Can't have a manga just get to the point in Jump.
Damn the WSJ polls. They are the devil's tool.
At this rate RWBY will be the best non top three comic running on a regular basis.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Manga News/Discussion |OTC| Delicious cooking not in thread.
- Thread starter dramatis
- Start date
- Status
Damn the WSJ polls. They are the devil's tool.
At this rate RWBY will be the best non top three comic running on a regular basis.
nabe_shogun
Member
Yuragi-sou no Yuuna-san 38
And another girl joins the inn. Though when they showed the room layout, there were two empty rooms. So I wonder when the other two girls that are after Fuyuzora will move in?
And another girl joins the inn. Though when they showed the room layout, there were two empty rooms. So I wonder when the other two girls that are after Fuyuzora will move in?
A Huge Battleship
Member
Nanashi no Asterism 5
I apologise for doubting Asakura's motives. A man who appreciates black hair is truly a discerning and cultured man. ... So anyway, he did actually have a real interest in Tsukasa, but naturally that's not the full story. Meanwhile, nearly everyone else continues to keep their true feelings bottled up and then monologue about them.
This explains the strange juxtaposition of Japanese cultural force towards female character in general. Like Japan is not shy nor being stranger to all-female cast show or female characters, and there's hardly bollocks reason of female character do not sell. At the same time there are rampant amount of unnecessary fan-service element attached to many female characters even when it's not make sense.
In the end of the day though, I still somehow grateful of this Japan's approach to female (main) character. At the very basic level it at least make people accustomed to the idea of watching a show or reading a manga that featured a main character from the opposite gender, unlike in Western world particularly US until recent decade.
Yeah Japan always that great recipe for something but always managed to royally screw it up.
FlowersisBritish
fleurs n'est pas britannique
Nanatsu no Taizo Caaaaaaalled it. Also, oh boy... a training arc.
Promised Neverland Haha Emma has a dark side too. I'm so glad, her sugar attitude as a character was a little much, especially in the face of recent reveals.
Kimi ni Todoke 30-66 When I posted a few weeks ago, someone said "you mean that slow manga?" To them, I say, if by slow you mean there is a multi-chapter arc where the primary conflict is "can Sawako hold Kazehaya's hand???" Yeah its pretty slow, but it does things I love in romances constantly and the characters are all just great.
Magi 310 to current Man I love Magi! I don't know why I always drop it for a few months and come back. Maybe because this is one of those manga better read in chunks? Hmmm? Anyway, in the MHA thread i was talking about world building and how I don't think manga in general does it well. Redacting somewhat, Magi has great world building. Hands down, the best I've seen in fiction ie I can see this being a working world. It is everything I was talking about in that thread. And also god the story has gotten so weird but in such a good way! I think this might be one of the most underrated mangas, i never hear anyone singing its praises nearly enough. One of the best fantasies I could ever recommend.
Promised Neverland Haha Emma has a dark side too. I'm so glad, her sugar attitude as a character was a little much, especially in the face of recent reveals.
Kimi ni Todoke 30-66 When I posted a few weeks ago, someone said "you mean that slow manga?" To them, I say, if by slow you mean there is a multi-chapter arc where the primary conflict is "can Sawako hold Kazehaya's hand???" Yeah its pretty slow, but it does things I love in romances constantly and the characters are all just great.
Magi 310 to current Man I love Magi! I don't know why I always drop it for a few months and come back. Maybe because this is one of those manga better read in chunks? Hmmm? Anyway, in the MHA thread i was talking about world building and how I don't think manga in general does it well. Redacting somewhat, Magi has great world building. Hands down, the best I've seen in fiction ie I can see this being a working world. It is everything I was talking about in that thread. And also god the story has gotten so weird but in such a good way! I think this might be one of the most underrated mangas, i never hear anyone singing its praises nearly enough. One of the best fantasies I could ever recommend.
Kimi ni todoke is a manga that pays off the dedicated readers. I still recommend as a manga left read in burst not by single chapters
OniBarubary
Banned
Thanks a lot for the dialogue about my shit guys, it's really something I've been interested in for a while but is a bit difficult to do any heavy research in as articles/essays/papers often focus on other matters in regards to characters or fan-service/there aren't many very good actual academic pieces as it's mostly blogs or whatever, which means I'd have to do a lot of shit on my own without too much back-up. That and any articles or writings in Japanese are limited to ones that are translated meaning there could be some great dialogues about this in Japan that I will just never know about.
YES OH AWESOME, Thank you so much for this dude. This is exactly the article I was looking for. I wasn't able to find anything other than a back issue site where I could order the magazine for $10 but it only listed the larger movie articles and so I didn't know which 95/96 issue actually had this article in it (as I was unaware of the title). This is gonna be a real big help, I'll have to read it after work.
Amusing note, I've watched Jojo anime stuff and read up on the wiki but I never read any of the Jojo manga...except for Stone Ocean. I read it a while back for the shit of it, maybe because I was intrigued by the jail aspect, and that others said it was a bit more...low-key than the other parts. Not like less ridiculous, just that the Stand powers were less super duper strong and more unique and weird.
After reading about other Jojo parts I'm not certain that's true anymore but I definitely think Jolyne is a really REALLY unique character in the continuum of Jojo.
YES OH AWESOME, Thank you so much for this dude. This is exactly the article I was looking for. I wasn't able to find anything other than a back issue site where I could order the magazine for $10 but it only listed the larger movie articles and so I didn't know which 95/96 issue actually had this article in it (as I was unaware of the title). This is gonna be a real big help, I'll have to read it after work.
Amusing note, I've watched Jojo anime stuff and read up on the wiki but I never read any of the Jojo manga...except for Stone Ocean. I read it a while back for the shit of it, maybe because I was intrigued by the jail aspect, and that others said it was a bit more...low-key than the other parts. Not like less ridiculous, just that the Stand powers were less super duper strong and more unique and weird.
After reading about other Jojo parts I'm not certain that's true anymore but I definitely think Jolyne is a really REALLY unique character in the continuum of Jojo.
Stands've always been more weird than powerful, yeah. Part 3's really the only exception, and even that started ending around the Egypt arc.
e: But I can sort of get where they're coming from, Vento Aureo and Stone Ocean is where the series starts going from shounen to seinen, and the tone just feels...I dunno how to describe it, but it feels more "personal" compared to the earlier parts. Nothing to do with the Stands, though.
e: But I can sort of get where they're coming from, Vento Aureo and Stone Ocean is where the series starts going from shounen to seinen, and the tone just feels...I dunno how to describe it, but it feels more "personal" compared to the earlier parts. Nothing to do with the Stands, though.
Thank you for that. I'm pretty behind to the other readers due to the delayed release schedule here, so I'm grateful for any spoilerless impressions that keep me intrigued of what's to come (as opposed to "So, X dies/lives / kills/marries/betrays Y, eh?"). I just finished the Alma Toran arc and it was a delight to see some of the foreshadowed concepts being put into place, although it felt rushed at the end. Another two months wait now. I actually love reading old reactions alongside reading the story myself, however it'd be difficult without an OT.
Nanashi no Asterism ch5
That's as good a reason as any for asking her out I guess.
It looks like it'll take a while before everyone gets honest with each other however.
Mitsuboshi Colors ch17
He totally deserves a statue.
Tate no Yuusha no Nariagari ch29
They sure are good at teamwork and coordination.
That's as good a reason as any for asking her out I guess.
It looks like it'll take a while before everyone gets honest with each other however.
Mitsuboshi Colors ch17
He totally deserves a statue.
Tate no Yuusha no Nariagari ch29
They sure are good at teamwork and coordination.
Sibersk Esto
Banned
BassForever
Member
Love Rush Fin
Meh ending for a meh series
Nothing of value was lost
Meh ending for a meh series
Nothing of value was lost
OniBarubary
Banned
Guys, I unironically like Mai Ball.
Like, really really like it a lot.
I don't even care about the titties and everyone lusting after that dude's dick.
Like, really really like it a lot.
I don't even care about the titties and everyone lusting after that dude's dick.
I don't see what's wrong with that!
OniBarubary
Banned
Grand Blue 16
DEAD
FUCKING DEAD
DEAD
FUCKING DEAD
Strongly considering pressuring wiseblade into doing a daily of this
8 X 11 Printer Paper
Member
Bi-Yearly Tower of God S2 Catch Up 196-224
The Name Stealing arc was much better then the Hell Train, this may or may not have to do with with Eye Ghost reappearing.
The Name Stealing arc was much better then the Hell Train, this may or may not have to do with with Eye Ghost reappearing.
MetroidPrimeRib
Banned
Dungeon Meshi 29
wat
i miss cooking dungeon adventures, this dark magic stuff is sad
wat
i miss cooking dungeon adventures, this dark magic stuff is sad
Dedication Through Light
Member
Food Wars
What? Taku better get the offer to room with Soma. How Hayama get offered first is odd.
Also was so glad Taku wasn't eliminated off panel, and based on plot he ought to have won (no way would he lose to a key antagonist again after that subaru messy writing).
I would actually want for the three eliminated to actually pack their bags. Itd really make this arc feel really intense.
What? Taku better get the offer to room with Soma. How Hayama get offered first is odd.
Also was so glad Taku wasn't eliminated off panel, and based on plot he ought to have won (no way would he lose to a key antagonist again after that subaru messy writing).
I would actually want for the three eliminated to actually pack their bags. Itd really make this arc feel really intense.
A Huge Battleship
Member
I had no idea The Black Museum: The Ghost and the Lady was even a thing, let alone that it had an official English release. Bought vol 1 today when I saw it in a shop, partially because I enjoyed Springald a lot, and partially because Florence Nightingale is cute. Will wait until vol 2/2 comes out in December before I actually read it though.
Dedication Through Light
Member
Toriko
Take-chan having lines in this newest chapter made it amazing. He was so underutilized in most of the manga that he deserved so much better.
Take-chan having lines in this newest chapter made it amazing. He was so underutilized in most of the manga that he deserved so much better.
BassForever
Member
7 Deadly Sins ~100
This reminds me of fairy tale but better. Enjoyed this first saga despite the fact there were no stakes at the end since nobody died.
This reminds me of fairy tale but better. Enjoyed this first saga despite the fact there were no stakes at the end since nobody died.
8 X 11 Printer Paper
Member
Have you hit the power scouter part yet....
Dedication Through Light
Member
Promised Neverland 15
Normans face when Ray just admits to being the traitor is the most hilarious panel.
I wonder if this will get so big that we can actually get Ray spinoff manga/LN novel. His would be the most interesting, him and his lone six year fight to figure out the plan, the sacrifices, and his emotions for Norman.
Normans face when Ray just admits to being the traitor is the most hilarious panel.
I wonder if this will get so big that we can actually get Ray spinoff manga/LN novel. His would be the most interesting, him and his lone six year fight to figure out the plan, the sacrifices, and his emotions for Norman.
BassForever
Member
No they just beat demon hendrickson and the king told the hk to start helping to rebuild the kingdom.
Dedication Through Light
Member
BLack Clover
Another week of waiting for a new Dorksta special move. I cant wait. The dragon was great too. Apart from Stealth Symphony we seemed to never get dragons, now we have one in BLack Clover, I like it.
Another week of waiting for a new Dorksta special move. I cant wait. The dragon was great too. Apart from Stealth Symphony we seemed to never get dragons, now we have one in BLack Clover, I like it.
Dedication Through Light
Member
Ace of Diamond Act 2 - 56
Okumura has great instincts as a catcher and also in rallying the teams spirits. He needs to become captain someday.
Also I loved how proud Sawamura looked at both Asada and Okumura.
Okumura has great instincts as a catcher and also in rallying the teams spirits. He needs to become captain someday.
Also I loved how proud Sawamura looked at both Asada and Okumura.
ColossalLazy
Member
Grand Blue 1-2
I thought this was a manga about diving, instead its about drinking until you pass out. Regardless its hilarious.
I thought this was a manga about diving, instead its about drinking until you pass out. Regardless its hilarious.
Yeah, I can see where you're coming from.
Mai Balls 29
This can be quite heartwarming at times.
Great art, be it the football, the expressions or character designs. Charming personalities and well done interaction between the girls makes the whole cast really likeable. Even Kunimitsu plays a subdued role that doesn't push the romantic stuff too much. In the early chapters I thought the kissing/conjuring and daydreaming would get out of hand fast, but the balance is quite good actually.
Of course the thing with the fan service and frequent bath house scenes might cross the line for people. But you could argue that the easy-going dynamics of those visits add quite a bit to the relaxed and comfy feeling you get from the team.
Sure, there are ways to get the same results with other settings and more clothes on, but Mai Balls makes it pretty clear from the beginning that there will be fan service all over and is quite honest about it, without going overboard.
All in all: I like it.
ColossalLazy
Member
Grand Blue 3
I havent laughed so hard at a manga for a long time. This is the best.
I havent laughed so hard at a manga for a long time. This is the best.
thesaucetastic
Unconfirmed Member
Just poppin' in to say Kimetsu no Yaiba is really good. Y'all should try it out. Unfortunately that means I have to start paying attention to Shonen Jump again, I guess.
Ha, picked it up today too. Pretty fun so far. Refreshing to see people who actually drink and get drunk in manga
ColossalLazy
Member
Grand Blue 4-5
Humor continues to be good and now there is actual diving.
Humor continues to be good and now there is actual diving.
A Huge Battleship
Member
Bakeneko System 2
If I'd known this manga had faux yuri I would've paid it more attention initially. It reminds me of Yamanko for one reason or another. Bakenekos are barely monster girls, but they're still better than nothing / dog girls.
ColossalLazy
Member
Grand Blue 6-8.5
Miss Izu contest was a riot. Too good lol. Also there wasnt any actual diving these chapters.
Grand Blue 9
Dat cakey-san transformation was really something. No diving but more party shenaningans yay.
Miss Izu contest was a riot. Too good lol. Also there wasnt any actual diving these chapters.
Grand Blue 9
Spooky
Dat cakey-san transformation was really something. No diving but more party shenaningans yay.
OniBarubary
Banned
I feel like a lot of humor manga has been coming out recently that is actually...you know, funny.
I'm used to "gets a smirk from me" in my Japanese humor once every 3 pages but there's a lot of stuff coming out that gets legit out loud laughs from me
I'm used to "gets a smirk from me" in my Japanese humor once every 3 pages but there's a lot of stuff coming out that gets legit out loud laughs from me
GoldCrusader
Member
Red Sprite 12
This is so good and yet doesn't show any signs of ending? The battle shots were sooooo cool!
YO!
And that first big boss looks so amazing!
It's not ending people! it's not ending!
This is so good and yet doesn't show any signs of ending? The battle shots were sooooo cool!
YO!
And that first big boss looks so amazing!
It's not ending people! it's not ending!
ColossalLazy
Member
Grand Blue 10
Mixers are serious business lol. Great chapter.
Grand Blue 11
Hilarious chapter. And finally there was some diving.
Also MC confirmed to be an assman.
Mixers are serious business lol. Great chapter.
Grand Blue 11
Hilarious chapter. And finally there was some diving.
Also MC confirmed to be an assman.
8 X 11 Printer Paper
Member
Keep on telling yourself it ain't ending, the manga hasn't once been able to clear the bottom 3 in rankings. It doesn't have the volume sales, nor a popular enough Mangka to save its ass. The one thing that may be saving its ass for another 6 or so chapters (unless the rankings change drastically which is unlikely due to how little the manga's style and content has changed since chapter 1) is the fact that the magazine has too many open spots with only 14 filled (not including Toriko which is gone next week) at the moment and will only be doing a 2 new series for this upcoming round of new mangas.
ColossalLazy
Member
Grand Blue 12
This is totally a manga about diving lol.
This is totally a manga about diving lol.
Dedication Through Light
Member
Gave up reading and commenting every since it decided to go into ending soon stage. Ill miss the character designs. But it just never got as good as Stealth Symphony or Best Blue.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Poll