Pegosaurus
Banned
started reading Bakuman
how does the anime stack up to the manga?
how does the anime stack up to the manga?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Manga News/Discussion |OTS| Yeah I couldn't come up with a thread title ¯\_()_/¯
- Thread starter dramatis
- Start date
- Status
Dedication Through Light
Member
I thought it was a pretty faithful and great adaption. They only cut out one arc/volume in the third season
but it was understandable due to time and it being kind of a repeat of a previous arc.The anime does the in universe manga/anime great, like OLDCODEX provided one of their best songs for one of the best Bakuman series (dont look it up unless you want spoilers), while the voices and animation for one of the other in universe series makes it one I wish were real. Song wise just about every theme the anime did for these series was perfect.
Definitely look into it.
Eh, I dunno. If it happened in the first few chapters, it wouldn't have mattered and you wouldn't have cared for Fuuka. We would've all just assumed she was some tsundere character with little personality.
It's the same reasoning for why the first Phoenix Wright game was the way it was. The victim is case 2 was originally the first case until he was talked out of it. Same goes for the impact when you compare some of Mitsuru Adachi's works (sorta, but even then he does it really really well lol).
Pegosaurus
Banned
I thought it was a pretty faithful and great adaption. They only cut out one arc/volume in the third season
The anime does the in universe manga/anime great, like OLDCODEX provided one of their best songs for one of the best Bakuman series (dont look it up unless you want spoilers), while the voices and animation for one of the other in universe series makes it one I wish were real. Song wise just about every theme the anime did for these series was perfect.
Definitely look into it.
worth it to watch the anime instead of reading it?
my pain is being taken lightly ;_;
no manga ive read as of yet has caught my interest. the majority of manga seems boring now since all of them are predictable and boring. anime is the only thing for me right now that allows me to find interesting manga.
It's Seo, you have to expect someone thing to piss you off to no end when you pick it up. That's just how it works.
ask me how i felt when i heard combofiend say that yun has a hard time getting in thats what i felt with fuuka
Kappa
Well tbh i like what seo did just for the shits
dakkumauji
Member
Soshite, Hare ni Naru 05
I find it fairly interesting we're diving into the whole past we were introduced to in this story. So much emotion.
I find it fairly interesting we're diving into the whole past we were introduced to in this story. So much emotion.
Mockingbird
Member
A Silent Voice 61
A good chapter. I feel it's ending a bit too soon though. Hope it will be a good ending.
A good chapter. I feel it's ending a bit too soon though. Hope it will be a good ending.
Infinite Justice
Member
Boku Girl 30
little sister has arrived.
poor Takeru, just when it seemed everything was "normal" again LOL
little sister has arrived.
poor Takeru, just when it seemed everything was "normal" again LOL
no matter how many times i experienced kimi no iru rage, i never got used to seo BSing his fanbase. he should just draw H so he can stay far away from a constructive story
and even then he might go and eff that up
combofiend is lying and telling us what capcom relays to him, poor soul is being used as a puppet in my opinion until i actually see some substance from capcom. also, im actually part of the group that liked suzuka, even the ending, although it was pretty stupid that he amounted to nothing in the end. however, i remember an extras where the protag actually tries out for the olympics again in fuuka and wins or im just going crazy with my fantasies.
well i actually genuinely liked suzuka too
i mean im neutral at seos works. I enjoy them then just kinda put them in the back of my mind
dakkumauji
Member
Minidura 02
Izaya gets trolled by human relations~
Izaya gets trolled by human relations~
So I was in the comic panels thread and after trying to read some of them, I exclaimed "This story didn't make any fucking sense".
Then I realized I've been reading it from right to left.
Help me, ManGAF.
Then I realized I've been reading it from right to left.
Help me, ManGAF.
Dedication Through Light
Member
Yes, I went to the manga after watching it all.
but he makes the best waifus!
best looking that is, he knows how to do proportions like a boss, just like the other guy in Soma
Its a curse we live with.
Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
I mean, if you want good proportions in waifus you might as well go straight to hentai artists. They do the best proportions for a reason.
Much like tosh.
Much like tosh.
no they dont, its disappointing
Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
Trust me, they do. Some hentai artist are actually insanely good at anatomy.
Tosh is a hentai artist too.
thesaucetastic
Unconfirmed Member
Koe no Katachi 61
They'd better fuck next chapter or I riot.
The best of Ishida.
The worst of Ishida.
They'd better fuck next chapter or I riot.
Agreed.
thesaucetastic
Unconfirmed Member
You should join the party.
And by join the party, I mean serve out the rest of my sentence for me.
Well y'know what, they kinda, I mean, naked people. Makes sense.
We just lucky that Tosh is one of the artist with sensible proportion.
Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
I did say that they do the best proportions for a reason.
I mean, let's be real here, there's nothing sensible about his proportions if you're talking about real life. Nikumi's boobs are about as big as her head. So is erina actually.
I did say that they do the best proportions for a reason.
I mean, let's be real here, there's nothing sensible about his proportions if you're talking about real life. Nikumi's boobs are about as big as her head. So is erina actually.
as long as it looks good and somewhat reasonable
where
It's sensible in hentai artist artist context, which there is far worse than him (relatively speaking though, hentai artist most of the time better at drawing curves and proportion than non-ero mangaka).
Those big boobs is quite a problem in anime/manga subculture >__>
Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
as long as it looks good and somewhat reasonable
True enough, true enough.
Hinako is still the only worthy woman in soma.
aunt is g.o.a.t
That only part is problematic, but I agree with the notion of this.
I don't know, somewhere in this OT. Well whatever, we're ok.
If you're angry at Seo work then he did his job correctly.
Boku Girl 30
Sister is on the OTP wagon as well. She was pretty disappointed her brother didn't jump on Mizuki already. Good for you lil'sis!
I can't be the only one that thinks Mizuki in a school girl outfit just didn't work right?
Boku Girl 30
Sister is on the OTP wagon as well. She was pretty disappointed her brother didn't jump on Mizuki already. Good for you lil'sis!
I can't be the only one that thinks Mizuki in a school girl outfit just didn't work right?
Minidura 02
Izaya gets trolled by human relations~
Even Shizuo got a sexy russian and loli yakuza right? Poor Izaya
I thought we clarified this a while ago? I mean Tosh is the only one.... Lets not get into detail.
dakkumauji
Member
To Love-Ru Darkness 49
It would be terrible if Rito does the one thing he shouldn't this chapter.
*proceeds to do that very thing*
It would be terrible if Rito does the one thing he shouldn't this chapter.
*proceeds to do that very thing*
There's a slight chance that in next chapter the author has already skipped the scene where Nishimiya and Ishida became a couple. I can imagine Ishida just casually throwing a "sorry, my wife's waving at me" right at the end
As fun as Keijo is, you can't reach Prison School levels that easily.
striferser
Huge Nickleback Fan
Touch vol. 1
Very late to the party, but i finally jump in!
Adachi been doing the same kind of joke for more than 10 years, but i can't get mad at him for some reason. This is great introduction for all the major character. We know their relationship. At this point, Adachi art is still a bit rough and leaning more to a shojo kind of style than shonen.
Very late to the party, but i finally jump in!
Adachi been doing the same kind of joke for more than 10 years, but i can't get mad at him for some reason. This is great introduction for all the major character. We know their relationship. At this point, Adachi art is still a bit rough and leaning more to a shojo kind of style than shonen.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked