Vinterbird said:
So anti-glare isn't "better" in any way to the current screen type?
I don't know why there are so many Mac users here who don't know how to answer this yet. I'm going to assume that these GAFers -- and I mean no disrespect -- either (a) did little/no research with regard to the the actual differences in screen quality and color reproduction or (b) did no basic side-by-side comparisons with a variety of pictures and consequently don't want to think about the question. Either way, they are not the same screen and present images in a noticeably different way. As a prospective buyer, you should know the differences. I'll try to articulate them here:
My experience.
I did both. I researched the differences for a few weeks and spent about 3 hours in Apple Stores doing side-by-side tests with glossy and matte MBP's. I went over approximately 100 images of varying photographic styles. Maybe nobody else cared enough to go through such efforts...but for people who *care* about getting the display that provides the most accurate colors, it is simply a necessity. It should be mentioned that I purchased my MBP in April of 2010 after coming over from the God-like 18.4" Sony VAIO AW 290 line. 137% of the Adobe RGB color spectrum. Perhaps the greatest laptop display ever made (semi-glossy finish), the laptop was plagued with design and consistency problems (rubber palmrest bubbling, display power inverter failing, various repair center-created issues) that ultimately forced Sony to issue me a full refund 10 months after purchase. I still miss that laptop because of how beautiful that display was. It was truly on another level. But the point here is only to articulate that my expectations are high and settling for less than the best accuracy of the two was unacceptable. Anyway...
Answers
To answer your question directly (one that I've answered several times in this thread but people many seem to fail to absorb):
matte is the choice for color accuracy. It resolves its range of colors better than the glossy version of the display. If that wasn't the case, I would not have bought it. Period. The deepest blacks are resolved (visible) and there is little/no perceivable crush or artifacting. These are all essential things for video/photo professionals.
IMO, the glossy version screen was tailored in the same way that HDTVs on a showroom floor are set up to get them sold: they emphasized "pop". The colors are a bit more saturated and exaggerated by default on the glossy screen. It's slight, but apparent. This is not inherently a big problem, as most people do not care about the loss of a bit of color accuracy in favor of more "vibrance". Non-pro users tend to associate higher vibrance with "better" colors, when just the opposite is true - accuracy is sacrificed for slightly brighter, "enhanced" and artificial color richness. It will look a wee bit more colorful when watching movies or looking at photos or some such. It will not be a display you'll want to do your professional graphics work from.
Additional Notes:
Also, the matte is non-reflective. That's a nice plus. Glossy isn't horrible, but I have seen slightly less glare-prone "glossy" finishes. You'll get used to it if you go glossy, so it's not a big deal. Matte features a silver border that matches the rest of the laptop where glossy features an edge-to-edge glass and black border. The glossy screen is slightly heavier than the matte, which I would attribute to the shedding of the edge-to-edge glass.
Final thought.
If you don't need color accuracy, you'll probably be fine with either. But even if I didn't use my MBP for pro photo work, I'd still want matte. It looks fantastic whether I'm working on photos or watching a movie (LED backlit = fantastic contrast that's not overdone). I can take it outside without being bothered by reflections. Personal preferences, of course. You may be okay with the glossy and prefer the slightly more "vibrant" look. It looks great for movie watching, so long as you're okay with some black crush (many won't even notice or will attribute to the quality of the film rather than the actual culprit: the display itself)
If you're still not sold on matte, just go to a local Apple Store. They usually have a Matte and Glossy version sitting next to each other. Take some pictures on a USB stick, load them up in Preview and compare them yourself. Be sure to have some pictures of people with say...dark hair on a slightly darker background. The superiority of the matte will become apparent.
$0.02
(I'm probably going to bookmark this post because I'm sure I'll need it again eventually)