my ideas either way.
so like i have this idea for a short film, its about a princess mantis (one of those adorable pink ones) whose family is massacred in a coup, but she survives and goes on this whole bloody whirlwind of revenge, eventually violently retaking her throne, only to ascend it a more vicious tyrant than the usurper she killed. like it has this whole mesage of how violence only begets more vio-
y'know what, it doesn't matter
melonrabbit
Member
It meant that I could see myself voting for acohrs but I wasn't fully convinced that acohrs was scum and his antics were worrying to me. Started to feel he was actively trying to get people to lynch him and which is why I saw him as neutral (Tanner).
look when has a tunnel I initiated went wrong?
Yeah, Okay. It's not went right. I think melon is scum. That's the bottom line. If I am wrong, well. We can work on that in Day 3.
come again?
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
i mean the fastest way to really move on from CCS would be to lynch him, not lynching him isnt going to make the issue go away.
or do you mean move on in some other sense?
The implication seems to be that town will have two deaths on Night 2 + CCS is town. Huuuh...
melonrabbit
Member
May have something to with the stolen item Natiko told us about? Strange comment tho.
lots of assumptions in that statement then
If we lynch town and have another two night kills?
D:
If you could override who would you choose?
Oh yeah, I remember someone bringing up the tanner angle...
I know one midseason game used them, but wasn't the consensus to not use tanners period?
presumes another night of two kills.
regardless mislynches are a fact of mafia life. scared money don't make money, and i really don't agree with the position that CCS is unlikely to be scum.
melonrabbit
Member
You are wrong, doctor.
Hope my flip illuminates something of value so town can bounce back from your malpractice.
I can't remember. They're not allowed in main season games. It would actually be hilarious if CCS was one tho.
That being said, what you specifically quoted was more in response to Sorian calling me a third wheel, and me being frustrated with the antics at the end of Day 1.
melonrabbit
Member
I don't know? It was the only way I could explain acohrs descent into madness.
Well, we can only find out from your flip. I'm still pretty certain you're scum. We'll see what everyone else thinks.
Godspeed, Doctor.
I personally would put him closer to scum than town and have said so throughout this day phase. If he's town he is a purposefully bad teammate. My point was everyone voting for him will just argue that it was a necessary lynch and thus we will get no insight from the votes.
As for the assumption go back and look at the beginning of this day phase, the main idea put forward was someone else having a second kill ability. Fran and Sorian weren't pro-town deaths so assuming it wasn't a one shot kill there's no reason to think N2 will go any better.
Not sure if the issue is as much ccs as the people who aren't willing to vote elsewhere until he's gone.
Well I mean ccs is the problem but you know what I mean
but that lack of info there is offset by the gained complete info regarding the vote contention at days end yesterday. and this is the second person to bring up the complaint that a vote is too much of a no brainer. which i mean i guess i can see why it's not ideal, but sometimes you play the hand that's been dealt to you by others.
double kill every night would generally have some type of balance off set. or its an alternating night ability, etc etc. i'd but it at even odds we have only 1 death tonight vs 2 tbh.