-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Manga News/Discussion |OTC| Delicious cooking not in thread.
- Thread starter dramatis
- Start date
- Status
OniBarubary
Banned
Toriko turned straight garbage after the "Here's a sudden Time Skip and everything got solved during it!"
Dedication Through Light
Member
Haikyuu!! 218
Furudate delivers.
But also the rivalry between Hinata and Goshiki over Ushiwaka and other things, and Goshiki yelling at Tsukishima in the two on two (which should have been longer). Ill miss this training camp.
Furudate delivers.
But also the rivalry between Hinata and Goshiki over Ushiwaka and other things, and Goshiki yelling at Tsukishima in the two on two (which should have been longer). Ill miss this training camp.
Bleach (COMPLETE)
Well it's finally here. What a ride that was, for better or worse. I would give this manga props for at least keeping me reading it weekly like Naruto did despite it's dropping in quality, buutt...Bleach isn't quite like that. Pretty much after Aizen's trolling, the manga really descended into mediocrity in it's entirety.
The Fullbringer arc had some promise to it, but ended in an underwhelming way. It wasn't rushed, and Kubo had plenty of time doing something interesting with it, but decided not to.
The Quincy arc as well also had some promise to it. In theory, this should be one of the most important arcs in the entire series, right? It is afterall expanding on the history of the Quincies. A lot of the foundation for this arc I felt was also a lot better than any of the shit we got in Hueco Mundo. Yamamoto's death was a memorable moment, Ichigo's mom backstory was pretty solid overall, and Yorouichi's ass was the best thing in the entire series. This arc had some redeeming qualities to it...that is, until the end.
Before I get to the end however, there's also all of the Quincy backstories we got in this. Each of the major Quincies get backstories in this arc, and none of them get resolved! That includes the one for our main antagonist Ywatch.
Nothing was ever written to really make sense in Bleach. Outside of some good character design and "cool moments," Bleach has to have some of the most fragmented and lazy writing in any shonen manga. Not even the action sequences are unique, especially compared to series like Jojo which is similar to Bleach in that 99% of the manga is entirely action-based but manages to make every battle fresh. Bleach doesn't do that, and tends to repeat itself.
All the characters are terrible. Character development is non-existent, but rather emotionally change for pretty much no reason other than the move the plot forward. Hell we still haven't gotten a proper explanation to why Rukia became more emo in Soul Society arc compared to her more light-hearted personality in the very first arc of the series. It just isn't good writing, from beginning to end.
The only real character in the series I felt had a strong character arc is Mayuri in fact, but even that is pushing it. At least his stuff got resolved properly, even though it was weird all the way through. Aizen was enjoyable for his trolling, and I like some stuff like Yammy doing stuff. But neither of those have to do with how good the characters are by any means but rather how amusing they are in of itself.
If you like unresolved plotlines, non-existent character arcs, action sequences that repeat themselves, "cool moments" and some solid character designs, Bleach is the series for you.
Final Grade: D-
Well it's finally here. What a ride that was, for better or worse. I would give this manga props for at least keeping me reading it weekly like Naruto did despite it's dropping in quality, buutt...Bleach isn't quite like that. Pretty much after Aizen's trolling, the manga really descended into mediocrity in it's entirety.
The Fullbringer arc had some promise to it, but ended in an underwhelming way. It wasn't rushed, and Kubo had plenty of time doing something interesting with it, but decided not to.
The Quincy arc as well also had some promise to it. In theory, this should be one of the most important arcs in the entire series, right? It is afterall expanding on the history of the Quincies. A lot of the foundation for this arc I felt was also a lot better than any of the shit we got in Hueco Mundo. Yamamoto's death was a memorable moment, Ichigo's mom backstory was pretty solid overall, and Yorouichi's ass was the best thing in the entire series. This arc had some redeeming qualities to it...that is, until the end.
Before I get to the end however, there's also all of the Quincy backstories we got in this. Each of the major Quincies get backstories in this arc, and none of them get resolved! That includes the one for our main antagonist Ywatch.
Nothing was ever written to really make sense in Bleach. Outside of some good character design and "cool moments," Bleach has to have some of the most fragmented and lazy writing in any shonen manga. Not even the action sequences are unique, especially compared to series like Jojo which is similar to Bleach in that 99% of the manga is entirely action-based but manages to make every battle fresh. Bleach doesn't do that, and tends to repeat itself.
All the characters are terrible. Character development is non-existent, but rather emotionally change for pretty much no reason other than the move the plot forward. Hell we still haven't gotten a proper explanation to why Rukia became more emo in Soul Society arc compared to her more light-hearted personality in the very first arc of the series. It just isn't good writing, from beginning to end.
The only real character in the series I felt had a strong character arc is Mayuri in fact, but even that is pushing it. At least his stuff got resolved properly, even though it was weird all the way through. Aizen was enjoyable for his trolling, and I like some stuff like Yammy doing stuff. But neither of those have to do with how good the characters are by any means but rather how amusing they are in of itself.
If you like unresolved plotlines, non-existent character arcs, action sequences that repeat themselves, "cool moments" and some solid character designs, Bleach is the series for you.
Final Grade: D-
BassForever
Member
I mean we all called Hayama being forced into the villain role to save his guardian when this arc began. The only issue is they took so long to get to this point we should have seen him joining central early in the arc when they were looking for people to join their mini resistance.
Bleach has to be the most vicious cancellation of a series I've even seen, taking into account how long it had been running for, not that it didn't deserve it with Kubo's inability to stop introducing new things. It's like right up until the end he was refusing to accept the fact. It didn't just get cut off at the knees, it slammed into a brick wall at 120 mph with no time for anybody in the car to react.
Anyway, feels weird that it's over now. But it was pretty much lumbering along as a shell of its former self for quite a while, so at least it can finally get some rest. I'll miss the fun parts of it.
Anyway, feels weird that it's over now. But it was pretty much lumbering along as a shell of its former self for quite a while, so at least it can finally get some rest. I'll miss the fun parts of it.
Kubo had literally 4 years to finish the final arc in the series. That's more than enough time to cover everything he needed to cover. He just chose not to. It's really his fault. Every other arc in the series ended with a ton of unresolved shit in it as well and none of them were rushed, it was just assumed that those plot points would get covered later...and they never did.
Oh, I'm not denying it's Kubo's fault, I'm just saying that the sheer speed with which it went from "final battle!" to "show's over kthxbye", and the overall non-finality feeling of it all, seems unprecedented for something with as much history as the series has.
Infinite Justice
Member
Where are those vastolordes ice dumbass was talking about
:trollface
:trollface
OniBarubary
Banned
The only good Bleach character was...Underboob McThirdbetrayed.
Infinite Justice
Member
I thought it was a weird case which the movie exposed even more.
You mean to say he still had no idea until in the movie set 2 years after? really, LOL
I know hes an idiot but damn
I know hes an idiot but damn
AlimNassor
Banned
Bleach
KUUUUUBO/10
What a lazy shitty ending. A fitting end to this shit show.
KUUUUUBO/10
What a lazy shitty ending. A fitting end to this shit show.
Rindou is going to be animated?
OniBarubary
Banned
Why does everybody forget Akira hugging Jun? ;____________;
nabe_shogun
Member
Yeah this Central plot isn't that great. But you know its going to go on a while.
Infinite Justice
Member
BassForever
Member
Can't be posted enough now
IceBringer
Banned
Ok what the hell. We never find out what happened to Tier? No Nel in the last chapter? And more importantly no Yoruichi? Dammit
MetroidPrimeRib
Banned
JoJolion Latest
That was...weird. It just kinda ended? I thought it would be an arc like Cheap Trick but I guess we are moving on already.
That was...weird. It just kinda ended? I thought it would be an arc like Cheap Trick but I guess we are moving on already.
Infinite Justice
Member
I liked if but felt it dragged on for too long and I didn't care for the ending. I'd still say it's worth a read though.
Mediking
Member
I discovered this cool place too late ;_; Haha Bakuman is one of my favorite manga and I was hoping to discuss it. Lol I found the Prison School manga too late also...
NCR Redslayer
NeoGAF's Vegeta
You can find a thread pretty much dedicated to anything if you just search.
Mediking
Member
Senpai?!?! ;_; Ahhhh... the Otaku world is refreshing!
Favorite manga so far: Bakuman (amazing character development and witty), Bleach (haven't finished it yet but I love the directing of manga), Prison School (witty, fanservice, love, funny... it has it all), Black Cat (Train is awesome), Ral & Grad (heh), Berserk (gritty and wild), Hmmm... I've read so many that I'm sure I'm forgetting some!
How about you?
I've been reading lots of manga and not posting here as usual. I reread all of what's out of Keijo to get myself ready for the anime. It's still as good as it was the first time through, I actually think I liked some of the earlier stuff better this time.
I think I'm going to let Saki build up some chapters and read them all in bulk. It's in a match with characters I mostly don't care about and it's still going as slow as ever.
I think I'm going to let Saki build up some chapters and read them all in bulk. It's in a match with characters I mostly don't care about and it's still going as slow as ever.
Aaronrules380
Member
I apologize in advance
Mediking
Member
Oh, yeah... hahaha I'm dumb.
Yo, what's Sakic about????
Oh come on! Kubo does scene directing so good in Bleach. The panels flow so well!
Aaronrules380
Member
I completely disagree, but that's not even what I was referring to. What part of Bleach are you on out of curiosity
Mediking
Member
Hahaha I'm on the Arc that started Yahwach or something and uhhhh...
Old Man of Soul Society threw his best shot and got killed... I think.
Saki is about girls playing mahjong. It's known for everyone having a special ability for playing mahjong and none of the girls wearing panties. Going off the other series you like I don't think you'd like it much.
You're not going to find many people on here who like Bleach but Black Cat is a favourite of mine so it's always nice to see another fan.
One Piece, My Hero Academia, Pokemon Special, Jitsu Wa Watashi Wa, Sakura Card Captors
nabe_shogun
Member
umisho 53 - 55
I don't think I could ever do any kind of eating competition. I'd definitely throw up.
Nomi Joshi 16
It is fun to watch them cook
I don't think I could ever do any kind of eating competition. I'd definitely throw up.
Nomi Joshi 16
It is fun to watch them cook
Mediking
Member
Train is really cool... I oughta do a avatar change to him someday. And Bleach isn't well liked on GAF? ;_; Hahaha I love Bleach.
I used to really like One Piece in the beginning....
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Poll