This isn't going to be me trying to appeal to you, but better than a "gotcha" at the end of the game.
Everything I've said up until now is true. However, once I found out about the role confusion, I figured the best way to sell it was to act like I'd really been screwed and that I was pissed off about it; it wasn't hard, I was a little agitated, I just needed to make it sound worse than it was. At that point, I was just letting it ride out like that, since hounding down Kark plus the outburst sold me as some overly aggressive guy, and I was thinking "well sounds good to me". I haven't been acting this way since around D4, though I suppose people have taken notice.
This isn't a testament to anything, but Tim messaged me about it (I mentioned this earlier in the thread) and asked if I wanted him to modkill me because I was acting so negatively and bringing down the mood. I told him no, I was trying to sell my outrage so that's why I was acting this way. I also apologized for calling him a bunch of names.
Also, not related to the above, but a little to my defense. I was the one who pointed out Roy was probably a mafia tracker and that his role lined up with mine very well. Can I get some points for that? lol