-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Manga News/Discussion |OTC| Delicious cooking not in thread.
- Thread starter dramatis
- Start date
- Status
I don't honestly expect to see him fight Garou actually. I'm expecting some Squirrel Girl style antics where he kicks Garou's ass off panel and we just see the aftermath.
UnemployedVillain
Member
Ugh, I'm about to drop the Murata OPM. It's seriously dragging and I feel like a lot of the recent fans got into the series through it/the anime, and it is completely missing the point of the original ONE manga. All these fights are the opposite of what the series was about. It's practically just a typical shonen at this point. I get it's probably so it doesn't catch up to ONE's version, but still
Just think of them as two separate manga like i do, you'll enjoy it way more.
I'm mixed at the moment. I do like certain parts like the Metal Bay Vs. Garou battle which helped fill in some blanks from ONE's original version and was just an all around awesome fight but I admit a lot of the martial arts tournament stuff isn't great though I did love Genos wrecking all those other monsters and his battles and the resolutions to them matching the fights going on in the tournament.
I'm actually curious what the fuck the deal is with the Monster King since he's not at all from the webcomic.
OniBarubary
Banned
Watchdog Man's whole shtick was seeing him never do anything, only the aftermath of torn apart corpses. Showing him fight and worse explaining it destroys the entire joke around his character.
I do think he's stronger than his rank; I think he's low because he only defends one city and never answers calls anywhere else.
I do think he's stronger than his rank; I think he's low because he only defends one city and never answers calls anywhere else.
nabe_shogun
Member
tomo 438 - 440
Going to the beach, should be fun. And of course Tomo would think the school swimsuit is good enough.
Going to the beach, should be fun. And of course Tomo would think the school swimsuit is good enough.
Yea now we won't look at him the same. the gag is over and now he is more of a serious character to the viewers.
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
If the bonus story doesn't feature Shouko and Ishida's children its shit
shiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiit
UnemployedVillain
Member
Can that even be counted as a school swimsuit, lol
UnemployedVillain
Member
Yeah...but it's the complete opposite of the point of One Punch Man. The premise is you have all these traditionally cool characters who in other manga would get tons of fights and be kicking ass, yet you have this plain bald dude who is secretly the strongest.
It's why Genos is a jobber, and always will be a jobber. He's a subversion of the bishy badass super powered MC who powers up and wins.
It's why we have King who people assume is strong solely because he looks like a badass even though he has no abilities or strength whatsoever.
NCR Redslayer
NeoGAF's Vegeta
Ok I'm not caught but is that ninja guy still a shit?
That's obviously for the inevitable sequel/spin-off.
Tomo-chan wa Onna no ko! ch441
At least she's got the motivation part down.
Jitsu wa Watashi wa ch145
Jitsu wa is a gag manga.
Himouto! Umaru-chan ch149
They didn't burn the house down at least.
Aho Girl ch67-68
So it all started when Akkun gave her his banana.
Car Graffiti JK ch13
Nothing like the beach to blow off some steam~
Bird Café! ch13.5
Teaching a birdbrain must be tough.
At least she's got the motivation part down.
Jitsu wa Watashi wa ch145
Jitsu wa is a gag manga.
Himouto! Umaru-chan ch149
They didn't burn the house down at least.
Aho Girl ch67-68
So it all started when Akkun gave her his banana.
Car Graffiti JK ch13
Nothing like the beach to blow off some steam~
Bird Café! ch13.5
Teaching a birdbrain must be tough.
Stone Ocean
Member
It has no filler but it comes out once a millenia and ONE has no mercy with cliffhangers.
Very, very lighthearted
I always come in to put a Big BUT (not the Zweizer kind) in, which is that rankings matter quite a bit for new series (unless they have special circumstances like Isobee or the other manga that said it wanted to be at the end of every magazine during its run).
I do think people put too much stock into the rankings though. OT got all hopped up about it in a thread from like a month ago I think
Tetsugaku Letra - Volume 2
Hmm... having Fujimoto show up again and makes me think this might end up going the romance route after all, since the MC is now looking up to her from the shadows due to being overly self-aware about his previous hikkikomori ways, which isn't the best development in my book. I mean, I initally expected the two characters to be more interconected, but the first episode kind of made me feel like the girl was only a stepping stone (like his little sister or the former bailaora) in his way to accepting himself and finding a new passion in his life that could fill the void left by basketball after he realized it just wasn't for him.
I also get that he has to drill the basic motions for dancing flamenco, but the illustrator didn't have to drill the same exact kappa nightmare page into us (except for one time that used a different drawing for one panel, even though the dialogue was the same) three times in the span of a single volume.
If I gave the first volume a ten, then I'd probably give this a six, and mostly for the earlier parts where Fujimoto was still out of the picture (if only momentarily).
Hmm... having Fujimoto show up again and makes me think this might end up going the romance route after all, since the MC is now looking up to her from the shadows due to being overly self-aware about his previous hikkikomori ways, which isn't the best development in my book. I mean, I initally expected the two characters to be more interconected, but the first episode kind of made me feel like the girl was only a stepping stone (like his little sister or the former bailaora) in his way to accepting himself and finding a new passion in his life that could fill the void left by basketball after he realized it just wasn't for him.
I also get that he has to drill the basic motions for dancing flamenco, but the illustrator didn't have to drill the same exact kappa nightmare page into us (except for one time that used a different drawing for one panel, even though the dialogue was the same) three times in the span of a single volume.
If I gave the first volume a ten, then I'd probably give this a six, and mostly for the earlier parts where Fujimoto was still out of the picture (if only momentarily).
Aw, why not?
Revenge Classroom Volume 1
Girl is bullied by most of her classmates, with the few not bullying her just looking to the other side when people do bad things to her.
The bullying is quite severe, as she's been raped and someone tried to outright kill her by pushing her under an oncoming car.
Initially she resigned herself to all that shit happening to her but after the attempt to kill her she decides to take revenge on all everyone, no one excluded.
The revenge chain begins easily, with things seemingly going well for our heroine: she gets one guy who raped her beat up and the one she tricked to beat up the rapist suspended.
She gets one of the delinquent girls who beat her up and stole her money caught for prostitution while the other raped. She also manages to get her ex friend grounded by her crazy parents.
Everything seems to go well with the revenge until she learns that there is some hidden mastermind behind all the bad things that happened to her while her ex friend was somehow protecting her (she notes that after she came left the hospital the bullying eased a bit and the guys stopped raping her, but I'd define that a very weak and late protection) but it's now too late to turn back, the event she set in motion accelerate and two of her ex friends die.
I can smell the drama intensifying here, with Ayana, our heroine, possibly getting feelings of guilt after these 2 deaths at the end of the volume.
For my take, this seems quite the trashy story. I'd prefer a full on revenge with no plot twist where some assholes turn out to only be half assholes (fuck them all up Ayana, they deserve it) but I'll take what I can get.
Girl is bullied by most of her classmates, with the few not bullying her just looking to the other side when people do bad things to her.
The bullying is quite severe, as she's been raped and someone tried to outright kill her by pushing her under an oncoming car.
Initially she resigned herself to all that shit happening to her but after the attempt to kill her she decides to take revenge on all everyone, no one excluded.
The revenge chain begins easily, with things seemingly going well for our heroine: she gets one guy who raped her beat up and the one she tricked to beat up the rapist suspended.
She gets one of the delinquent girls who beat her up and stole her money caught for prostitution while the other raped. She also manages to get her ex friend grounded by her crazy parents.
Everything seems to go well with the revenge until she learns that there is some hidden mastermind behind all the bad things that happened to her while her ex friend was somehow protecting her (she notes that after she came left the hospital the bullying eased a bit and the guys stopped raping her, but I'd define that a very weak and late protection) but it's now too late to turn back, the event she set in motion accelerate and two of her ex friends die.
I can smell the drama intensifying here, with Ayana, our heroine, possibly getting feelings of guilt after these 2 deaths at the end of the volume.
For my take, this seems quite the trashy story. I'd prefer a full on revenge with no plot twist where some assholes turn out to only be half assholes (fuck them all up Ayana, they deserve it) but I'll take what I can get.
Yeah that's odd. I know there's no One Piece but what about the others?
Thanks for reminding me this has already started!
I hope they don't ruin the happily ever after from the original's ending..
yay
Jeez, seriously... Your synopsis almost cut me from reading it.
Revenge stories can be entertaining every now and then, but the execution there sounds more ham-fisted than Kinzo Ushiromiya.
Its been a while since I read ONE's webcomic version of OPM but Saitama is not in the series much after he takes out Boros. He often pops in to do something cool but a lot of the focus is on the other hero's until the very end of the Monster Association Arc. There are long sections where he fails to show up and I think that's what Murata's version is basically expanding upon.
Rebel Leader
THE POWER OF BUTTERSCOTCH BOTTOMS
Just saw the rankings and soma fell hard
Strong plot armor and no interesting antagonists will do that. I'll continue to read when he gets expelled because it would mean that there are some stakes again.
A Huge Battleship
Member
Strange Babys 2
Lewd. Unless the obsessive one turns yandere soon, this will be a strong contender for the least entertaining yuri series I've read. The author's aversion to backgrounds isn't helping things.
She's not ready for that, she's not even close to being ready for that.
nabe_shogun
Member
Jitsu wa watashi wa 145
Pretty serious chapter. Mikan needs to come to terms with these things eventually anyway.
Pretty serious chapter. Mikan needs to come to terms with these things eventually anyway.
You tell me
He's rushing everything and still doing those nonsense bait and switch right at the end, how far have we fallen
Three heavenly fodders casually dismembered by eye rays LOL.
Everything after gourmet world never happened except Jirou being badass because reasons.
Also RIP Guinness the rest were irrilevant anyway, like quarter paneled.
BassForever
Member
I look at Toriko's ending as a condensed "this is all I had planned for a better paced final battle" certainly better then the garbage that was Bleach's final battle.
Reborn is the worse, I will never not be mad at the ending
I was duped and thought Tsuna would be something for once.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Poll