• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Mad Max: Review Thread.

F

Freezasaurus

Member
Hmm.... This might be a case where review scores are going to vary wildly between one outlet and the next. We'll see what Gamespot gives it.

Edit: Okay, a 6. Hmmm.....
 
A

antitrop

Member
matrixman92 said:
8.4- IGN

http://www.ign.com/games/reviews
Click to expand...

"Mad Max is a juxtaposition of exciting, thrilling fun set in a world of disgusting, primal depravity – like a singing telegram informing you of a death in the family, or an ice-cream cake with your terminal test results written in frosting. It’s a conflicting place of despair, a personal playground of explosive action and compulsive, unending progression that I can’t wait to get back to, and one hell of a ride. Mad Max is an engaging rampage through a brutal world of depravity and loss that urges you to probe every ugly corner."

+Gorgeous Sandbox
+Honest, Savage Tone
+Cathartic Combat

– Visual Irregularities
– Repetitive Objectives
 
Y

Yurikerr

This post isn't by me, it's by a guy with the same username as me.
Pack it up guys... the dream is dead.

We aren't going to Valhalla.

Just a reminder to posters that didn't saw the Until Dawn review thread, Polygon review whining is now a bannable offense!
 
F

Freezasaurus

Member
It's an open world game, so we knew there was going to be repetition. I enjoyed Shadow of Mordor for the most part, despite it essentially being the exact same thing over and over and over.
 
A

antitrop

Member
Freezasaurus said:
It's an open world game, so we knew there was going to be repetition. I enjoyed Shadow of Mordor for the most part, despite it essentially being the exact same thing over and over and over.
Click to expand...

Ya, but how many games like this can you play before you get as tired of it all as I am?
 
meanspartan

meanspartan

Member
So 5 from Polygon, 6 from Gamespot, 7.5 from Gameinformer, 8.4 from IGN.....


God damn it I hate when there isn't a critical consensus and so I have to decide for myself whether to buy lol.
 
Dr. Kitty Muffins

Dr. Kitty Muffins

Member
The Gamespot review at the end seems to penalize it for being a Batman combat/Ubisoft quest design style game. IGN, on the other hand seems to either like or not mind those those elements (combat good, quests repetitive). Take from that what you will.
 
I

IcyRhythms

Member
Some of the complaints in these reviews read like they weren't that big of a deal to the critic playing at all. Scores don't reflect that, though. It reads like they loved it overall but the actual score tells a different story.
 
I

ironcreed

Banned
I expected scores to land around 6, 7 and 8. Regardless, I have seen more than enough to know that I'll have a great time with it.
 
T

therealminime

Member
I've found game reviews of the last two years to be highly inconsistent with my enjoyment. I'm going to play this regardless of some of the less positive reviews. As others have said, sometimes a game that is simple "ok" can be really enjoyable in the right mindset and for the right price (thanks GMG).
 
E

EBreda

Member
Hate lreview embargoes that last up to the game's release date... always smell fishy.

In my mind that's reason alone to wait for a price drop right there.

Edit:
Yurikerr said:
Just a reminder to posters that didn't saw the Until Dawn review thread, Polygon review whining is now a bannable offense!
Click to expand...
 
A

antitrop

Member
Dr. Kitty Muffins said:
The Gamespot review at the end seems to penalize it for being a Batman combat/Ubisoft quest design style game. IGN, on the other hand seems to like those elements. Take from that what you will.
Click to expand...

IGN gave Mordor a 9.3. Not the same reviewer, but I'm a believer in "Birds of a feather".

I'm not saying they're wrong, if anything, I'm commending them for their consistency.
 
S

seriosbrad

Member
Not reading any reviews, I just like seeing numbers. The numbers are telling me it's all out of whack and I shouldn't care. Can't wait for it to unlock!
 
F

Freezasaurus

Member
antitrop said:
Ya, but how many games like this can you play before you get as tired of it all as I am?
Click to expand...

Well.... I can stand them more than I can Dynasty Warriors. I can play maybe one musou game out of every five or so that get released. I admittedly loved Dynasty Warriors Gundam 3, but that was more out of a love of Gundam than DW.
 
G

golem

Member
Sounds like a pretty decidedly average open world game. The car combat sounds interesting and I think I'd enjoy the setting but not sure I'll have time between all the other titles coming out this year, maybe in 2016 Max.
 
R

ryan299

Member
Game Informer 7.5

At the end of the day, Max overtook some bases, ran a couple hundred cars off the road, met some forgettable characters, and buried his fist into the sunburnt skin of the villainous locals. Was it worth the effort? That ultimately depends on how much fun you had in performing these basic, repetitious open-world activities.
Click to expand...
 
D

DukeBobby

Member
It looks like GMG were selling it for the right price.

I'll probably get 15-20 hours of fun out of it until I get bored and move onto something else.
 
Q

Queen of Hunting

Unconfirmed Member
polygon marked the game down because of no female lead
 
Z

ZoddGutts

Member
Dr. Kitty Muffins said:
The Gamespot review at the end seems to penalize it for being a Batman combat/Ubisoft quest design style game. IGN, on the other hand seems to either like or not mind those those elements (combat good, quests repetitive). Take from that what you will.
Click to expand...

Ugh Batman combat and Ubisoft type quest design, I can see why this is getting 6's and 7's.
 
Dr. Kitty Muffins

Dr. Kitty Muffins

Member
K.Sabot said:
Wow reviewers finally calling the batman / mordor combat "simple and easy to exploit"? Finally.
Click to expand...

I think that is what some people like though. You either like those elements for what they are or you don't. For those that do, I think they occasionally just want to beat stuff up and do crazy stuff mindlessly without being stressed. Its not wrong, its just a particular play style. I like playing Dark Souls but sometimes I just want to chill and play Batman. I'm glad to have both styles to enjoy.
 
B

Burgess_101

Member
Still tempted at £13, I love the original film and found the new one to be lacking in many aspects but I am in a rather Mad Max kinda mood....
 
Definity

Definity

Member
Ferny said:
Impressions on GAF have been pretty positive. I'll go with that.
Click to expand...

I've played a ton of the game already and I agree the game should fall around a 7 at best. If you still like the assassin creed formula/checklist for open world games you will be just fine with this game.
 
K

kaskade

Member
If it wasn't for MGSV out the same day I probably would've just bought the game. Especially since the PC version is cheap.
 
G

GRaider81

Member
All these numbers and so little sense!

Always liked the look of it, looks a lot of fun. With the PC price it was a no brainer, looking forward to it unlocking.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Life is Strange: Double Exposure | Review Thread
Analysis Review
17
2K
rkofan87 replied
LTTP: Severed Steel
20
834
Grildon Tundy replied
FURIOSA: A MAD MAX Saga | Review Thread (It's Another Masterpiece)
4 5 6 7 8
386
25K
OmegaSupreme replied
[REDACTED] | Review Thread
Review
27
3K
Bitmap Frogs replied
Life is Strange: Double Exposure - Announce Trailer | Releases October 29 on XBS, PS5, PC | Also coming to Switch at a later date
Trailer 2 3 4
192
13K
GymWolf replied
Top Bottom